Regan Roth Insurance Agency

Call Directions Website

Regan Roth Insurance Agency Let us help you with all your Florida insurance needs. https://reganroth.com And rest assured, we are always here to help you weather any storm.

Family owned and operated for over 55 years, Regan Roth Insurance Agency is a proven leader in the Florida Keys insurance industry. We are experienced insurance professionals with a deep understanding of the unique Florida Keys insurance risks associated with all types of business and personal exposures. We are confident we can provide comprehensive, competitive and custom-made coverage for your Florida Keys business and personal needs. Our agents are committed to offering personalized, local attention to your requests even after the sale.

🎉WE DID IT AGAIN!!! 🎉 NOW WE NEED YOUR VOTES🙏Thanks to YOU, Regan Roth Insurance has been nominated in not one, not two,...
10/20/2026

🎉WE DID IT AGAIN!!! 🎉
NOW WE NEED YOUR VOTES🙏

Thanks to YOU, Regan Roth Insurance has been nominated in not one, not two, but THREE categories in this year’s Keys Weekly BEST OF THE UPPER KEYS competition! 🌴💙

🏆 BEST INSURANCE AGENCY

🏆 BEST OVERALL BUSINESS

🏆 BEST FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS

❤️ WOW! THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU! ❤️

We are beyond grateful to everyone who took the time to nominate us! As a family-owned business, being recognized by the community we love and serve means the world to us!

But we’re not done yet…

🗳️ NOW IT’S TIME TO VOTE!!!

We would LOVE your support in all THREE categories! Every vote counts, and we couldn’t do this without our amazing customers, friends, family, and community!

💙 YOU GOT US NOMINATED… NOW LET’S BRING HOME THE WINS! 🏆🏆🏆

Vote once every day until November 1st!!

Please share with your friends!

With heartfelt thanks,
Your Regan Roth Insurance Family 💙

https://keysweekly.com/buk26/

A message from Sara Roth:Regan Insurance Agency, now known as Regan Roth Insurance Agency, was founded in 1954 by my gre...
10/19/2026

A message from Sara Roth:

Regan Insurance Agency, now known as Regan Roth Insurance Agency, was founded in 1954 by my great-grandfather, Carlton Regan, out of his house in Lower Matecumbe. In 1958, the original office was constructed on Plantation Key as the business outgrew his home. In 1972, my grandfather, Robert Regan(Bob), and my grandmother, Charlen Regan, joined my great-grandfather as the second generation, significantly growing the family business.

In 1995, my uncle, Robert Regan II, my mother, Catherine Regan, and my father, Joseph H. Roth III, joined as the third generation to assist with ownership, management, and day-to-day operations. With my addition in 2023, Regan Roth now spans over four generations.

In addition to my family, generations of Regan Roth team members have assisted generations of Keys families with their insurance needs, and we even have some members who have been with us throughout all four generations! The same commitment to our community and clients that we had back then still exists today, and we strive to provide quality insurance products, knowledge, and good service with integrity. We are one big family here at Regan Roth and hope that you can take a moment to vote for us as Best Family Owned/Local Business.

Click here to vote:

https://keysweekly.com/buk26/

For the second year in a row, Sara Roth earned the prestigious “Ambassador of the year” award from the Islamorada Chambe...
10/18/2026

For the second year in a row, Sara Roth earned the prestigious “Ambassador of the year” award from the Islamorada Chamber of Commerce!
We are so proud of her dedication to the community with hard work and heavy involvement with the Chamber and the Upper Keys Rotary Club!
What a great achievement! Keep shining, Sara! ☀️🌺

🎉🏆 WE DID IT AGAIN!!! 🏆🎉Thanks to YOU, Regan Roth Insurance has been nominated in not one, not two, but THREE categories...
10/16/2026

🎉🏆 WE DID IT AGAIN!!! 🏆🎉

Thanks to YOU, Regan Roth Insurance has been nominated in not one, not two, but THREE categories in this year’s Keys Weekly BEST OF THE UPPER KEYS competition! 🌴💙

🏆 BEST INSURANCE AGENCY

🏆 BEST OVERALL BUSINESS

🏆 BEST FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS

❤️ WOW! THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU! ❤️

We are beyond grateful to everyone who took the time to nominate us! As a family-owned business, being recognized by the community we love and serve means the world to us!

But we’re not done yet…

🗳️ NOW IT’S TIME TO VOTE!!!

We would LOVE your support in all THREE categories! Every vote counts, and we couldn’t do this without our amazing customers, friends, family, and community!

💙 YOU GOT US NOMINATED… NOW LET’S BRING HOME THE WINS! 🏆🏆🏆

Vote once every day until November 1st!!

With heartfelt thanks,
Your Regan Roth Insurance Family 💙

https://keysweekly.com/buk26/

You may think your condo association’s master policy provides all the coverage you need, but it typically focuses on the...
10/14/2026

You may think your condo association’s master policy provides all the coverage you need, but it typically focuses on the building’s exterior, structure, and shared spaces, leaving gaps that your own condo insurance can help fill.

Condo insurance can help cover:

• Interior features you’re responsible for insuring, such as flooring, cabinets, and fixtures.
• Personal belongings, such as furniture and electronics.
• Personal liability if you’re held responsible for someone’s injury or damage to their property.
• Additional living expenses if a covered loss makes your unit unlivable.

Reach out to us to review your condo insurance and discuss potential gaps in coverage.

The housing market has changed a lot over the years. For many people, buying a first home happens later in life than it ...
10/07/2026

The housing market has changed a lot over the years. For many people, buying a first home happens later in life than it did for their parents. Whether you’re renting or buying, protect the place you call home and the belongings that make it yours.

Give us a call to discuss home or renters insurance that fits your needs.

Address

90144 Overseas Highway
Tavernier, FL
33070

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 5pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 5pm
Thursday 8:30am - 5pm
Friday 8:30am - 5pm

Telephone

+13058523234

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Regan Roth Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category