DeWitt Insurance Agency

DeWitt Insurance Agency Free quotes every day! Property, auto, life, business, farm insurance

08/18/2026

When was the last time you checked your insurance rate?

Insurance rates change, and you may be able to save money without sacrificing coverage!

Here at DeWitt Insurance, we work with several insurance carriers to find the best rate for you.

Send us a message or give us a call today. Let us shop for you!

📞 812-723-3810
📧 [email protected]

05/19/2026

Need better insurance coverage without the hassle? Let the team at DeWitt Insurance Agency help you find the right protection for your home, auto, life, or business — at a price that works for you!

✅ Free Quotes
✅ Fast & Friendly Service
✅ Coverage You Can Count On

Stop overpaying and see how much you could save today! Message us, call, or stop by the office for your FREE quote.

📞 Contact DeWitt Insurance Agency today!
812-723-3810

01/25/2026

Our office will be closed Monday, January 26th due to weather. Stay safe and warm!

08/26/2024

We are experiencing difficulties with our phones. We are working on getting them fixed now.

Now that all plans have been finalized, DeWitt Insurance and Springer Springer Insurance are happy to announce their mer...
02/17/2024

Now that all plans have been finalized, DeWitt Insurance and Springer Springer Insurance are happy to announce their merger. The collaboration of our companies will give us more of an opportunity to provide you with the best coverage at the most affordable prices.

This change will not affect anyone’s current coverage, and both Springer Springer and DeWitt Insurance remain open and available to meet your insurance needs. We look forward to continuing business with you.

08/21/2023

Effective September 1st, our hours will be changing to the following.

Monday- 8:00-4:00
Tuesday- 8:00-4:00
Wednesday- 8:00-12:00
Thursday- 8:00-4:00
Friday- 8:00-4:00
Saturday & Sunday- Closed

09/01/2022

Our office will be closing at NOON on Friday, September 2nd and will also be closed Monday, September 5th for Labor day weekend. Thank you and have a great weekend!

06/27/2022

Our office will be closed on Friday, July 1st and Monday, July 4th for the holiday weekend. We wanted to give people a notice incase they have payments due at the first of the month! You can also pay your bills over the phone directly to your insurance carrier during that time.

Thank you and have a great weekend!

Western Reserve 1-800-362-0426
Safeco 800-332-3226
Auto Owners 800-288-8740
Progressive 877-776-2436
Aegis 1-800-233-2160
American Modern 1-800-543-2644
Nationwide 1-800-282-1446
Liberty Mutual 866-290-2920

06/17/2022

Due to the power outage, we will be closed the rest of today, Friday June 17th.

06/10/2022

Our office will be closing at NOON on Friday, June 10th. We will be open normal hours next week. Thank you and have a great weekend!

Address

112 W Water Street
Paoli, IN
47454

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 4pm
Tuesday 8am - 4pm
Wednesday 8am - 12pm
Thursday 8am - 4pm
Friday 8am - 4pm

Telephone

+18127233810

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when DeWitt Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category