Preferred Mutual

Preferred Mutual Providing property & casualty insurance coverage through independent agents in NY, NJ, MA & NH. Protecting what matters most since 1896.

Live Assured.
πŸ”Ή Learn more: www.preferredmutual.com Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides property and casualty insurance coverage to now more than 232,000 individuals and business owners across a network of more than 560 independent agents located throughout New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. Through the partnerships that we have established with our agents, we are able

to provide the coverage policyholders want and need to protect what is most important to them – their families, their businesses, and their homes. Preferred Mutual maintains a long-standing, steadfast tradition of caring – not only for our agents and our policyholders, but also for our community. Etched deep in our culture, is our commitment to help others and support our community through leadership, hands-on volunteer work, and philanthropy. In business since 1896, and headquartered in New Berlin, NY, Preferred Mutual Insurance Company is rated β€˜A’ by AM Best Company, the largest credit rating agency in the world specializing in the insurance industry. To learn more, visit us at www.preferredmutual.com. For billing and payment inquiries, please contact our Customer Service Team at (800) 333-7642. To file a new claim 24/7/365, call (800) 333-7642 weekdays between 8:00AM and 5:00PM, email us at [email protected], log onto MyPreferred, or contact your independent agent to file a claim for you. We reserve the right to remove comments that we deem are offensive or violate our privacy policies.

Giving back is at the heart of who we are. πŸ’™ Last week, Team PMIC rolled up our sleeves to volunteer with Clear Path for...
06/24/2026

Giving back is at the heart of who we are. πŸ’™ Last week, Team PMIC rolled up our sleeves to volunteer with Clear Path for Veterans as they prepare for their 15th annual Red, White, and Blue BBQ Fundraiser.⁠
⁠
It was an honor to support an organization doing such meaningful work for the veterans and military families in our community.⁠
⁠
To everyone at Clear Path, thank you for letting us be part of it. πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έβ 
⁠

Big things happening for Team Preferred! πŸŽ‰ Earlier this month, we joined insurance professionals from across the industr...
06/23/2026

Big things happening for Team Preferred! πŸŽ‰

Earlier this month, we joined insurance professionals from across the industry at the 2026 RISE Professionals Summit & Awards Gala in Fort Lauderdale for leadership development, networking, and celebration.

And we had something extra to celebrate: our own Tim DiPaola, Underwriting Risk Analyst, was named one of RISE's 2026 "35 Under 35" winners. πŸ‘

Congratulations, Tim. We're proud to have you on the team!

06/21/2026

β˜€οΈ Say Hello to Our Summer Interns! β˜€οΈβ 
⁠
We're thrilled to welcome a fantastic new group of summer interns to the Preferred Mutual family.⁠
⁠
This crew wasted no time embracing the Preferred Mutual way of volunteerism, heading over to Chase Memorial Nursing Home & Rehab for some riveting rounds of Bingo with the residents. Laughter, friendly competition, and plenty of community spirit made for a great afternoon all around.⁠
⁠
We could not be more proud of this group, and we can't wait to see all they'll accomplish during an incredible summer ahead.⁠
⁠
Stay tuned! An official introduction is coming your way soon. πŸ‘€β 
⁠

πŸŽ“ Celebrating Excellence: Preferred Mutual's 2026 Scholarship Recipients πŸŽ“Since 1992, Preferred Mutual has been proud to...
06/18/2026

πŸŽ“ Celebrating Excellence: Preferred Mutual's 2026 Scholarship Recipients πŸŽ“

Since 1992, Preferred Mutual has been proud to support graduating high school seniors across Otsego, Delaware, and Chenango Counties who demonstrate outstanding academic achievement, leadership, and a commitment to their communities. This year is no exception, and we're honored to introduce our 2026 scholarship recipients!

πŸ… Preferred Foundation Scholarship

β˜‘οΈ Congratulations to Sophia Zheng of Norwich High School! Sophia will pursue Pre-Pharmacy at Binghamton University.

β˜‘οΈ Congratulations to Leah Figary of Sidney High School! Leah will study Chemistry at Binghamton University, with plans to transfer to Cornell University in Fall 2027.

πŸ… Irad and Jan Ingraham / James Honeywell Memorial Scholarship

β˜‘οΈ Congratulations to Myriah Taylor of Unadilla Valley Central School! Myriah will attend the Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences to study Diagnostic Medical Sonography.

β˜‘οΈ Congratulations to Braden Golliver of Unadilla Valley Central School! Braden will attend Rochester Institute of Technology to study Civil Engineering.

These four students represent some of the very best of our communities, and we couldn't be prouder to invest in their futures. Congratulations to all our winners and best of luck in your next chapter, and beyond! πŸ‘

Press Release πŸ”— https://preferredmutual.com/our-difference/press-room/-/2026/06/02/announcing-our-2026-college-scholarship-recipients

of2026

Members of Team PMIC recently attended the PIA Northeast Annual Conference in Atlantic City, connecting with industry pe...
06/10/2026

Members of Team PMIC recently attended the PIA Northeast Annual Conference in Atlantic City, connecting with industry peers and taking part in meaningful conversations about the future of insurance.

Preferred Mutual President/CEO Benedikt Sander joined the CEO Panel during the Networking Lunch, sharing initiatives and insights affecting carriers and independent insurance agents.

Thank you to PIA for hosting an engaging event and creating space for important industry dialogue.

06/05/2026

What a week! πŸŽ‰

We officially wrapped up Agency Appreciation Week, and we spent it doing one of our favorite things: getting out from behind the desk and visiting our incredible agent partners.

From office to office, we got to say thank you in person, share some laughs, and celebrate the people who make what we do possible. Our agents are more than partners. They're an extension of the Preferred Mutual family, and the trust they place in us every day never goes unnoticed.

To every agency that welcomed us this week: thank you for your dedication, your relationships, and the care you bring to your policyholders.

You are truly valued, this week and always.

Here's to many more years of partnership!

06/04/2026

This week is CPR & AED Awareness Week. A great reminder that a few simple skills can make a real difference when it matters most.

We got a head start at our recent Wellness Day, where our team took part in hands-on CPR training with American Heart Association - New York State. It was a chance to build the confidence to step in and help at work, at home, or out in our communities.

At Preferred Mutual, looking out for one another is at the heart of what we do. We loved seeing our team learn skills they can carry well beyond the office.

Curious whether you'd know what to do in the moment? This is the perfect week to learn. Find a CPR & AED course near you and get ready to lend a hand.

Preferred Mutual is proud to support the United Way of Mid Rural New York, Inc. with a recent contribution to help stren...
06/03/2026

Preferred Mutual is proud to support the United Way of Mid Rural New York, Inc. with a recent contribution to help strengthen the communities we serve.

By mobilizing the caring power of our region, United Way brings people together to advance education, economic mobility, and health.

Together, we can make a lasting difference.

Proud to support the Baden-Powell Council of Scouting America's 2026 Chenango County Distinguished Citizen Awards Dinner...
06/01/2026

Proud to support the Baden-Powell Council of Scouting America's 2026 Chenango County Distinguished Citizen Awards Dinner!

This annual banquet celebrates the civic and business leaders who exemplify outstanding service and inspire the next generation in our county.

Congratulations to this year's honoree, Heather Bartle Ferrarese!

πŸ“š Some investments pay dividends for a lifetime and literacy is one of them! We're delighted to continue our support of ...
05/29/2026

πŸ“š Some investments pay dividends for a lifetime and literacy is one of them!

We're delighted to continue our support of the Reading is Fundamental (RIF) program at Unadilla Valley Central School District. Year after year, RIF puts free books in the hands of elementary school students and sparks a love of reading that lasts.

Address

1 Preferred Way
New Berlin, NY
13411

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Preferred Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Preferred Mutual:

Share