What are the opening hours?

Monday 8:30am - 5pm Tuesday 8:30am - 5pm Wednesday 8:30am - 5pm Thursday 8:30am - 5pm Friday 8:30am - 5pm

Carlton Insurance Agency, Inc.

Home
United States
Warsaw, NC
Carlton Insurance Agency, Inc.

Protecting businesses and personal assets across the Carolinas since 1934 with trusted, expert service.

Visit us in Warsaw and Beulaville, North Carolina, or call us at 1.800.323.3960 to learn how we can take care of you. Based in Eastern North Carolina, Carlton Insurance serves the insurance needs of North Carolina & South Carolina. Let us help you find the right coverage for your commercial and personal insurance needs.

09/02/2026

Today, we received a plaque recognizing Carlton Insurance as a new agency partner in the Selective agency pool.

More agency partners = more options for you.

For an agency built on a legacy of taking care of our customers, this partnership is especially meaningful as Selective celebrates an incredible milestone - 100 years in business.

Selective has built its reputation around strong relationships, responsive service, and providing insurance solutions for businesses and beyond. We’re excited to have Selective as one of our offerings and look forward to all that this partnership will bring to the clients we’re privileged to serve.

Here’s to many years of partnership ahead! 🎉

08/21/2026

🚗 Shopping for Auto Insurance? Let us do the shopping for you.

Instead of getting just one quote, we’re able to shop your coverage with multiple insurance companies to find a competitive rate that fits your needs.

We’ll compare your options, review the coverage with you, and help you find the right balance of price and protection.

07/02/2026

We'd like to wish all of our clients, friends, and neighbors a safe and happy Fourth of July!

Please note our holiday office hours:

🇺🇸 Thursday, July 2: Closing at 12:00 PM
🇺🇸 Friday, July 3: Closed
🇺🇸 Monday, July 6: Closed

Whether you're enjoying a cookout, spending time on the water, or watching fireworks, we hope your holiday weekend is filled with fun, family, and lasting memories.

❤️🤍💙 Happy Fourth of July from your Carlton Insurance family!

05/21/2026

As we head into Memorial Day weekend, we want to take a moment to honor and remember the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our country.

Please note our office will close at 12:00 PM tomorrow, Friday, May 22, and remain closed on Monday, May 25, in observance of Memorial Day. We will reopen during normal business hours on Tuesday, May 26.

We hope everyone has a safe, relaxing, and meaningful holiday weekend with family and friends. ❤️🤍💙

04/20/2026

Today we’re celebrating someone incredibly special to our Carlton Insurance family — Cheryl! 🎉

42 years of dedication, wisdom, and heart is no small milestone, and Cheryl has been a true gift to all of us. From her thoughtful insight to the way she consistently goes above and beyond to care for our customers, she brings a steady presence and a whole lot of grace to our team each and every day.

Cheryl, your commitment and kindness have made a lasting impact, and we are so grateful to have you as part of our Carlton family. Here’s to you and this incredible achievement. Congratulations on 42 amazing years! 💙

04/09/2026

Last night, we had the honor of attending the 65th Anniversary Celebration at Grandover Resort & Spa in Greensboro, NC, celebrating First Mutual Insurance Company and its incredible legacy.

Founded on March 13, 1961, by Graham Neville at just 23, First Mutual was built to create competition and better serve consumers across North Carolina. Its independence from the Rate Bureau allows for more competitive and flexible products.

North Carolina remains one of the most stable insurance markets in the country, supported by strong regulation and leadership from the Department of Insurance, making it especially meaningful to have Mike Causey in attendance.

A key to First Mutual’s success has been its strong reinsurance partnerships, providing stability through 37 catastrophic events, including Hurricanes Irene and Florence. Even its largest losses have remained well within reinsurance thresholds.

Out of all partner agencies, only a few were recognized for profit sharing, and Carlton Insurance Agency, Inc. was incredibly honored to be one of them.

Thank you for hosting such an incredible event and for the opportunity to connect with your team.

04/01/2026

Happy Easter from all of us at Carlton Insurance 🌷💛

Whether you’re gathered around the table, enjoying an egg hunt, or simply soaking up the day, we hope it’s filled with love, laughter, and lasting memories.

Wishing you and your family a joyful, peaceful, and safe Easter.

Our holiday hours are:
Tomorrow, Thrusday, April 2: Closing early at 12:00 PM
Friday, April 3: Closed

03/05/2026

After a year defined by meaningful growth, strengthened relationships, and steady work behind the scenes, one of our proudest accomplishments has been earning a place in the Main Street Elite Program.

This year, 31 agencies were welcomed into the 2026 class, and we’re honored to be among them.

Recognition like this reflects the kind of partnerships we value most - ones built on trust, shared values, and a commitment to serving clients well.

We’re grateful for the partnership with and proud to be part of a network that prioritizes excellence, relationships, and doing business the right way. 🏆⭐

02/01/2026

❄️ Weather Update ❄️

Due to inclement weather, our offices will be closed tomorrow. We’ll remain available by phone and email to assist you throughout the day.

From Duplin County to Wake County, our team is enjoying the snow - sharing a few weather-day photos from our employees.

We’d love to see yours too! Drop your snow photos in the comments and stay safe, stay warm, and enjoy the snow. ☃️

01/30/2026

Inclement Weather Reminder ⚠️

As inclement weather moves through our area, your safety comes first. If you experience damage or need to report a claim, helpful tools and carrier claim links are available on our website.

🔗 www.carltoninsurance.com/resources

You can also reach out to us for assistance as conditions allow. We’re here to support you every step of the way. ❄

Address

103 E Plank Road
Warsaw, NC
28398

Opening Hours

Monday	8:30am - 5pm
Tuesday	8:30am - 5pm
Wednesday	8:30am - 5pm
Thursday	8:30am - 5pm
Friday	8:30am - 5pm

Website

http://carltoninsurance.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Carlton Insurance Agency, Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed Finance Company in Warsaw?