What are the opening hours?

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm Friday 8:30am - 4pm

Stahlka Agency, Inc.

Home
United States
Buffalo, NY
Stahlka Agency, Inc.

Stahlka Agency works hand in hand helping you find insurance solutions for the everyday risks you fac

The Stahlka Agency has been serving the Western New York community with insurance services since being founded in 1957. The agency started to establish the strong reputation of the Stahlka name that it continues to enjoy today. The Stahlka Agency is a professional organization dedicated to providing the best Insurance products available at the most reasonable cost. In 1995, the Stahlka Agency join

ed two other reputable Insurance firms, the Emerling Agency and the McMahon Agency to form the EMS Group. The EMS Group has distinguished itself as a youthful dynamic group, which has a reputation of a leading Agency in the Insurance Business. With offices in both the Northtowns & the Southtowns the Stahlka Agency continues to grow in response to the ever changing needs of our customers.

04/09/2026

Last month’s Stahlka Spotlight was an incredible evening celebrating the people who make our team so special. The energy in the room and the well-deserved recognition made it a truly memorable event.

Congratulations again to our Spotlight winners—Stephen, Cynthia, Anthony, and Keith—for their outstanding contributions.

A sincere thank you to Giancarlos, Cannoli Carlo, and everyone at Stahlka whose hard work and dedication made the night such a success. Events like this are a true reflection of our team.

We’re already looking forward to the next opportunity to celebrate together.

04/03/2026

We’ll be closing at 3 pm this Friday in observance of the Easter weekend. Wishing everyone a safe and happy holiday! 🐰

03/30/2026

Nothing brings people together like basketball! 🏀 We had a fantastic time last week hosting clients, guests, and our team at KeyBank Center for the NCAA March Madness Tournament. There were so many great moments as both Michigan and Michigan State advanced to the sweet 16! It was a night we will never forget!
#716

03/25/2026

Looking to start your career, but don’t have experience yet?

At Stahlka Agency, we believe in hiring for attitude and training for skill. If you’re motivated, driven, and ready to learn, this could be the opportunity for you.

We’re hiring a full-time, entry-level Commercial Lines Account Manager—with real growth potential and a supportive team behind you.

Real career path. Meaningful work.

Interested? Send your resume to [email protected]

02/15/2026

Experienced service professionals only.
We’re growing and hiring at Stahlka Agency, and we’re intentionally selective.

We’re looking for proven Personal Lines and Commercial Lines Account Managers who already know the work, take pride in doing it right, and want to run with people who hold a high standard.
We lead with our heart.
We operate with real horsepower.
That means we care deeply about our clients and our team, but we hustle. We move with urgency, we expect ownership, and we protect the standard. Average doesn’t last here, and that’s by design.
If you’re at a large national, you may have scale but no voice.
If you’re at a small agency, you may have freedom but no upside.
We built Stahlka for people who want both.
40+ people. Three Western New York offices. Top-tier carriers. Clear process. High expectations.
And here’s what truly separates us: three of our owners aren’t named Stahlka.
People who earn it get a real seat at the table. Not a title. Actual equity.
No private equity. No flip. No surprise acquisition.
If you’re an experienced performer who wants to achieve great things with like-minded people, let’s talk.
📩 Reach out to Fraser McIntyre
[email protected]
🌐 www.stahlka.com

02/03/2026

Now Hiring at Stahlka Agency!

As a growing independent insurance firm specializing in personal and commercial insurance and employee benefits, Stahlka Agency is seeking qualified professionals to join our expanding team. Interested candidates are encouraged to apply by emailing [email protected]

01/19/2026

In honor of Martin Luther King Jr., Stahlka Agency will be closed on Monday, January 19, 2026. We encourage everyone to take this day to celebrate his vision, honor his legacy, and find ways to lift others and strengthen our communities.

We will reopen on Tuesday at 8:30 a.m.

12/31/2025

Happy New Year from all of us at Stahlka! We're grateful for our clients, partners, and team who made this past year a great one. We're excited for what's ahead and look forward to continuing to serve our community. See you next year! 😉

12/29/2025

Please note: Our physical offices will be closing today at 12:00 pm. Our team will continue working remotely and is here to help as usual.

12/24/2025

From all of us at Stahlka Agency, we hope you have a safe, warm, and wonderful holiday season! All of our offices will be CLOSED from 12:30 pm on Dec 24 to Dec 26.

Last Week, the Stahlka Agency team came together to celebrate the season at our annual holiday party! We are so grateful for this incredible team and a great year behind us. Merry Christmas!

11/26/2025

Happy Thanksgiving from all of us at Stahlka! 🦃 Our office will be closed this Thursday and Friday as we spend time with loved ones.

Last week, our team kicked off the holiday early with an in-office Thanksgiving celebration, sharing what we’re grateful for and getting ready for Bills Thursday Night Football.
Enjoy the holiday and as always, Go Bills! 💙❤️

Address

Buffalo, NY

Opening Hours

Monday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday	8:30am - 4pm

Website

https://www.stahlka.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Stahlka Agency, Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Finance Company in Buffalo?