09/02/2026
If you filed a homeowners claim with one of the five largest carriers in the country in 2025, there was a significant chance the claim closed with no payment.
That's not a scare tactic. A Wall Street Journal analysis of NAIC data found that more than 44% of 2025 homeowners claims closed by the five largest insurers ended with no payment — up from 36% a decade earlier.
But here's what that number actually means.
“Closed with no payment” doesn't necessarily mean the insurer denied a covered claim. The NAIC category can include claims that fell below the deductible and other claims that closed without a payment.
A separate April 2026 analysis from Weiss Ratings found 15 large insurers where at least half of homeowners claims closed with no payment in 2025. Mid-Century Insurance Co. of Texas was at 78%, while Lemonade was at 64%.
So the real question isn't just “Am I covered?”
It's “How often does my carrier close homeowners claims without payment?”
That's something Franklin County homeowners should understand before renewing — not after filing a claim.
As an independent agency representing multiple carriers, SBInsure can compare your current coverage with other options and help you understand what you're actually buying.
When was the last time you actually reviewed your homeowners policy?