Preferred Mutual

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Preferred Mutual Providing property & casualty insurance coverage through independent agents in NY, NJ, MA & NH. Protecting what matters most since 1896.

Live Assured.
🔹 Learn more: www.preferredmutual.com Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides property and casualty insurance coverage to now more than 232,000 individuals and business owners across a network of more than 560 independent agents located throughout New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. Through the partnerships that we have established with our agents, we are able to provide the coverage policyholders want and need to protect what is most important to them – their families, their businesses, and their homes. Preferred Mutual maintains a long-standing, steadfast tradition of caring – not only for our agents and our policyholders, but also for our community. Etched deep in our culture, is our commitment to help others and support our community through leadership, hands-on volunteer work, and philanthropy. In business since 1896, and headquartered in New Berlin, NY, Preferred Mutual Insurance Company is rated ‘A’ by AM Best Company, the largest credit rating agency in the world specializing in the insurance industry. To learn more, visit us at www.preferredmutual.com. For billing and payment inquiries, please contact our Customer Service Team at (800) 333-7642. To file a new claim 24/7/365, call (800) 333-7642 weekdays between 8:00AM and 5:00PM, email us at [email protected], log onto MyPreferred, or contact your independent agent to file a claim for you. We reserve the right to remove comments that we deem are offensive or violate our privacy policies.

10/17/2026

Team Preferred spent a morning at Freedom Guide Dogs in Cassville.

We brought along a basket of supplies, toys, treats, training pads, and raised a little money toward whatever else they need. Then we got the best assignment: helping socialize the pups and tidying up the outdoor play area.

Since 1992, Freedom Guide Dogs has been breeding, raising, training and placing guide dogs through their Hometown Training program, completely free to the people who receive them. More than 600 people over 30 years.

We're grateful they let us be a small part of it.

We’re grateful for the feedback we receive from our policyholders and proud to be there when it matters most.Thank you t...
10/16/2026

We’re grateful for the feedback we receive from our policyholders and proud to be there when it matters most.

Thank you to this policyholder for sharing their experience with Preferred Mutual!

We enjoyed attending Renaissance Alliance’s   conference in Louisville, Kentucky! It was a great opportunity to connect ...
10/16/2026

We enjoyed attending Renaissance Alliance’s conference in Louisville, Kentucky!

It was a great opportunity to connect with agency partners and industry colleagues, share ideas, and strengthen relationships.

10/14/2026

October is a great month for a quick check in with your agent. Here are three questions to help you get started. They'll walk you through the rest!

Team Preferred is at Big I New York’s Women in Insurance Summit today in White Plains!We’re connecting with industry pee...
10/14/2026

Team Preferred is at Big I New York’s Women in Insurance Summit today in White Plains!

We’re connecting with industry peers, sharing ideas, and celebrating the women making a difference in insurance.

Thank you to Big I New York for bringing us together for a day of learning, inspiration, and conversation!

A beautiful downtown sunset 🌇This is the part of upstate New York we get to call home, and we wouldn't trade it for the ...
10/12/2026

A beautiful downtown sunset 🌇

This is the part of upstate New York we get to call home, and we wouldn't trade it for the world.

Curious about open positions? Send us a message!

📷 Commerce Chenango

Preferred Team Spotlight!⁠⁠From recruiting talent to supporting teams and connecting employees with benefits, our HR tea...
10/10/2026

Preferred Team Spotlight!⁠
⁠
From recruiting talent to supporting teams and connecting employees with benefits, our HR team helps us thrive. New hire paperwork and new baby paperwork. Benefits questions and guidance that helps someone figure out their next step.

Thank you for looking out for all of us, and for making Preferred Mutual a great place to build a career.

10/09/2026

We spent the week celebrating the people who take care of our policyholders every single day. Thank you to all our teams who serve and support our customers!

10/08/2026

Fire Prevention Week is a good excuse to spend fifteen minutes on the smoke alarms and walk through your escape plan with the family.

Also, a big thank you to the firefighters in our communities for everything you do!

We were proud to serve as a table sponsor at last week’s Hospice & Palliative Care of Chenango County Celebrity Dinner F...
10/08/2026

We were proud to serve as a table sponsor at last week’s Hospice & Palliative Care of Chenango County Celebrity Dinner Fundraiser, which also celebrated the organization’s 35th anniversary.

Our Executive Assistant, Stacy, participated as a celebrity host, adding a little magic to the evening with her witch costume and theme!

Congratulations to Hospice Chenango on 35 years of providing compassionate care and support to local patients and families. 💙

Address

1 Preferred Way
New Berlin, NY
13411

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Preferred Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Preferred Mutual:

Share