Countryside Insurance Agency INC

Countryside Insurance Agency INC Second-generation, family-owned and proudly independent since 1976. Voted Best Insurance Agency & Agent 2021–2025.

We shop 30+ trusted carriers, explain the fine print and protect what matters—without sacrificing coverage just to make a sale. Independent Insurance Agency representing Erie, Safeco, Kemper, Travelers, Progressive, American Modern, and many more!

BECCA SAYS… 🚗Buying a new car? Have this ready before you call us.New car day is exciting — but we need a few things to ...
09/02/2026

BECCA SAYS… 🚗
Buying a new car? Have this ready before you call us.

New car day is exciting — but we need a few things to get your insurance updated correctly:

• Year, make & model
• VIN
• Date you’re taking possession
• Purchase price
• Whether it’s financed, leased or paid in full
• Lienholder/leasing company information
• Who will be driving it most often
• What vehicle it’s replacing, if any

Becca’s best tip: Call us before you leave the dealership when you can. It gives us time to make sure everything is handled correctly before you drive away.

📞 Countryside Insurance Agency
812-945-9123

🇺🇸 Labor Day Weekend Office Hours 🇺🇸Just a heads-up as we head toward the holiday weekend! Countryside Insurance will be...
09/01/2026

🇺🇸 Labor Day Weekend Office Hours 🇺🇸

Just a heads-up as we head toward the holiday weekend! Countryside Insurance will be closed for Labor Day weekend and Monday, September 7th so our team can enjoy the holiday with family and friends.

We will reopen with our regular office hours on Tuesday, September 8th at 9:00 AM.

Need assistance while we're away? Many of our carriers are available directly for billing, payments, and other self-service needs:

🔵 Erie Insurance: 1-800-458-0811
🟢 Goodville Mutual: 1-877-445-5780
🔴 Foremost Signature: 1-800-527-3905
🔵 Progressive: 1-800-888-7764
🟠 Ohio Mutual: 1-888-895-7725

You can also leave our team a message by phone, text your agent's work number, or send us an email, and we'll follow up when we return.

We hope everyone has a safe and relaxing Labor Day weekend! 🇺🇸

🏡 Home insurance can look pretty similar on paper — until you know what to look for.Roof settlement. Deductibles. Water ...
08/31/2026

🏡 Home insurance can look pretty similar on paper — until you know what to look for.

Roof settlement. Deductibles. Water backup. Replacement cost. Liability.

Those details can make a big difference when there is actually a claim.

At Countryside Insurance Agency, Inc., we don’t believe homeowners should have to figure all of that out on their own.

We represent more than 30 insurance carriers, and our job is not simply to find the cheapest policy. It is to help you understand what you are buying, where you can safely save, and where cutting coverage may cost you later.

We have been helping families in New Albany and Southern Indiana for 50 years, and that experience has taught us what to look for.

If you are buying a home, reviewing your current coverage, or simply wondering whether your policy is still the right fit, we would be happy to help.

📍 1411 State Street, New Albany, IN
📞 (812) 945-9123

Guidance You Can Trust. Coverage You Can Count On.

🚨 Myth-Busting Monday with Alyssa!This one came from a real conversation this week:“I don’t need boat insurance while I’...
08/31/2026

🚨 Myth-Busting Monday with Alyssa!

This one came from a real conversation this week:

“I don’t need boat insurance while I’m towing my boat because my auto insurance covers it.”

Not exactly.

Your auto policy may provide some liability coverage while you’re towing, but that does not mean your boat itself is protected the way people often assume.

That’s where a separate boat policy matters.

Before canceling coverage because of something you’ve “heard,” give us a call and let us make sure you understand exactly what is — and isn’t — covered.

Have an insurance myth you want Alyssa to bust next? Drop it in the comments. 👇

📞 Countryside Insurance: 812-945-9123

Indiana’s minimum auto liability limits are:$25,000/ $50,000/ $25,000But do you know what that last $25,000 means?It mea...
08/30/2026

Indiana’s minimum auto liability limits are:

$25,000/ $50,000/ $25,000

But do you know what that last $25,000 means?

It means there may be only $25,000 in property damage liability coverage if a driver causes an accident.

That matters whether you carry state minimums or not.

If someone hits you and only carries Indiana’s minimum coverage, there may be just $25,000 available from their policy for the damage they caused.

With newer vehicles often costing close to $50,000, that can become a problem very quickly! 🚘

State minimum means minimum required by law — not necessarily enough.

Have questions about your limits or how your policy protects you?

Call Trista Melton with Countryside Insurance at 812-945-9123.

Insurance is about more than a policy. ❤️It’s about having someone who will explain your options, help you understand wh...
08/29/2026

Insurance is about more than a policy. ❤️

It’s about having someone who will explain your options, help you understand what you’re buying, look for ways to save without sacrificing important coverage, and tell you the truth—even when the best decision is to stay exactly where you are.

That’s what being an independent agency means to us.

We’ve been serving our community since 1976, and nearly 50 years later, that part hasn’t changed.

Guidance You Can Trust. Coverage You Can Count On.

38 years teaches you a few things.It teaches you where clients can safely save money — and where cutting a few dollars c...
08/28/2026

38 years teaches you a few things.

It teaches you where clients can safely save money — and where cutting a few dollars can come back to hurt them later.

It teaches you which coverage differences matter when there is a claim.

It teaches you what questions to ask before there is a problem.

And it teaches you that the lowest price is not always the best value.

I understand that price matters. My job is not to sell you the most expensive policy.

My job is to help you get the best price we can without quietly taking away protection you may wish you had later.

That is the difference experience makes.

At Countryside Insurance Agency, Inc., you are not just getting a quote from a computer. You are getting 38 years of judgment, a local team that knows your account, and an independent agency representing more than 30 insurance companies.

You can buy insurance anywhere. Experience, advocacy, and people who know you are much harder to replace.

❤️ Real people. Real advice. Real advocacy.

08/28/2026

Before you spend an afternoon shopping your insurance… call your agent. 📞

We get calls every day from people looking for lower insurance rates, and one of the first things I ask is:

“Have you talked to your current agent yet?”

You’d be surprised how often the answer is no.

If you work with an independent insurance agency like Countryside, you may have more options than you realize. We can review your coverage, look for available discounts and savings, adjust options when appropriate, and even compare other carriers we represent — without you spending hours calling company after company.

Sometimes shopping makes sense. But before you start from scratch, give your current independent agent a chance to help you first.

That’s part of what we’re here for. ❤️

General liability is one of the most important coverages a business can carry—but a lot of business owners still aren’t ...
08/27/2026

General liability is one of the most important coverages a business can carry—but a lot of business owners still aren’t completely sure what it actually covers.

What is bodily injury liability? What is property damage liability? What does “each occurrence” mean? And why do so many contracts ask for a certificate of insurance?

For the next installment of our Terms Made Simple series, we’re breaking down general liability coverage in plain English.

General liability can help protect your business if someone is injured because of your work, your location or your products—or if your business accidentally damages someone else’s property.

It can also help with legal defense costs, but it does not cover everything. Your employees, your own business property and certain professional risks may require separate coverage.

That is why the details matter.

We’ll help you understand what your policy includes, what it leaves out and whether your limits still fit the work you do today.

Countryside Insurance Agency, Inc.
Independent • Local • Serving Southern Indiana Since 1976
📞 812-945-9123
🌐 countrysideinsinc.com

🎉 Big congratulations to Christina! 🎉Christina recently passed her insurance licensing exam and is officially making the...
08/26/2026

🎉 Big congratulations to Christina! 🎉

Christina recently passed her insurance licensing exam and is officially making the move from Customer Service Representative to Licensed Insurance Agent! 👏📚

As part of her new role, Christina will be our Home Renewal Specialist, helping review our clients' homeowners policies as they come up for renewal.

At Countryside, we don't believe in simply letting a policy renew without taking another look. Christina will help review coverage, pricing, available options, discounts, and potential coverage gaps to make sure we're continuing to provide the protection and value our clients deserve. 🏡🔎

We're so proud of Christina for putting in the work to earn her license and excited to see her take on this new role!

Please help us congratulate her! 🥳👏

Address

1411 State Street
New Albany, IN
47150

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Countryside Insurance Agency INC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Countryside Insurance Agency INC:

Shortcuts

Share

Category