Benninger Insurance Agency Inc.

Benninger Insurance Agency Inc. Benninger Insurance Agency was founded with the main philosophy of superior customer service in October 2008.

The Benninger Agency was founded in 1974 by Bruce Benninger and purchased by JMB, Inc. We continue to emphasize our main philosophy of superior service to all customers. Our licensed property and casualty agents specialize in the sales and service of auto, home, commercial and life insurance products in Pennsylvania. As an independent agency, we can insure your Volkswagen Jetta as well as your mil

lion-dollar concrete plant and your CEO. We have been committed to our customers and community for over 33 years. Let us customize your next insurance policy with A+ service through an A+ company

Our Company Offers,

*Personal Insurance
-Auto
-Home
- Boat
-Motorcycle
-ATV
-Etc...

*Commerical Insurance
-All Commercial Property

*Life Insurance & related products

Benninger Insurance Company was founded with the main philosophy of superior customer service. We remain committed to understanding and meeting the needs of our customers. We know that each customer’s situation is unique, so as agents, we look to find the most comprehensive coverage at the most affordable price. Our job is to ask questions, give you options, and help customize your policy to meet your personal needs.

Good news: your auto policy typically travels with you. But coverage details can vary, and it’s worth knowing exactly wh...
06/03/2026

Good news: your auto policy typically travels with you. But coverage details can vary, and it’s worth knowing exactly what’s protected before you hit the road.

Check in with us if you have any questions. For more safety tips from ERIE, read here: https://www.erieinsurance.com/2026/summer-driving-simplified

06/01/2026

You don’t need insurance experience. You just need someone who does. Get to know us and feel confident in your protection.

Did you expand your outdoor living space? Contact me to make sure your coverage is up to date.
06/01/2026

Did you expand your outdoor living space? Contact me to make sure your coverage is up to date.

05/26/2026

Perfect spring days are made for fresh air and outdoor fun. What activities are you and your family enjoying this season?

05/25/2026

Today, we honor and remember the brave souls who sacrificed their lives for our country and freedom. Know a hero? Take a moment to reflect on their courage and thank them in the comments.

Do you have enough rental reimbursement coverage? Contact me to make sure your coverage is up to date.
05/25/2026

Do you have enough rental reimbursement coverage? Contact me to make sure your coverage is up to date.

05/25/2026

Bike rides, park days, backyard fun. What spring activities are on your calendar?

In honor of  , we want to thank the men and women who served ❤️
05/25/2026

In honor of , we want to thank the men and women who served ❤️

Spring driving = dodge, swerve, repeat 😅And sometimes… potholes win.The good news? ERIE offers Emergency Roadside Servic...
05/22/2026

Spring driving = dodge, swerve, repeat 😅
And sometimes… potholes win.

The good news? ERIE offers Emergency Roadside Service Coverage to help when things don’t go as planned.

A little extra backup can go a long way! 🚗

Address

3055 Route 611
Tannersville, PA
18372

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+15706294200

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Benninger Insurance Agency Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Benninger Insurance Agency Inc.:

Share