Countryside Insurance Agency INC

Directions Website Contact the business

Countryside Insurance Agency INC Second-generation, family-owned and proudly independent since 1976. Voted Best Insurance Agency & Agent 2021–2026.

We shop 30+ trusted carriers, explain the fine print and protect what matters—without sacrificing coverage just to make a sale. Independent Insurance Agency representing Erie, Safeco, Kemper, Travelers, Progressive, American Modern, and many more!

👻 SURPRISE, BECCA! IT’S PICTURE DAY! 📸😂Poor Becca! She showed up for work in her cute little Halloween sweatshirt, just ...
10/19/2026

👻 SURPRISE, BECCA! IT’S PICTURE DAY! 📸😂

Poor Becca! She showed up for work in her cute little Halloween sweatshirt, just planning to answer phones and help customers.

Little did she know her boss had OTHER plans! 🤣

That’s right, our newest insurance chick got tricked into a photo shoot!

But don’t let that fool you. When you call Countryside Insurance or stop by the office, you’ll discover that Becca is as sweet as she looks!

We’re so happy to have her on our team! ❤️

🎃 All treats, no tricks!

Except maybe surprise picture day. 😂👻

🚗🔑 PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT: Let's Not Make It Easy for Car Thieves!Here's your friendly reminder from Countryside In...
10/18/2026

🚗🔑 PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT: Let's Not Make It Easy for Car Thieves!

Here's your friendly reminder from Countryside Insurance:

Your glovebox is NOT a key safe.

Your unlocked vehicle is NOT secure.

And leaving your keys inside your unlocked vehicle? Well… you're practically rolling out the welcome mat. 🤦‍♀️

We know life gets busy. We get distracted. We forget things.

But please, PLEASE:

✅ Lock your vehicle. Every time.

✅ Take your keys with you. Yes, even in your own driveway.

✅ Never leave valuables in plain sight.

✅ Don't assume your vehicle is safe just because you're at home.

And here's your insurance tip of the day: Comprehensive coverage generally covers vehicle theft, subject to your deductible and policy terms. Liability-only coverage does NOT cover the theft of your own vehicle.

At Countryside Insurance, we've spent 50 years helping our neighbors protect what matters. We'd much rather help you PREVENT a claim than have to help you through one!

Countryside Insurance Agency
Guidance You Can Trust. Coverage You Can Count On.

📍 New Albany, Indiana
🌐 www.countrysideinsinc.com

I had to jump on the trend! 😂Some of us were just born to be our own boss. Apparently, the teachers saw it coming long b...
10/18/2026

I had to jump on the trend! 😂
Some of us were just born to be our own boss. Apparently, the teachers saw it coming long before we did! 😂

Who else spent a little time in this seat? �

💐 Feeling especially grateful this Boss’s Day!What a beautiful surprise from my Countryside family! The flowers are gorg...
10/16/2026

💐 Feeling especially grateful this Boss’s Day!

What a beautiful surprise from my Countryside family! The flowers are gorgeous, but the thoughtful words in the card meant even more. ❤️

After 50 years in business, one thing remains true — it's the people who make Countryside Insurance Agency special.

I'm so thankful for the wonderful ladies I have the privilege of working alongside every day. 💙🍷

Some days in the insurance business, you just have to laugh! 😂🤣Between rising premiums, claims, underwriting, and trying...
10/14/2026

Some days in the insurance business, you just have to laugh! 😂🤣

Between rising premiums, claims, underwriting, and trying to find everyone the best coverage for their money, we occasionally resemble this Barbie by 4 PM. 💁‍♀️

But don’t worry. We’re still here, still working hard, and still looking out for our clients!

Just maybe bring coffee. ☕😂

⭐ Saving money is great. Saving money while making sure you're properly protected? Even better! 💙Thank you, Ashley, for ...
10/13/2026

⭐ Saving money is great. Saving money while making sure you're properly protected? Even better! 💙

Thank you, Ashley, for the wonderful review and for trusting our team with your auto and renters insurance!

At Countryside, we believe finding the right insurance is about more than just the price. It's about reviewing your options, identifying opportunities for savings, and making sure your coverage fits your needs.

For 50 years, we've been proud to offer Southern Indiana something you can't always find with a 1-800 number: real people, personal guidance, and a local team looking out for you. 🏡🚗

Looking for an independent agency that cares about both your coverage AND your budget? We'd love the opportunity to earn your business, call us at 812-945-9123!

10/12/2026

We were just trying to get some nice, professional pictures to celebrate Countryside Insurance’s 50th anniversary when the strangest noises started coming from a nearby police car. 🚔

Nobody could figure out WHAT we were hearing!

Becca thought it might be a deer. 🦌 I wanted to know if someone was hunting. 😂

And just when we thought things couldn’t get any more ridiculous, it took approximately 8 HOURS and $200-a-month WiFi to upload this masterpiece! 🤦‍♀️😂

🔊 Turn your sound ON and tell us… WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT NOISE IS?!

🎃 Flashback Friday! 🍂In honor of Harvest Homecoming in New Albany, we’re taking a little trip down memory lane to 2023!W...
10/09/2026

🎃 Flashback Friday! 🍂

In honor of Harvest Homecoming in New Albany, we’re taking a little trip down memory lane to 2023!

We’re proud to be part of this wonderful New Albany tradition and the community we’ve called home for 50 years! ❤️

From all of us at Countryside Insurance, Happy Harvest Homecoming! 🎃🍁

We have a question for you. 👇What is something you’ve always wondered about insurance… but never actually asked?Maybe it...
10/08/2026

We have a question for you. 👇

What is something you’ve always wondered about insurance… but never actually asked?

Maybe it’s:

• Why did my rate go up if I didn’t have a claim?
• What does “replacement cost” really mean?
• Do I really need an umbrella policy?
• Why are home deductibles getting so high?
• What happens if my teenager starts driving?
• What coverage do I actually need?

No question is too basic — insurance can be confusing, and that’s exactly why we’re here.

Drop your question in the comments. We may even use it for an upcoming post! 😊

Guidance You Can Trust. Coverage You Can Count On.

Yesterday was my birthday — and this photo has me thinking about just how much of my life has been tied to Countryside I...
10/06/2026

Yesterday was my birthday — and this photo has me thinking about just how much of my life has been tied to Countryside Insurance. ❤️

That little girl is me with my dad, Charles C. Wathen.

A few years after this photo was taken, in 1976, Dad started Countryside Insurance Agency. I was six years old.

By the time I was eight, I was already spending time at the office, answering phones, filing paperwork and doing whatever little jobs Dad could find for me.

I grew up there.

I worked there through school and summers. I earned my insurance license at 18. And when life changed much sooner than I ever expected, I eventually found myself responsible for carrying forward what my dad had started.

At 27 years old, I became the owner of Countryside Insurance Agency.

And somehow, here we are.

50 years.

What started with my dad in 1976 has grown into an agency with an incredible team, thousands of families we’ve had the privilege to serve, and generations of clients who have trusted us with their homes, cars, businesses and lives.

Insurance has changed tremendously in those 50 years.

But the part that matters most to me never has:

People trusting us to help take care of them.

I’m incredibly proud to be a second-generation insurance agent, and even more proud that the little agency my dad started all those years ago is still here — local, independent and serving this community half a century later.

Dad, I hope I’ve made you proud. ❤️

Here’s to 50 years of Countryside Insurance — and to whatever comes next.

Guidance You Can Trust. Coverage You Can Count On.

Address

1411 State Street
New Albany, IN
47150

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Countryside Insurance Agency INC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Countryside Insurance Agency INC:

Shortcuts

Share