1859 Mutual

1859 Mutual 1859 Mutual: Bridging legacy and tomorrow. Welcome to a new era of financial stability.

The holiday season is a time for reflection, gratitude, and togetherness.At 1859 Mutual, we’re grateful for the communit...
12/18/2025

The holiday season is a time for reflection, gratitude, and togetherness.

At 1859 Mutual, we’re grateful for the communities we serve and the trust placed in us to help protect what matters most. As the year draws to a close, we wish you and your loved ones a Merry Christmas and a safe, joyful holiday.

Warm holiday wishes from all of us at 1859 Mutual.

Rooted in 1859. Growing with You.For more than 160 years, 1859 Mutual has stood beside Ohio families, farms, and propert...
09/17/2025

Rooted in 1859. Growing with You.

For more than 160 years, 1859 Mutual has stood beside Ohio families, farms, and property owners. As a policyholder-owned insurance company, our mission is simple: put people first.

Through trusted independent agents, financial strength, and a commitment that spans generations, we continue to protect what matters most — your home, your family, your future.

Learn more about our story and our promise:

🔗 https://1859mutual.com/about-us

Why a Mutual Insurance Company Works for YouAt 1859 Mutual, we’re not owned by outside shareholders. We’re owned by our ...
09/05/2025

Why a Mutual Insurance Company Works for You

At 1859 Mutual, we’re not owned by outside shareholders. We’re owned by our policyholders—the people we serve. That means every decision we make is about protecting your home, your livelihood, and your peace of mind, not about maximizing profits for investors.

Here’s what that means for you:
• Local Focus: We serve only Ohio communities, so we understand your needs.
• Policyholder Ownership: You have a voice in the company’s future.
• Long-Term Stability: Decisions are made to protect you, not short-term gains.
• Independent Agents: Local professionals you can trust, right in your community.

For over 160 years, mutual values have guided us—stability, community, and service above all. When you choose a mutual, you’re choosing more than insurance. You’re choosing a partner that works for you.

Learn more about 1859 Mutual at https://1859mutual.com/mutual-insurance

🛡️ Proud to Partner with Local Agents Across Ohio1859 Mutual is built on relationships — with policyholders, with commun...
07/28/2025

🛡️ Proud to Partner with Local Agents Across Ohio
1859 Mutual is built on relationships — with policyholders, with communities, and most importantly, with local agents who understand what matters most.

We work exclusively with independent Ohio agents because we believe insurance should always be personal, accountable, and community-driven.

💼 Want to find an agent near you?
Use our Agent Locator: 1859mutual.com/agent-locator

Wishing You a Safe and Meaningful Fourth of JulyThis Independence Day, all of us at 1859 Mutual celebrate the spirit of ...
07/03/2025

Wishing You a Safe and Meaningful Fourth of July

This Independence Day, all of us at 1859 Mutual celebrate the spirit of community that makes Ohio home. As you gather with family and friends, we encourage everyone to take a few simple precautions to help keep your celebrations safe.

A few reminders for a safe holiday:
• Keep fireworks away from homes and never allow children to handle them unsupervised
• Dispose of used fireworks in water and a metal container
• Keep grills and fire pits at a safe distance from your home and guests
• Have a water source or fire extinguisher nearby, just in case

Thank you for trusting 1859 Mutual to help protect what matters most. Wishing you and your loved ones a safe, memorable Fourth of July.

Happy Independence Day, Ohio!

Severe Weather Preparedness for Ohio PolicyholdersSevere storms can arrive quickly in Ohio, and preparation makes all th...
06/30/2025

Severe Weather Preparedness for Ohio Policyholders

Severe storms can arrive quickly in Ohio, and preparation makes all the difference. At 1859 Mutual, we encourage every policyholder to take simple steps now—so you’re ready for whatever comes next.

Quick Tips:
• Secure outdoor items and trim back trees or branches near your home
• Review your emergency kit—include flashlights, batteries, and a portable phone charger
• Store essential documents in a safe, dry place
• Sign up for local weather alerts and have a family communication plan

If you have questions about your coverage or need guidance on preparing your property, your independent 1859 Mutual agent is here to help. A few simple precautions today can help protect what matters most tomorrow.

Learn more about coverage at 1859mutual.com, or contact your local agent for a review.

Thank you for trusting 1859 Mutual—proudly serving Ohio communities for generations.

We’ve heard from our Ohio policyholders and agents that managing insurance payments should be simpler. That’s why 1859 M...
06/05/2025

We’ve heard from our Ohio policyholders and agents that managing insurance payments should be simpler. That’s why 1859 Mutual has updated our billing process—automatic payments are now available.

This means fewer missed payments and one less thing to keep track of. Our goal is to help you protect what matters most, backed by steady support from your local mutual.

To set up automatic payments or learn more, contact your independent 1859 Mutual agent or visit https://1859mutual.com.

Thank you for trusting 1859 Mutual. We’re here for Ohio, every day.

1859 Mutual Earns "A, Exceptional" Rating for Financial Stability 🌟We are proud to announce that 1859 Mutual has been ra...
06/18/2024

1859 Mutual Earns "A, Exceptional" Rating for Financial Stability 🌟

We are proud to announce that 1859 Mutual has been rated "A, Exceptional" for financial stability by Demotech. This prestigious rating means that even in challenging economic times or during downturns in the insurance market, 1859 Mutual is well-prepared to maintain a solid financial position. 💪📈

This recognition is a testament to our unwavering commitment to care for our policyholders. It reassures you that 1859 Mutual is a reliable partner, always ready to support you when you need us most. 🤝🏠

Trust 1859 Mutual to be there for you, no matter what. 🔒💙

From our origins in 1859, we've evolved from Woodville Mutual into a leading property insurance provider committed to pr...
05/02/2024

From our origins in 1859, we've evolved from Woodville Mutual into a leading property insurance provider committed to protecting Ohio's homes and farms with innovative and comprehensive policies.

Specializing in Homeowners and Farmowners insurance, we offer tailored solutions to meet the changing needs of our community, ensuring peace of mind and security for our policyholders.

With over 160 years of experience, we've established a legacy of financial strength, ensuring the protection and prosperity of our policyholders for generations to come.

Rooted in Ohio, we are proud of our strong community ties and the personal relationships we build with each policyholder, reflecting our commitment to mutual trust and support.

Address

200 East Main Street
Woodville, OH
43469

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 4pm
Tuesday 8am - 4pm
Wednesday 8am - 4pm
Thursday 8am - 4pm
Friday 8am - 3:30pm

Telephone

+14198492521

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 1859 Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to 1859 Mutual:

Shortcuts

Share

Category