Starr Mathews Agency

Starr Mathews Agency Starr-Mathews Agency, Inc. is a full service independent insurance agency based in N. The principals include James S. Mathews, W. Craig Mashburn, Robert H. Mathews.

GA/TN - offices in Calhoun, Cartersville, Rome, Dalton, Ringgold, GA and Chattanooga, TN. is a locally owned independent insurance agency serving clients throughout Northwest Georgia and the Chattanooga, Tennessee markets. Mathews and W. Barton Mathews. This agency has been built on a solid foundation of integrity, honesty, and hard work. Jim Mathews’ grandfather, James H. Starr, started the agenc

y in 1920 to serve the community of Calhoun, Georgia. In 1953 Mr. Starr was joined by his son in law, Bill D. The agency expanded to include offices throughout Northwest Georgia. As the third generation family member, Jim Mathews joined the agency in 1977 and we are now proud to welcome a fourth generation with Robert and Barton Mathews. As an independent agency Starr-Mathews represents over thirty financially sound insurance companies and specialty markets. Through our core values and these company partnerships we act as advocates for our customers in the insurance market for their various insurance needs. We offer insurance knowledge, competitive pricing, and a commitment to meet the needs and objectives of our customers. The success of our agency is directly related to the quality of service given by our highly trained employees. We currently have over thirty employees who specialize in personal, commercial, life and health insurance coverages. We also have a separate claims department to assist our customers in the event of a loss. Our staff, with an average tenure of over ten years, is dedicated to providing our customers with the best service available. Starr-Mathews Agency is headquartered in Calhoun, Georgia, and has branch offices in Cartersville, Dalton, Ringgold, and Rome, Georgia. Call us at (800) 627-4441 today!

FRESH FACE FRIDAY: Help us welcome Drew Parker into our employee benefits department! Drew has a strong background in em...
08/28/2026

FRESH FACE FRIDAY: Help us welcome Drew Parker into our employee benefits department! Drew has a strong background in employee benefits and is ready to help businesses in Georgia with choosing the right employee benefits plans. Here's 3 fun facts about Drew: 1) Born and raised in Georgia, 2) Recently married in April of 2026, 3) he has hunted hogs in south GA. We are excited to see our Employee Benefits Team grow with such a go-getter!

FRESH FACE FRIDAY - its been a few months but we are happy to announce a new face at Starr Mathews Insurance Agency: Jor...
08/21/2026

FRESH FACE FRIDAY - its been a few months but we are happy to announce a new face at Starr Mathews Insurance Agency: Jordan Wellborn! Jordan will be working in support to our Commercial Lines Service team once she passes her licensing exam and completes training. Here's 3 fun facts about Jordan: 1) she has had a pet squirrel before, 2) she loves reading murder mysteries or listening to murder mystery podcasts, 3) she is little sister to Chynna Moody, who is a Commercial Lines Marketing Specialist. Welcome aboard Jordan!

NEW BLOG POST ALERT - for our HR and operations folks out there trying to figure out the employee benefits world right n...
08/12/2026

NEW BLOG POST ALERT - for our HR and operations folks out there trying to figure out the employee benefits world right now - we are here with 5 ways to choose the right broker https://bit.ly/4wtW259

Thanks to Builders Mutual for taking superior care of our clients and also wonderful care of our team. ❤️
08/07/2026

Thanks to Builders Mutual for taking superior care of our clients and also wonderful care of our team. ❤️

We had a great time hosting Starr Mathews Agency at the Atlanta Braves game yesterday evening! It was a great opportunity to connect, catch up, and enjoy time together beyond the day-to-day.

Thank you to everyone who joined us—we’re grateful for the strong partnership we’ve built and the continued collaboration that helps move our industry forward.

Need YOUR help! Starr Mathews Agency has been nominated in Best of North Georgia for top insurance agency. Please vote:
07/10/2026

Need YOUR help! Starr Mathews Agency has been nominated in Best of North Georgia for top insurance agency. Please vote:

The votes are in… and the Top 5 finalists in every category have officially been revealed! Now it’s time to help decide who takes home the title of Best of North Georgia. Cast your vote for your favorites in all 30 categories below and help […]

Our offices are closed today, Friday July 3rd for our team to fully enjoy the Independence Day holiday weekend. We will ...
07/03/2026

Our offices are closed today, Friday July 3rd for our team to fully enjoy the Independence Day holiday weekend. We will reopen normal hours on Monday July 6th. We wish you and your family a safe and happy weekend. Happy 250th Birthday to the United States!

Congratulations Ben Rebne on graduating from Leadership Catoosa ! Some of our Ringgold and Chattanooga team were there t...
06/11/2026

Congratulations Ben Rebne on graduating from Leadership Catoosa ! Some of our Ringgold and Chattanooga team were there to help celebrate the achievement. The 2025-26 Leadership Catoosa class brought a cross section of future leaders from across the community to grow, serve, and experience what sets Catoosa apart. We are proud of Ben for his commitment to learn how to better serve and contribute. Thank you to Catoosa County Chamber of Commerce and the leaders who led this class.

Address

108 N Court St
Calhoun, GA
30701

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+18006274441

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Starr Mathews Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Starr Mathews Agency:

Shortcuts

Share