Nikki Carter Insurance Agency

Nikki Carter Insurance Agency Your locally owned and operated independent insurance agency with access to the top carriers special

Founded by Nikki Warren Carter, an experienced insurance professional since 2008, our agency was built on one simple belief: every client deserves options. After starting her career with one of the nation’s largest captive carriers, Nikki saw the power of independence—being able to shop multiple companies to find the right coverage at the right value. As a lifelong resident of Claiborne County and

proud alumna of Lincoln Memorial University, Nikki understands the unique needs of her community. She is committed to building long-term relationships with her clients by listening, educating, and tailoring insurance solutions as life evolves. Beyond the agency, Nikki is a wife, mom of three, and the owner/competition team cheerleading coach at CG Elite Athletics in Harrogate, TN. At Nikki Carter Insurance Agency, our mission is simple: protect what matters most to you with honesty, expertise, and exceptional service.

Happy Easter!
04/05/2026

Happy Easter!

03/30/2026

Nikki Carter Insurance Agency will be closed Friday, April 3rd, 2026 in observance of Good Friday.

We hope everyone has a Happy Easter!

We are incredibly grateful for the growth and referrals we’ve received recently. Our agency is experiencing one of the b...
02/24/2026

We are incredibly grateful for the growth and referrals we’ve received recently. Our agency is experiencing one of the busiest seasons we’ve ever had.

High demand is a blessing — but quality service will always come before speed for us.

For personal lines quotes, please allow 24–48 business hours for review and underwriting.
Commercial and farm quotes are currently running approximately one to two weeks due to underwriting requirements and carrier response times.

If you haven’t heard from us within those timeframes, a quick call or text to the office ensures nothing was missed.

We truly appreciate your patience and your trust in our agency. 💙

02/13/2026
With road conditions still uncertain, Nikki Carter Insurance Agency is operating remotely so everyone stays safe.We’re s...
02/03/2026

With road conditions still uncertain, Nikki Carter Insurance Agency is operating remotely so everyone stays safe.

We’re still just a call, text, or email away:
📞📱 423-626-3221

📧 [email protected]

01/26/2026

Safety first today ❄️

We’re working remotely due to road conditions, but we’re still here for you by phone, text, and email.

The only thing we can’t handle today is walk-ins.

Thank you!

01/26/2026

Safety first today ❄️

We’re working remotely due to road conditions, but we’re still here for you by phone, text, and email.

The only thing we can’t handle today is walk-ins.

Wishing you a merry and blessed Christmas from Nikki Carter Insurance Agency!
12/25/2025

Wishing you a merry and blessed Christmas from Nikki Carter Insurance Agency!

🎄 Holiday Office Hours Update 🎄In observance of the Christmas holiday, our office will be closed on:📅 Christmas Eve – De...
12/19/2025

🎄 Holiday Office Hours Update 🎄

In observance of the Christmas holiday, our office will be closed on:

📅 Christmas Eve – December 24
📅 Christmas Day – December 25
📅 Friday – December 26

This time allows our agent and team to enjoy the holiday with their families.

✨ Monday, December 29 & Tuesday, December 30
Our office will be open by appointment only, but we will still be available to assist you via text, email, and phone.

🚨 Emergent Claims
If you experience an emergency claim while we are closed, please contact your insurance carrier’s claims department directly — visiting the carrier’s website is the quickest way to file a claim, or you may call their claims phone number.

📧 Service Requests
For policy changes or non-urgent needs, please email us at:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]

We will respond as soon as possible when the office reopens.

🎁 We are grateful for your trust and wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a safe, happy holiday season!

— Nikki Carter Insurance Agency

12/04/2025

Our for December is Nikki Carter Insurance Agency in New Tazewell!

They are an independent and local agency that will use their expertise in the insurance industry and consult with you on the insurance needs you have. Then they'll do the "shopping" for you!

Learn more about them at nikkicarterinsurance.com

Address

405 North Broad Street
New Tazewell, TN
37825

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nikki Carter Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Nikki Carter Insurance Agency:

Shortcuts

Share

Category