Countryside Insurance Agency INC

Countryside Insurance Agency INC Celebrating 50 years of providing superior insurance/asset protection via 30+ carriers. Our team will advise you through every step of your journey.

Voted Best Insurance Agency & Agent (Susan Wathen) for Floyd Co 2021-2025-News & Tribune. Independent Insurance Agency representing Erie, Safeco, Kemper, Travelers, Progressive, American Modern, and many more!

Now quoting GEICO! 🚌Have an RV, camper, or converted bus? We can help — even “schoolies” with the right setup.If it incl...
06/03/2026

Now quoting GEICO! 🚌

Have an RV, camper, or converted bus? We can help — even “schoolies” with the right setup.

If it includes required features like bathroom facilities, GEICO may be a great fit.

📞 Call 812-945-9123 to get a quote.

💻 Reminder: Staff Training Today 💻Our staff will be participating in training today from 11:00 AM – 12:00 PM as part of ...
06/03/2026

💻 Reminder: Staff Training Today 💻

Our staff will be participating in training today from 11:00 AM – 12:00 PM as part of our transition to a new agency management system.

If you need us during that time, please leave a voicemail, send a text, or email us and we’ll respond as soon as training wraps up.

We appreciate your patience as we continue improving our systems and service!

🌧️ Flood Insurance: One of the Biggest Coverage Gaps We See 🌧️Many people are surprised to learn that most standard home...
06/01/2026

🌧️ Flood Insurance: One of the Biggest Coverage Gaps We See 🌧️

Many people are surprised to learn that most standard home, renter, and business insurance policies do NOT cover flood damage.

Flooding can happen from heavy rain, flash flooding, overflowing creeks, drainage issues, or water entering from outside the structure — and it typically requires a separate flood insurance policy.

And remember: you do not have to live in a high-risk flood zone to experience a flood claim.

Countryside Insurance Agency can help with flood insurance options for:

🏠 Homes
🏢 Businesses
🏘️ Rentals & Condos
📦 Business Property & Equipment

We offer both NFIP and private flood insurance options through multiple carriers.

⚠️ Most flood policies have a waiting period before coverage begins, so don’t wait until severe weather is already approaching.

📞 812-945-9123

Need to stop by the office? We’re here Monday–Friday from 9 AM – 4 PM! 😊You’ll find us in the vintage white house with t...
05/28/2026

Need to stop by the office? We’re here Monday–Friday from 9 AM – 4 PM! 😊

You’ll find us in the vintage white house with the giant metal rooster outside — hard to miss! 🐓🏡

For the safety of our staff and clients, our front door remains locked at all times. When you arrive, simply ring the doorbell and we’ll be right there to assist you. 🔔

Parking is available beside the building or along the street. We look forward to seeing you!

💻 Reminder: Staff Training Today 💻Our staff will be in training today from 11:30 AM – 12:30 PM as we continue transition...
05/27/2026

💻 Reminder: Staff Training Today 💻

Our staff will be in training today from 11:30 AM – 12:30 PM as we continue transitioning to our new agency management system.

During this time, staff will be unavailable. Please feel free to call and leave a voicemail, send a text, or email us, and we’ll respond once training is complete.

Thank you for your patience and understanding!

🇺🇸 Memorial Day Office Closure 🇺🇸Our office is closed today in observance of Memorial Day as we honor and remember those...
05/25/2026

🇺🇸 Memorial Day Office Closure 🇺🇸

Our office is closed today in observance of Memorial Day as we honor and remember those who have served our country. We hope everyone is having a safe holiday with family and friends.

For immediate assistance while we’re closed, here are some helpful resources:

💻 Visit countrysideinsinc.com/client-center for claims, ID card requests, payments, and more

🚙 Erie Customers:
erieinsurance.com
📞 1-800-458-0811 (ID cards, payments, etc.)
🚨 Emergency Claims: 1-800-367-3743
📧 Non-emergency claims: email us the details and we’ll follow up during business hours

🚕 Goodville Customers:
📞 Emergency Claims: 1-877-445-5780

🚗 Progressive Customers:
📞 1-800-888-7764

🏠 Ohio Mutual Customers:
📞 1-888-895-7725

⛈ Home Damage:
Contact a roofer, contractor, or restoration company if needed. Protect your property if safe (mitigation, removing water/trees, etc.) and take photos first if possible.

🚗 Purchased a Vehicle?
If you already have an active auto policy with us, you’re covered to drive it. We’ll add it on the next business day.

There has been some confusion recently. Norma Jean is a popular name and 2 separate businesses. One is in Borden.  One i...
05/24/2026

There has been some confusion recently. Norma Jean is a popular name and 2 separate businesses. One is in Borden. One is in New Albany. Borden specializes in ice cream and serves food as well. New Albany specializes in cakes and pies.

🚨 Friendly Clarification 🚨

It has come to our attention that some people are getting us confused with the Norma Jean’s baked shop in New Albany. While the names are similar, please understand that these are two completely separate businesses and entities.

🍦 Norma Jean’s Ice Cream Shop in Borden has NOT changed our hours, and we are still proudly open 7 days a week serving our community!

Our current hours are:
Monday-Thursday 3pm-8pm
Friday-Sunday 12pm-8pm

We’ve noticed some confusion may have contributed to business being slower lately per customer inquiries on our hours (we did NOT go down to 2 days a week), so we wanted to make this post to help clear things up. We truly appreciate all of your continued support and hope to see you soon for ice cream, burgers, and treats! ❤️

Please feel free to share this post to help spread the word!

🚗 Are you comparing a 6-month auto policy to a 12-month auto policy?This is one of the biggest things people miss when c...
05/22/2026

🚗 Are you comparing a 6-month auto policy to a 12-month auto policy?

This is one of the biggest things people miss when comparing insurance quotes.

Many companies quote auto insurance on a 6-month term. Erie auto policies are written on a 12-month term. That means a “cheaper” quote may not actually be comparing the same thing.

A 12-month policy gives you a full year of rate stability, while a 6-month policy can change again in just a few months.

And price is only part of the picture. Before switching insurance, it’s important to compare:

✔️ Liability limits
✔️ Deductibles
✔️ Coverage options
✔️ Claim service
✔️ Overall protection

At Countryside Insurance, we help clients look beyond just the payment and understand what they actually have before making changes.

📞 812-945-9123
🏡 Local. Independent. Experienced.

Memorial Day weekend means more travel, more traffic… and more distractions. 🚗☀️Whether it’s your phone, snacks, or some...
05/21/2026

Memorial Day weekend means more travel, more traffic… and more distractions. 🚗☀️

Whether it’s your phone, snacks, or something happening outside your vehicle, stay focused and keep your hands on the wheel. If something needs your attention, it’s always safest to pull over.

💻 Training Schedule Notice 💻Starting today, as part of our transition to a new agency management system, during the next...
05/20/2026

💻 Training Schedule Notice 💻

Starting today, as part of our transition to a new agency management system, during the next 3 weeks our staff will be unavailable during the following training times:

📅 05/20/26 • 11:30 AM – 12:30 PM
📅 05/27/26 • 11:30 AM – 12:30 PM
📅 06/03/26 • 11:00 AM – 12:00 PM

Please feel free to call and leave a voicemail, send a text, or email us, and we will respond once training is complete.

We appreciate your patience as we continue working to better serve our clients!

Address

1411 State Street
New Albany, IN
47150

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Countryside Insurance Agency INC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Countryside Insurance Agency INC:

Share