05/28/2026
The appraisal came in low.
Here's what I actually do about it — and what most lenders don't.
A low appraisal is not a death sentence. It's a starting point.
Step 1: Review the report immediately
I look at every comp the appraiser used. Are they truly comparable?
Step 2: Find better comps they missed
Appraisers work fast. They're not infallible. I've found sales they missed that supported the full contract price.
Step 3: Submit a formal rebuttal
If the comps support a higher value, I submit with documentation. Appraisers can and do revise.
Step 4: If the value holds — options:
• Seller reduces to appraised value
• Buyer bridges the gap
• Split the difference
• Walk away if contingency is in place
I've saved deals with appraisal rebuttals that other lenders would've accepted as final.
Agents — when your deal hits a low appraisal, your first call should be to your LO.
I fight for every number. 📌
📌 Nate Hoffman | NMLS # 2088452 | The Money Store NMLS # 1019 | Licensed MLO | Equal Housing Lender 🏠 | Not financial advice. Contact me for a personalized quote. nmlsconsumeraccess.org
Source: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1 (Appraisal Requirements) | CFPB Appraisal Independence Requirements | USPAP Guidelines | Original Professional Practice