07/22/2026
DID YOU KNOW that the Sanibel Tomato Pickers baseball team, named after the Island’s most famous crop, was the pride of the young community? In 1910, the team’s historical milestone came when they captured the Caloosahatchee Valley Baseball Championship (1910 Team Pictured).
One standout player was Will Reed, who served as the Sanibel Postmaster for 40 years. Another player, Pete Jenny, had his life forever changed when he hit another player in the head with a ball. Thinking that he had killed the man, Jenny fled Sanibel and kept running until he reached Alaska. Forty years later, he learned that the man had just been unconscious. “Uncle Pete” returned to SW Florida, living in a small trailer in Bonita near the Gulf for the rest of his days.
Read more about Pete Jenny's story, along with many others, in "Once Upon the Island Known as Sanibel," co-authored by Betty Anholt and Charles LeBuff.
Photo Credit: Sanibel Public Library