Preferred Mutual

Preferred Mutual Providing property & casualty insurance coverage through independent agents in NY, NJ, MA & NH. Protecting what matters most since 1896.

Live Assured.
πŸ”Ή Learn more: www.preferredmutual.com Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides property and casualty insurance coverage to now more than 232,000 individuals and business owners across a network of more than 560 independent agents located throughout New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. Through the partnerships that we have established with our agents, we are able

to provide the coverage policyholders want and need to protect what is most important to them – their families, their businesses, and their homes. Preferred Mutual maintains a long-standing, steadfast tradition of caring – not only for our agents and our policyholders, but also for our community. Etched deep in our culture, is our commitment to help others and support our community through leadership, hands-on volunteer work, and philanthropy. In business since 1896, and headquartered in New Berlin, NY, Preferred Mutual Insurance Company is rated β€˜A’ by AM Best Company, the largest credit rating agency in the world specializing in the insurance industry. To learn more, visit us at www.preferredmutual.com. For billing and payment inquiries, please contact our Customer Service Team at (800) 333-7642. To file a new claim 24/7/365, call (800) 333-7642 weekdays between 8:00AM and 5:00PM, email us at [email protected], log onto MyPreferred, or contact your independent agent to file a claim for you. We reserve the right to remove comments that we deem are offensive or violate our privacy policies.

09/01/2026

Growth sneaks up on a policy. πŸ“ˆ

You added a location. You put a vehicle on the road. You hired your first employee. Your inventory is worth more than it was last spring.

Every one of those is a win. Every one of them can also open a gap in coverage that was written for a smaller version of your business.

Four signs it's time for a coverage review, and one short conversation with your independent agent that can save a much longer one later.

Preferred Mutual was proud to serve as a hole sponsor and participant in the inaugural Menzo Case & Bob Rosenkrans Memor...
08/31/2026

Preferred Mutual was proud to serve as a hole sponsor and participant in the inaugural Menzo Case & Bob Rosenkrans Memorial Golf Outing, hosted by Northwoods Insurance Agencies at Seneca Falls Country Club. β›³

The event brought together two longstanding community golf traditions benefiting Habitat for Humanity and the American Cancer Society for a unified day honoring the legacies of Menzo Case and Bob Rosenkrans, both of whom made a lasting impact on Seneca County.

We were grateful for the opportunity to take part in this meaningful event and support our agency partners at Northwoods Insurance Agencies.

08/26/2026

That's a wrap on another summer with our intern program. πŸ’™

Each summer, our interns bring fresh perspectives to Team Preferred, and we're grateful for the opportunity to learn alongside them.

To this year's interns: thank you for the energy, the ideas and the questions. Best of luck this semester!

08/21/2026

Team Preferred headed north for the 62nd Annual South of the Border Golf Tournament in Tupper Lake, hosted by Blue Line Insurance Agency. ⛳⁠
⁠
Our Preferred team members played the day out, joined by our invited guests from Capital Gate Insurance Group.⁠
⁠
The best part: the tournament raised $2,358 for the American Heart Association - New York State. A great day on the course for an even better cause.⁠
⁠
Thank you to Blue Line Insurance Agency for another one to remember. See you at the 63rd. πŸ’™β 
⁠

This is what we mean when we say Live Assured. πŸ’™Thank you for trusting us when it matters most. Ready to experience insu...
08/18/2026

This is what we mean when we say Live Assured. πŸ’™

Thank you for trusting us when it matters most. Ready to experience insurance the way it should be? Reach out to your local independent agent today.

08/17/2026

It's National Nonprofit Day!

So far in 2026, the Preferred Mutual Foundation has supported 17 local organizations with total donations of $53,600.00.

To every nonprofit team in our communities: thank you for everything you do for our neighbors. It's a true honor to celebrate you today and every day!

Address

1 Preferred Way
New Berlin, NY
13411

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Preferred Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Preferred Mutual:

Shortcuts

Share