09/09/2025
š” We walked away from this property, and hereās why ā¬ļø
The seller wanted us to rehab instead of tear down. On the surface, that might save costs ā but this home is a wood frame/crawl space, which isnāt highly desirable in Florida. The real issue? The foundation was in terrible shape. Cracks in the upstairs walls and ceilings, dips in the flooring, and spray foam ārepairsā instead of real fixes made it impossible to compete with the new construction comps nearby.
When we shifted the conversation to a tear down, the seller said she had two buildable lots worth $500k each. Hereās the problem:
ā
The lot hasnāt actually been split.
ā
Zoning requirements for minimum square footage, width, and depth made it very tight.
ā
A builder across the street just had to tear down a brand new home due to encroachment.
Because of that, a 2-build wasnāt realistic. Our best plan was one beautiful new build with a spacious yard on this corner lot ā something weāve already seen sell successfully in the neighborhood on a similar-sized property.
But when we explained our numbers and why weād have to come in lower, the seller disagreed. She decided sheās going to rehab it herself ā and we respect that decision.
š” Hereās the lesson:
Most sellers see new construction values and think the land should be worth half or more of the ARV. But reality is different. If a new build is worth $2M, it can cost around $1,050,000 just in construction, not counting permits, demo, holding, and realtor fees. Thatās why investors typically pay 20ā30% of ARV for land.
At Stonebridge Home Buyers, we donāt make ālowball offersā ā we make real offers based on numbers, repairs, and zoning laws. Sometimes that means walking away, and thatās okay.