Benninger Insurance Agency Inc.

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Benninger Insurance Agency Inc. Benninger Insurance Agency was founded with the main philosophy of superior customer service in October 2008.

The Benninger Agency was founded in 1974 by Bruce Benninger and purchased by JMB, Inc. We continue to emphasize our main philosophy of superior service to all customers. Our licensed property and casualty agents specialize in the sales and service of auto, home, commercial and life insurance products in Pennsylvania. As an independent agency, we can insure your Volkswagen Jetta as well as your million-dollar concrete plant and your CEO. We have been committed to our customers and community for over 33 years. Let us customize your next insurance policy with A+ service through an A+ company

Our Company Offers,

*Personal Insurance
-Auto
-Home
- Boat
-Motorcycle
-ATV
-Etc...

*Commerical Insurance
-All Commercial Property

*Life Insurance & related products

Benninger Insurance Company was founded with the main philosophy of superior customer service. We remain committed to understanding and meeting the needs of our customers. We know that each customer’s situation is unique, so as agents, we look to find the most comprehensive coverage at the most affordable price. Our job is to ask questions, give you options, and help customize your policy to meet your personal needs.

Do you know how to turn off the gas, electricity and water in your home? It’s more important than ever to be ready to re...
10/14/2026

Do you know how to turn off the gas, electricity and water in your home? It’s more important than ever to be ready to respond to natural disasters. Follow these 8 disaster preparedness tips to be ready for anything. Learn more.

Creating an emergency survival kit can ready you for when disaster strikes. Use Travelers emergency survival kit list to...
10/12/2026

Creating an emergency survival kit can ready you for when disaster strikes. Use Travelers emergency survival kit list to create yours.

If your possessions are lost or damaged in a storm, it may be difficult to remember all of your belongings. Having a cur...
10/05/2026

If your possessions are lost or damaged in a storm, it may be difficult to remember all of your belongings. Having a current inventory of your possessions, including make and model numbers, may help you recover faster after a loss. – Learn more.

Trees can beautify your property, but during storms, they can become a risk. Inspect for dead or broken limbs, watch for...
09/30/2026

Trees can beautify your property, but during storms, they can become a risk. Inspect for dead or broken limbs, watch for leaning trunks, and keep trees healthy with pruning, watering, and pest control. Taking care of your trees can help protect your home and family during severe weather.

Tree maintenance and care can help prevent damage to your property caused by falling dead tree limbs. Learn more about tree maintenance from Travelers.

Every parent wants their teen driver to stay safe on the road.With teenSMART®, they’ll learn how to handle distractions,...
09/30/2026

Every parent wants their teen driver to stay safe on the road.
With teenSMART®, they’ll learn how to handle distractions, manage risks and navigate real-world driving situations with confidence.

Plus, completing the program could qualify them for a discount of up to 20% on their ERIE auto policy, giving you peace of mind that lasts well beyond the driveway.*

Reach out to learn more!

*The teenSMART program is offered and managed by ADEPT. Only Customers ages 16 through 20 years old who successfully complete the teenSMART program are eligible for the possible discount of up to 20% on their ERIE auto policy. For eligible policies, the teenSMART discount will be applied at the policy’s next renewal following completion of the program and will not be applied midterm. Discount subject to eligibility criteria and rates and rules in effect at the time of purchase. Not available in all states.

Are tree branches on your property too close to power lines or hanging over your house? Fall is a good time to trim over...
09/29/2026

Are tree branches on your property too close to power lines or hanging over your house? Fall is a good time to trim overgrown branches before they damage your home or become a safety hazard. Learn more.

Tree maintenance and care can help prevent damage to your property caused by falling dead tree limbs. Learn more about tree maintenance from Travelers.

A garage door is the largest opening in the home and the most vulnerable in a storm. Wind-rated garage doors can help pr...
09/24/2026

A garage door is the largest opening in the home and the most vulnerable in a storm. Wind-rated garage doors can help provide better protection in severe windstorms. Upgrade to a wind-rated garage door today. Learn more at IBHS.org

A safer teen driver and extra savings? That’s what we call a win-win.With teenSMART®, your teen driver learns how to han...
09/23/2026

A safer teen driver and extra savings? That’s what we call a win-win.
With teenSMART®, your teen driver learns how to handle real-life driving challenges while also saving up to 20% on their auto policy.*
*The teenSMART program is offered and managed by ADEPT. Only Customers ages 16 through 20 years old who successfully complete the teenSMART program are eligible for the possible discount of up to 20% on their ERIE auto policy. For eligible policies, the teenSMART discount will be applied at the policy’s next renewal following completion of the program and will not be applied midterm. Discount subject to eligibility criteria and rates and rules in effect at the time of purchase. Not available in all states.

If you’re putting on a new roof, consider renovating to FORTIFIED standards. Learn how FORTIFIED home building standards...
09/22/2026

If you’re putting on a new roof, consider renovating to FORTIFIED standards. Learn how FORTIFIED home building standards can help your home better withstand the next storm. Learn more.

Address

3055 Route 611
Tannersville, PA
18372

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+15706294200

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Benninger Insurance Agency Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Benninger Insurance Agency Inc.:

Shortcuts

Share