1st Choice Insurance

Call Directions Website Contact the business

1st Choice Insurance Protecting what matters most since 1897!

We offer free quotes on personal, farm & business insurance with offices in North Judson and Knox, Indiana.

➡️ Learn more at 1stChoiceInsurance.net 1st Choice Insurance Services provides auto insurance, homeowners insurance, commercial insurance, life, health and group insurance in North Judson, IN.

I wanted to share this beautiful message I received today from a friend and 1st choice client. I appreciate her kind wo...
09/03/2026

I wanted to share this beautiful message I received today from a friend and 1st choice client. I appreciate her kind words so much. I really want to show my appreciation to our Wonderful Staff. They care deeply for people and work hard for our clients.

I appreciate their hard work and dedication while I am home recovering.

Thank you Lisa, Patti, Sara, Brittany, Megan, Jamie, Noah, and Haley. You all are #1!

08/11/2026

Storm season is still upon on us. With that being said, we hope everyone is safe after the storms that hit us yesterday and today.

If you have damage or think you may have damage here are some tips & steps to take:
• take necessary steps to prevent any additional damage such as putting a tarp on roofs or areas that have been exposed.
• take pictures of the damaged areas
• call us at our North Judson or Knox office to inform us of your damage
• Please remember if you are contacted by a contractor, you are not required to sign a contract for an estimate.

If you are in need of a licensed, bonded and insured contractor, we have list of recommendations.

We are here for you when you need us the most!

It’s Independence Day! In the midst of all the barbeques, firecrackers, and sunshine, take a moment to honor the men and...
07/04/2026

It’s Independence Day!

In the midst of all the barbeques, firecrackers, and sunshine, take a moment to honor the men and women who fought and continue to fight for the freedom that we’re celebrating.

We’d also like to thank you—for supporting small businesses like ours. We hope you all have a safe and fun weekend ❤️🇺🇸🎆💙

Team members celebrated alongside us at the Erie Annual Branch meeting in Indiana, where we were honored with the Commer...
06/04/2026

Team members celebrated alongside us at the Erie Annual Branch meeting in Indiana, where we were honored with the Commercial Lines District Sales Award for 2026. We are thankful for the support of our customers. With new insights into Erie's upcoming changes, we look forward to a productive remainder of the year.

Celebrating Lisa and her amazing career in insurance. Lisa joined our agency in June, 1986.40 years dedicated to insura...
06/02/2026

Celebrating Lisa and her amazing career in insurance.
Lisa joined our agency in June, 1986.
40 years dedicated to insurance and assisting so many clients, family, and friends with their insurance needs.
Congratulations Lisa, we are so grateful for you!
👏🍾💐🎉💕🥰

03/11/2026

To our insureds. If you have sustained damage. You can take necessary measure to secure your property from further damage. Just keep track of any expenses and it will get reimbursed during the claims process.
If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to call us. 574-806-4927 or 5624. Stay safe.

03/11/2026

As the storm passes through our area, we are already getting reports of severe damage.

If you have a claim that needs report immediately due to severe damage, please text or call 574-806-5624.

Our offices will all be open at 7 AM Wednesday to assist each and everyone of you.

We are praying that everyone is safe and continue to be safe through the rest of the evening!

01/30/2026

We’d love to breakdown your policy for you! Bring it on over for a free quote!

A sweet reminder that during the hard times being kind and going the extra mile makes a difference. We truly enjoy worki...
01/27/2026

A sweet reminder that during the hard times being kind and going the extra mile makes a difference. We truly enjoy working with our clients everyday 💛

Address

4975 W State Road 10
North Judson, IN
46366

Opening Hours

Monday 7:30am - 4pm
Tuesday 7:30am - 4pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 4pm
Thursday 7:30am - 4pm
Friday 7:30am - 4pm

Telephone

+15748963482

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 1st Choice Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to 1st Choice Insurance:

Shortcuts

Share

Category