Madison-Collins-Stephens Insurance Agency

Directions Website

Madison-Collins-Stephens Insurance Agency Your local leader for all of your insurance needs! Once a client, your service needs will be a top priority. Contact us for a free quote.

Let us shop the rates for you as we provide competitive policies for Home, Auto, Business, Life and Health Insurance. Established in 1957, we are a full service and locally owned independent insurance agency with offices in Newark, Ohio and Mount Vernon, Ohio with clients all across the state and the country. We have the expertise to tailor specific coverage’s to each and every client that we insure. We represent many top line insurance companies which allows us to shop the insurance marketplace for you. We work to provide our clients the coverage they need, at the lowest available premium. All of our clients are treated with the knowledge that their time is extremely important. We strive to offer the best possible service and to develop a one-on-one personal relationship with all of our customers. After more than 50 years, our professional staff continues the tradition of quality service. Madison-Collins-Stephens has insurance agents licensed for all lines of coverage including auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life, heath and business insurance. We would like to provide you with a no-cost, no-obligation insurance review. Please contact us for all your insurance needs.

REAL EXPERIENCES. REAL RELATIONSHIPS.Choosing an insurance agency is about more than finding a policy. It’s about having...
10/20/2026

REAL EXPERIENCES. REAL RELATIONSHIPS.
Choosing an insurance agency is about more than finding a policy. It’s about having people you can reach, questions you can ask, and a team that takes time to understand what matters to you.

Here’s what a client recently shared about Madison Collins Stephens Agency:
“Mike is the best! I’m always busy and running around trying to keep myself together and Mike is always there to make sure he keeps me on track with all of my Insurance needs! I recommend MCS agency to all my friends and family for their insurance. I know they’ve all saved money by switching and they all enjoy working with Mike B!” Alisa W

We’re grateful for every client who trusts us with their home, business, family, and future.

🎃 WHO'S READY FOR SOME FALL FUN?! 🎃We are! And as proud sponsors of the Licking County Fall Festival & TreatFest, we wan...
10/16/2026

🎃 WHO'S READY FOR SOME FALL FUN?! 🎃

We are! And as proud sponsors of the Licking County Fall Festival & TreatFest, we want to make sure you have this one on your calendar!

Join us Sunday, October 18, from 1–4 PM at the Canal Market District for one BIG afternoon of family fun.

Think you can fit all of this into one afternoon? 👇
🎃 Pick out a pumpkin
🍬 Go trick-or-treating
👻 Dress up for the costume contest
🎪 Play carnival games
🐴 Take a hayride
🐐 Visit the petting zoo
🏰 Bounce, play & explore the Fun Zone
🎭 Meet Bingo and Pikachu
🎈 Get your face painted
🍿 Grab something from a food or treat truck
🏆 Enter contests and win prizes

And that's just the beginning!

Space is limited for some registration options, so don't wait to register.
📅 Sunday, October 18 | 1–4 PM
📍 Canal Market District, Newark

We’re proud to support events that bring families and our community together. Come join the fun! ❤️

👉 Register: https://www.kidslinked.com/Home/CalendarEvent/11357

MEET THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE POLICYMeet Leda Anderson! Leda has been part of the Madison Collins Stephens Agency team for ...
10/14/2026

MEET THE PEOPLE BEHIND THE POLICY

Meet Leda Anderson!

Leda has been part of the Madison Collins Stephens Agency team for 22 years.

We asked her: What's your favorite part of working with our clients?

“With the rising cost of insurance, it truly makes my heart happy when I can help a client save money.

Whether it’s making changes to their current policy or finding a new insurance company with better rates, I love being able to find ways to help my clients keep more money in their pockets.

Helping people protect what matters most while also saving them money is one of the most rewarding parts of what I do!”

Insurance is about policies, but it's also about people. We're proud of the people who make MCS what it is.


REAL CLIENTS. REAL EXPERIENCES. ❤️There's a lot we can say about Madison Collins Stephens Agency, but sometimes the best...
10/13/2026

REAL CLIENTS. REAL EXPERIENCES. ❤️

There's a lot we can say about Madison Collins Stephens Agency, but sometimes the best way to tell our story is to let our clients do the talking.

Here's what one of our clients recently shared:

"I was having trouble getting some specific insurance needs met and Tim made short work of my issues with previous providers, bringing me fast effective insurance solutions. I had one necessary tweak on my final form to formalize the policy and Tim responded to my questions despite being on vacation! Top notch service and expertise, I'd recommend them in a heartbeat.” Christopher J.

We don't take your trust for granted. For more than 70 years, we've built our business around experience, integrity, honesty, and attentive service.

Thank you for choosing MCS and for taking the time to share your experience!

1955 TO TODAYA lot has changed since then. Technology has changed. Vehicles have changed. Homes have changed. Businesses...
10/09/2026

1955 TO TODAY

A lot has changed since then. Technology has changed. Vehicles have changed. Homes have changed. Businesses have changed.
And the insurance industry has changed.

One thing hasn't: Our commitment to our clients.

For more than 70 years, Madison Collins Stephens Agency has been helping people protect what matters most.

🎃🍂 WE’RE PROUD TO BE A SPONSOR! 🍂🎃Madison Collins Stephens Agency is proud to sponsor the 8th Annual Licking County Fall...
10/07/2026

🎃🍂 WE’RE PROUD TO BE A SPONSOR! 🍂🎃

Madison Collins Stephens Agency is proud to sponsor the 8th Annual Licking County Fall Festival & TreatFest, and we’d love to see you there!

Join us Sunday, October 18, from 1–4 PM at the Canal Market District in Newark for an afternoon packed with family fun! ❤️

There will be:
🎃 Pumpkins
👻 Costume contests
🍬 Trick-or-treating
🎭 Character meet & treats
🎪 Bounce houses & carnival games
🐴 Hayrides, a petting zoo & pony rides
🎈 Face painting & balloon artists
🍿 Food & treat trucks
🏆 Games, contests & prizes
…and SO much more!

Best of all, it’s a FREE family event, with additional activities and passes available.

📍 Canal Market District
📅 Sunday, October 18
⏰ 1–4 PM

Register early and bring the whole family! We hope to see you there! 🎃🍂
👉 Register: https://www.kidslinked.com/Home/CalendarEvent/11357

10/06/2026

More Than a Policy

A good insurance relationship should be about more than handing you a policy and sending you on your way.

It's about:
Listening.
Understanding.
Explaining.
Advising.
Being there.

Since 1955, Madison Collins Stephens Agency has focused on building long-lasting relationships with the people and businesses we serve.

That's what insurance should feel like.

Protect What Matters Your home.Your vehicle.Your business.Your family.Your future.Insurance is ultimately about protecti...
10/01/2026

Protect What Matters

Your home.
Your vehicle.
Your business.
Your family.
Your future.

Insurance is ultimately about protecting the things you've worked hard to build.

At Madison Collins Stephens Agency, our goal is simple: understand what's important to you and help you find insurance solutions designed around your needs.

Because peace of mind starts with knowing you're protected.

TESTIMONIAL TUESDAY! ⭐We can tell you we're experienced. We can tell you we're independent. We can tell you we care abou...
09/29/2026

TESTIMONIAL TUESDAY! ⭐

We can tell you we're experienced. We can tell you we're independent. We can tell you we care about our clients.

But honestly, we'd rather let our clients tell you.

Here's what one of our customers had to say about their experience with Madison Collins Stephens Agency:

"Absolutely best customer service anyone could ask for! Beyond expectations in every way, Ryan was extremely helpful and not only were the policies better with coverage, but also cheaper! I highly recommend anyone looking for any type of coverage to look into Erie insurance and ask for Ryan!!" Jesse F.

We are incredibly grateful when our clients take the time to share their experiences. Your trust means everything to us, and we're proud to have been serving our clients since 1955.

Thank you for trusting Madison Collins Stephens Agency! ❤️

09/25/2026

LIFE INSURANCE AWARENESS MONTH ❤️

September is a great reminder to take a closer look at something many people don't think about until it's too late: life insurance.

Life insurance can help provide financial protection for the people who depend on you, helping with expenses, income replacement, debts, education, and other financial needs if you're no longer there to provide for them.

Your coverage should reflect your life as it is today. Marriage, children, a new home, a growing business, or other major life changes can all be good reasons to review your policy.

At Madison Collins Stephens Agency, we believe insurance should be built around your needs, with guidance you can trust. If it's been a while since you've reviewed your life insurance coverage, we're happy to help you start the conversation.

Because protecting what matters most starts with planning ahead. ❤️

Address

10 E Locust Street
Newark, OH
43055

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Madison-Collins-Stephens Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category