Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance

Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance Insurance Agency Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance Agency is a full service insurance agency. We take great pride in providing insurance with service to our clients.

We'll answer your questions, provide you with a free quote, help you with your insurance claim and anything else needed to ensure that you are receiving the very best. We would also like to introduce Prey Benefits LLC. Prey Benefits is a new adventure for Prey Insurance to provide our clients with life insurance, health insurance, and investment opportunities which wasn't available through Prey Insurance in the past. www.preyinsurance.com

02/27/2026

Who's looking for Packer tickets? 👀

We will have 2 tickets and a stamped Packers ball on the Live auction tomorrow night!

Thank you to Prey Insurance for the donation of the Packer tickets and for the stamped ball.

01/06/2026

The winner of the $250 gift card is Gary Malueg. Congratulations Gary!!!

12/28/2025

Visiting family in December? Snow, ice, and long-distance travel can put extra strain on your vehicle and your insurance coverages.

👉 Let us review your auto policy before your next holiday road trip.

https://www.preyinsurance.com/

12/25/2025

Warm Wishes from Prey Asenbrenner

From our family to yours, we wish the entire Shawano community a warm, joyful, and safe Christmas season. Thank you for trusting us with your insurance needs this year — we’re honored to serve such a wonderful community.

🎁 Merry Christmas! If you need help over the holidays, we’re just a message away.

Extending warmest wishes to our wonderful clients and their families for a joyous holiday season and a happy new year.Mi...
12/24/2025

Extending warmest wishes to our wonderful clients and their families for a joyous holiday season and a happy new year.

Mike, Sue, Brittney, Sharie, and Myles

12/22/2025

Snowmobile Season is Here

With trails opening soon across Shawano County, make sure your snowmobile is properly insured before hitting the trails.

👉 Call us today for a snowmobile insurance quote.

https://www.preyinsurance.com/

Life Insurance for the New Year AheadAs you plan for 2026, now is a good time to review your life insurance needs—especi...
12/18/2025

Life Insurance for the New Year Ahead

As you plan for 2026, now is a good time to review your life insurance needs—especially if your family has grown, your job has changed, or you bought a new home this year.

👉 Contact us for a personalized life insurance quote.

Products

12/14/2025

Heading to the Shawano Ice Rink? Drive Safely!

As you enjoy winter fun like the Shawano Ice Rink, make sure your vehicle is winter-ready and properly insured for seasonal conditions.

👉 Message us to double-check your auto policy before the next snowfall.

https://www.facebook.com/crawfordcenter/

Holiday Fire Safety TipWith Christmas trees, candles, and space heaters running, December is peak fire season. A quick h...
12/12/2025

Holiday Fire Safety Tip

With Christmas trees, candles, and space heaters running, December is peak fire season. A quick homeowners policy check can ensure you’re fully protected.

👉 Message us for a quick homeowners insurance review before the holidays.

https://www.preyinsurance.com/

Winter Driving Reminder – Stay Safe in ShawanoDecember roads in Shawano can get slick fast. Before you head out to this ...
12/08/2025

Winter Driving Reminder – Stay Safe in Shawano

December roads in Shawano can get slick fast. Before you head out to this year’s Shawano Holiday Stroll, make sure your auto coverage is up to date and your deductibles make sense for winter conditions.

👉 Call us today for a free auto coverage review.

Contact

11/27/2025

🦃 Happy Thanksgiving from everyone at Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance!

We’re thankful for the relationships we’ve built in Shawano and beyond—our clients, our partners, our community. Protecting your future is our honor, and we look forward to doing so for many years to come.

May your holiday be safe, warm and full of gratitude.

Address

1411 S Main Street
Shawano, WI
54166

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 4:30pm
Thursday 8am - 4:30pm
Friday 8am - 4:30pm

Telephone

+17155262515

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Prey & Asenbrenner Insurance:

Share