The Gemini Insurance Agency

The Gemini Insurance Agency It’s time to expect more. Auto 🚗 | Home 🏡 | Life 👨‍👩‍👧 | Commercial 🏢 | Travel ✈️ Welcome to The Gemini Insurance Agency.

We are a sister-owned and operated full service Insurance Agency located in New Castle, IN. With so many options, prices and uncertainty while shopping for insurance, we are dedicated to providing an entirely new and improved way to buy insurance. The Gemini Insurance Agency is a true concierge service that will provide long-lasting and trustful relationships fueled by consumer transparency. While

other insurance agencies are limited in their carriers they can offer, we can offer an array of premium choices at affordable prices. We work with a carefully selected group of financially strong and reputable insurance companies that give you the freedom to choose the best carrier for your insurance needs. We are committed to providing our community with the best quality insurance and world-class customer service all under one roof. How can you be sure if you over-insured or under-insured? How can you be sure that you and your family are protected from life's uncertainties? Give us a call today and let us be the only insurance agency you'll ever need.

04/20/2026

Something we saw recently 👀

Someone thought they had “full coverage” …

until they actually needed to use it.

That’s the part people don’t realize … insurance isn’t just about having it, it’s about what it actually does when something happens.

We always walk people through it so there are no surprises later.

Quick question ⬇️

Do you feel like you actually understand your coverage? YES or NO ❓

Okay we’re actually really excited about this one 🤩We just added Root Insurance and the quotes coming back have been 👀🔥I...
04/13/2026

Okay we’re actually really excited about this one 🤩

We just added Root Insurance and the quotes coming back have been 👀🔥

If you’ve been wanting to see if you could lower your payment, this might be a really good option to check out.

Want us to run it for you? We can do it FAST 😉

Agent Atlas is in the office today 🌎🙌🏼He hasn’t wrote any policies today so we were thinking we might have to let him go...
04/09/2026

Agent Atlas is in the office today 🌎🙌🏼

He hasn’t wrote any policies today so we were thinking we might have to let him go but he has made a lot of clients smile so we will keep him around 😜😆

Be honest 👀What’s your most annoying monthly bill right now?Rent/mortgage?Car payment?Insurance? 😅⬇️ drop it below
04/07/2026

Be honest 👀

What’s your most annoying monthly bill right now?

Rent/mortgage?
Car payment?
Insurance? 😅

⬇️ drop it below

04/06/2026

⚠️‼️ PSA ‼️⚠️

With spring storms in full swing and BEFORE you sign a contract with a roofer:

✅ Make sure they provide an active verifiable certificate of insurance with today's date. You want to see a company name, insurance agency name, policy number, effective and expiration dates and policy limits. If you're our client and want to verify a certificate, call us.

✅ Get a copy of their workmanship and material warranties

✅ Use someone local. These storm chasing roofing companies will come and go but there are several reputable businesses that will NOT scam you.

Need a list of client recommended companies?

Give us a call 765-566-7156 📱

We talk about price a lot when it comes to insurance…but price isn’t everything 👀The cheapest option isn’t always the on...
03/27/2026

We talk about price a lot when it comes to insurance…

but price isn’t everything 👀

The cheapest option isn’t always the one that actually protects you when something happens.

Our goal is to make sure you understand ALL your options so you can choose what’s best for you and your family.

Some people want the lowest price, and that’s totally fine. Others want better coverage and peace of mind.

Both are okay …. you just need to know the difference.

Which matters more to you right now?

💰 Price
🛡️ Coverage

We looked at 5 insurance policies today from new clients …. 4 of them were overpaying! Not by a little either 😳If you’re...
03/26/2026

We looked at 5 insurance policies today from new clients ….

4 of them were overpaying!

Not by a little either 😳

If you’re even a little curious about yours, we can check it super quick! Just slide in our DM’s 🙌🏼

Final score 👀Hadley: 8 🏆Maggie: 6We welcomed 4 new clients today 🙌Such a fun day — thank you to everyone who participate...
03/25/2026

Final score 👀

Hadley: 8 🏆
Maggie: 6

We welcomed 4 new clients today 🙌

Such a fun day — thank you to everyone who participated!!

🚨 Update from the sister showdown 🚨Maggie is currently winning… 5 to 3 😤Not saying Hadley needs a comeback… but she defi...
03/25/2026

🚨 Update from the sister showdown 🚨

Maggie is currently winning… 5 to 3 😤

Not saying Hadley needs a comeback… but she definitely needs a comeback 😂

Still time to get on Team Hadley or Team Maggie — comment below or message us for a quick, free quote!

This could get interesting 👀

03/25/2026

🚨 SISTER SHOWDOWN 🚨

We’re having a friendly competition today…

👯‍♀️ Team Hadley vs Team Maggie

Who can get the MOST insurance quotes today?!

Want to help?
👉 message us your info for a FAST & FREE quote!
👉 include what team you are on the the message

We’ll post the winner at the end of the day 👀🏆
Loser has to buy the other coffee for a WEEK ☕️🧋

03/24/2026

🏍️ Motorcycle Riders!! We want to know…

What do YOU ride?! 👇

Cruiser? Sportbike? Touring? Something custom?

Drop it in the comments (bonus points for pics!!)

Also… quick question:
Do you know what your current motorcycle insurance actually covers? 👀

If you’re not 100% sure, message us and we’ll get you a fast, free quote + review what you’ve got.

Address

2927 S 14TH Street
New Castle, IN
47362

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Telephone

+17655667156

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Gemini Insurance Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Gemini Insurance Agency:

Share