01/09/2025
The takeaway from this video is the hard truth. California does not allow carriers to properly charge for risk and thus their market is not competitive. Carriers have been pulling out of the state/fire prone areas b/c they cannot charge the appropriate rate.
It is counter-intuitive to a point - insurance is a regulated industry, but the regulators believe they are re-elected by grandstanding and artificially suppressing rates. However, in the real world aka the free market, the public is better off with a competitive environment with as many options as possible. Some consumers will pay more for a better product/outcome, some will look for a bargain. But when government artificially suppresses premiums and carriers operate at a loss their only option is to leave the market.
The solution for tax-payers/citizens is an open market with many carriers setting pricing according to profitability, but with strong consumer protections so that claims are paid timely and in full.
Wayne Peacock, outgoing USAA president and CEO, and Juan Andrade, incoming USAA president and CEO, join CNBC's 'Squawk Box' to discuss reactions to the California wildfires, how insurance companies are assessing the fires, and more.