James Madison Insurance

James Madison Insurance We are an independent insurance agency representing many insurance companies. Welcome to our page. We currently have 2 locations to serve you at.

James Madison Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Ohio representing Morrow, and surrounding counties. Our original office is in Mt. Gilead, and our new location is in Sunbury. We write auto, home, business, life, and farm insurance. We strive to provide the best insurance experience possible. We are the "Revolution in Insurance". Please contact us to provide you with a no risk, no obligation quote.

Did you know an umbrella can cover more than just a stormy day? ☔ERIE’s umbrella policy is that extra layer of protectio...
06/12/2026

Did you know an umbrella can cover more than just a stormy day? ☔

ERIE’s umbrella policy is that extra layer of protection many people don’t think about until they wish they had it.
Want to know if it’s right for you? Let’s chat. 📱(419) 947-4575

Have you stuck with the same auto insurance for years because it feels easier?Easier doesn’t always mean better. 🤔 And s...
06/10/2026

Have you stuck with the same auto insurance for years because it feels easier?
Easier doesn’t always mean better. 🤔 And switching is simpler than most people think.
If you haven’t reviewed your policy recently, it’s worth seeing what ERIE can offer. Between top-notch coverage options and standout claims service, it’s often a noticeable upgrade. ✨
Want to see what it can look like for you? 📱☎️

June 9th is National Meal Prep Day. Celebrate the time-saving/money-saving advantages of planning home meals ahead of ti...
06/09/2026

June 9th is National Meal Prep Day. Celebrate the time-saving/money-saving advantages of planning home meals ahead of time. Health-wise, home cooking beats take-out every time.

06/05/2026

The official start of summer means opening the pool. Be sure you've checked all our safety tips off for a safe and fun summer.

Road trip ready? Let’s make sure your coverage is too before you load up the car. An auto policy from ERIE is the perfec...
06/01/2026

Road trip ready? Let’s make sure your coverage is too before you load up the car. An auto policy from ERIE is the perfect way to protect the miles ahead, so you can focus on the playlist, not the what-ifs.
🚗🎶

As newlyweds, creating a strong financial foundation for your future should be an important point on your to-do list.Dis...
05/28/2026

As newlyweds, creating a strong financial foundation for your future should be an important point on your to-do list.

Disclaimer: Erie life insurance and annuity products and services are provided by Erie Family Life Insurance Company (home office: Erie, Pennsylvania.) Erie Family Life Insurance Company is not licensed to operate in all states. ERIE life insurance products are not available in New York. Go to erieinsurance.com for company licensure and product information.

We remember and honor the brave people who have given their lives for our country and our freedom.
05/26/2026

We remember and honor the brave people who have given their lives for our country and our freedom.

Insurance should feel human when it matters most. No one shops for auto insurance hoping to use it. But when something d...
05/20/2026

Insurance should feel human when it matters most.

No one shops for auto insurance hoping to use it. But when something does happen, the experience matters. It’s about how quickly you get help. How clearly things are explained. How supported you feel in a stressful moment.

The right auto policy isn’t just about coverage; it’s about confidence that someone will show up when you need them. 💙

Storms can hit fast, make sure your business is ready. ➡️ Contact us at 419-947-4575 or Julie@jmiquote.com to review you...
05/18/2026

Storms can hit fast, make sure your business is ready.

➡️ Contact us at 419-947-4575 or [email protected] to review your business insurance coverage today.

In short, if you own a motorized RV, you will need to purchase separate liability coverage for that vehicle. Get a quote...
05/15/2026

In short, if you own a motorized RV, you will need to purchase separate liability coverage for that vehicle. Get a quote with us to learn how coverages can vary.

Address

38 W. Center Street
Mount Gilead, OH
43338

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when James Madison Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to James Madison Insurance:

Shortcuts

Share

Category