02/05/2026
The retirement planning landscape changed forever in the early 1980s, and many people today have limited awareness of what we lost in the process. Before that time, for a much larger percentage of the population, the story was clear: you worked for a company, they promised you a pension, and when you retired, checks showed up in your mailbox until you died. Period. In this situation, the company bore all the investment risk. The company handled longevity risk. The company dealt with sequence of returns risk.
Following the passage of this act, the percentage of private wage and salary workers who received a "defined benefit" pension was cut nearly in half. What filled the gap? The 401(k) – originally designed as an executive compensation supplement, not a replacement for actual retirement security. And of course, in fact, the Economic Policy Institute described 401(k)s as “a poor substitute” for the defined benefit pension plans many workers previously relied on.
What happened here might well have been among the largest transfers of financial risk in American history – from institutions with professional management and deep pockets, who were able to pool retirement risk across thousands of employees, to individuals fending for themselves, with no risk pool, and armed with nothing but a handful of mutual fund options and a quarterly statement.
Suddenly, regular people had to become investment experts. They had to figure out asset allocation, rebalancing, and withdrawal rates. They had to predict their own lifespan and hope the market cooperated during their specific retirement window...
The retirement planning landscape changed forever in the early 1980s, and many people today have limited awareness of what we lost in the process. The Economic Policy Institute described 401(k)s as “a poor substitute” for the pensions...