03/24/2026
We've been asked some version of this question at least a hundred times: "I have $2 million saved. Can I safely withdraw $150,000 a year in retirement?"
It's a perfectly reasonable question. You've spent decades accumulating this portfolio, and now you're trying to figure out if it can actually support the life you want to live. The math seems straightforward, $150K is 7.5% of $2 million. But anyone who's spent time managing retirement portfolios knows that simple division doesn't tell you much about whether your money will last thirty years.
The honest answer we give clients is always the same: it depends. Not because we're being evasive, but because the sustainability of any withdrawal strategy hinges on variables that are specific to your situation and, frankly, unknowable in advance. What we can do is stress-test your plan against a range of scenarios and build in adjustment mechanisms that give you the best chance of success.
# # Why the 4% Rule Doesn't Answer This Question
The classic 4% rule would suggest an $80,000 annual withdrawal from a $2 million portfolio. Our hypothetical $150K withdrawal is nearly double that. Does that mean it's impossible? Not necessarily. We've seen it work for some clients and fail spectacularly for others.
Last year, we worked with a couple, let's call them the Johnsons, who retired at 58 with about $2.1 million. They wanted to withdraw $145,000 annually until Social Security kicked in at 70, at which point their portfolio withdrawals would drop to around $75,000. They also owned their home outright and had no debt. Compare that to another client who retired at 62 with the same portfolio size, needed $150,000 indefinitely, still had a mortgage, and had no other income sources. Same withdrawal amount, completely different risk profiles.
The Johnsons' plan had built-in relief valves. The high withdrawal rate was temporary, and they had twelve years of known, reduced spending ahead once Social Security started. The second client was asking their portfolio to sustain a 7.5% withdrawal rate potentially into their nineties. We could make the first scenario work. The second one required some difficult conversations about expectations.
# # The Variables That Actually Matter
When we analyze a withdrawal strategy, we're looking at four main variables that interact in complex ways.
First is age and time horizon. A 70-year-old withdrawing $150K from $2 million faces a different challenge than a 55-year-old with the same numbers. The 70-year-old might have a twenty-year time horizon; the 55-year-old could need this portfolio to last forty years. Sequence of returns risk, the danger of hitting a bear market early in retirement, becomes more pronounced the longer your time horizon.
Second is spending flexibility. We had a client retire in early 2022 with a plan to withdraw $160,000 from a $2.2 million portfolio. By October of that year, the portfolio was down to $1.85 million. He called us, understandably concerned.