03/01/2026
Understanding ACA-Alternative Health Plans
We’re nearly three months into a new year, with a new reality of increased health insurance premiums costs.
Those with higher incomes who get their health insurance through the individual ACA marketplace saw their premiums spike considerably, mainly due to the enhanced premium tax credits expiring at the end of 2025.
Those enhanced premium subsidies passed in 2021, fueled the greatest surge of ACA Marketplace plan enrollments in history. But that party is now over.
So far, the data shows that around 1.2 million fewer people enrolled in plans for 2026 versus last year. But that could drop further as people struggle with budgeting their monthly premium payments.
What do you do if you can no longer afford individual Marketplace coverage?
First things first. It’s important to know why ACA health plan premiums are so costly in the first place. It’s because it’s the most comprehensive coverage you can buy outside of employer-based, or government health plans, that have no pre-existing health condition exclusions.
That was the biggest catalyst. (no pre-ex) the game changer.
Prior to the ACA, only employer based or government health plans accepted enrollees regardless of health.
Everything else in the individual private insurance market, except for some very limited benefits plans, require health underwriting prior to being accepted.
So, what do you do if you don’t have access to employer based or government health plans and have pre-existing conditions that may prevent you from buying health insurance?
If you can afford it, ACA is the only way if you want comprehensive health insurance without pre-existing health condition exclusions.
But what if you’re priced out of the ACA Marketplace?
There are more affordable non-insurance options such as Health Sharing plans that will accept you with a waiting period for certain pre-existing conditions.
During the waiting period, you’ll have to learn how to navigate and manage your conditions as an uninsured cash payer. Thankfully there are price transparency tools online that can help with this.
For example, FAIR Health has online tools that help you estimate your healthcare expenses by procedure with both out of network/uninsured and in-network/insured prices.
You can often save significantly on healthcare costs with a cash payer rate versus the inflated rates insurance carriers are forced to pay.
I recommend also joining a Direct Primary Care Clinic. These are membership-based practices that provide ongoing medical care for a flat monthly fee.
There are even Direct Specialty Care that focus on specific medical specialties rather than general primary care.
The Direct Primary & Specialty Care movement is growing in response to more people choosing not to participate in the traditional health insurance market or are forced out due to unaffordable premiums.
But for those who are relatively healthy, there are several options in the private insurance market that are often more affordable than ACA Marketplace plans.
Let’s dive into the most common type of ACA alternative health plans available in the private market.
Comprehensive Major Medical
Do you lead a healthy lifestyle? Are you open to a part time job or side hustle? If so, there are Comprehensive Major Medical health benefits available for individuals who qualify to become consumer data survey respondents for organizations involved in the population health management and data research field. By becoming an employee or working owner, who contributes by completing a few surveys a month about your healthy lifestyle, you get access to the organization's group health plan.
Short Term Medical
Short Term Medical plans offer temporary health coverage for up to twelve months depending on your state’s rules. These plans generally cost less than traditional health insurance, and coverage can begin as soon as the following day. Benefits may be more limited compared to major medical though, especially for preventative care, maternity, or mental health, so it’s important to understand what your policy covers, and what it excludes.
Fixed Indemnity Plans
Limited Benefit Fixed Indemnity plans pay a fixed dollar amount per day, service, or visit when you experience certain medical events that are specified in the policy. For example, you might receive a fixed payment for a doctor’s visit, a hospital stay, or a specific procedure. These payments go directly to you, not the provider, and you can use the money however you choose. Since benefits are fixed, you know exactly what the plan will pay for each covered event. These plans are typically more affordable than comprehensive health insurance, however, it’s important to know that the fixed payments rarely come close to covering the full cost of serious medical care. A major hospitalization, chronic condition, or emergency can still leave you with substantial expenses. That’s why these plans should be considered supplemental, and not primary health insurance. But if the price of primary health insurance is out of reach for you, what can you do?
Health Sharing Plans
As healthcare costs continue to rise, many individuals and families are exploring alternatives to traditional health insurance. One option gaining attention is health sharing plans which are community-based programs where members contribute monthly amounts to help cover one another’s medical expenses.
At their core, health sharing plans function as a cost-sharing arrangement. Members pay a monthly “share” into a collective pool. When someone has an eligible medical need, funds from other members are used to help pay the bill. Instead of insurance companies, most plans are run by nonprofit organizations guided by shared values or lifestyle commitments.
Many people find health-sharing plans more affordable than traditional premiums. Members often appreciate the sense of contributing directly to others in need. Some plans offer freedom in choosing healthcare providers.
It’s important to consider that health sharing plans are not insurance. They’re not legally required to cover pre-existing conditions, preventive care, or certain treatments. Because payments are voluntary contributions, and not legally guaranteed benefits, there’s always a degree of risk. Additionally, many plans require members to adhere to specific lifestyle or belief standards.
For people seeking lower monthly costs and who are comfortable with the structure and values of these programs, health-sharing plans can provide meaningful financial support. However, anyone considering them should read the guidelines carefully and understand what is and isn’t covered.
Well… there you have it. Outside of job-based coverage, and government, such as the ACA Marketplace, Medicare, or Medicaid, your options for individual health plans in the private market are going to be limited to the types of plans I just laid out for you.
I’ll be covering these options in more detail in future posts. In the meantime, if you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment or reach out to me directly.