O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency

O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency You must talk to an agent directly to alter your policy.*** While we do advertise in the community, we believe this is our best advertisement.

O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency provides Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, and Life Insurance to the residents of The Plains, OH.

***Coverage cannot be bound via social media. The O’Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency (OHI) is a full-service insurance provider that has been serving Southeastern Ohio since 1964. We provide clients with auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, b

usiness insurance, and more! We take great pride in the fact that a large component of our growth has been derived from the positive personal experiences of our policyholders. Bob O’Nail, who founded the business as the O’Nail Insurance Agency in 1964, founded and operated the company until his death in 1974. At that time, Ralph and Peggy (O’Nail) Hartman assumed the reigns and have grown OHI into the thriving business it is today. OHI takes great pride in being exclusively a family-owned business. This tradition remains firmly in place as Brent Hartman is now the third generation owner of the O’Nail Hartman Insurance Agency. Third generation Insurance agency providing professional insurance services to individuals and businesses. O'Nail Hartman represents Erie Insurance, Grange Insurance, and many other carriers to handle most kinds of risks.

01/26/2026

O'Nail-Hartman Insurance will be closed today, January 26th. Stay safe and warm!

Whether you're an existing customer of ours or someone in search of a better company, Erie Insurance is consistently rec...
10/20/2025

Whether you're an existing customer of ours or someone in search of a better company, Erie Insurance is consistently recognized as a carrier who lives up to their 1925 founding purpose: "To provide policyholders with as near perfect protection, as near perfect service, as is humanly possible, and to do so at the lowest possible cost."

10/20/2025

The O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency is seeking to hire a customer service professional. If you are looking for an employer who cares about you and your future success and security, please consider submitting your resume! Contact [email protected] or call (740) 541-2067.

O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency provides Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, and Life Insurance to the residents of The Plains, OH.

***Coverage cannot be bound via social media. You must talk to an agent directly to alter your policy.***

We're proud to represent Erie Insurance! Give us a call today!
05/30/2025

We're proud to represent Erie Insurance! Give us a call today!

Erie Insurance ranks highest among large auto insurers in providing a satisfying purchase experience for the second consecutive year

05/23/2025
We are hiring! If you are looking for long-term employment with an employer who cares, please consider submitting your r...
05/23/2025

We are hiring! If you are looking for long-term employment with an employer who cares, please consider submitting your resume. We look forward to hearing from you!

10/12/2022

Local independent insurance agency in The Plains, Ohio has an exciting and immediate career opportunity! This well-established, multi-line agency is seeking a licensed Property and Casualty Insurance professional for Personal and Commercial Lines. Our agency solicits, insures, and services both Personal & Commercial Insurance, working with several carriers.

Our agency consists of knowledgeable, energetic, and motivated people working together to provide outstanding service to our customers. Candidates must have, or be willing to obtain, a property/casualty insurance license. An ideal candidate will be able to demonstrate a proven track record of success and possess excellent marketing and people skills.

Benefits include a competitive base
salary, bonuses, paid time off, health insurance, 401K with employer contribution, and healthy and friendly work environment. Compensation will be based on knowledge and experience within the insurance industry. A license in Life and Health insurance is a plus.

02/14/2022

As a result of ongoing supply chain challenges and a host of economic factors, the cost of everything from used cars to lumber is going up. Insurance companies are not immune to these increases, which means rate increases are inevitable. Wouldn't it be great if you could lock in your rate and avoid rate increases? You can with Erie Rate Lock. Ask your current auto insurance company if they'll lock in your rate (they won't), then give me a call!

[email protected] or 740-797-4685

O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency provides Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, and Life Insurance to the residents of The Plains, OH.

***Coverage cannot be bound via social media. You must talk to an agent directly to alter your policy.***

11/11/2020

Good morning! Our phone and internet have been out of service since yesterday morning. If you need to speak with us and it’s not an emergency, please leave a message and we will call you back. In case of emergency, please call 740-696-0082. Thank you for your patience while we address this issue.

Thank you for business!
Brent Hartman

Address

21 S Plains Road
The Plains, OH
45780

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to O'Nail-Hartman Insurance Agency:

Share