James Madison Insurance

James Madison Insurance We are an independent insurance agency representing many insurance companies. Welcome to our page. We currently have 2 locations to serve you at.

James Madison Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Ohio representing Morrow, and surrounding counties. Our original office is in Mt. Gilead, and our new location is in Sunbury. We write auto, home, business, life, and farm insurance. We strive to provide the best insurance experience possible. We are the "Revolution in Insurance". Please contact us to provide you with a no risk, no obligation quote.

Is your home one of them? Make sure you have the coverage amount you need for your home.
09/01/2026

Is your home one of them? Make sure you have the coverage amount you need for your home.

If your business has grown in the last 12 months (new staff, new equipment, higher revenue), your insurance may need a t...
08/25/2026

If your business has grown in the last 12 months (new staff, new equipment, higher revenue), your insurance may need a tune-up, too.

A quick review now can prevent surprises later.

Contact us to talk about coverage that fits your business. Reach us at (419)947-4575 or [email protected].

Exploring the great outdoors on an ATV is one of life's best feelings. What’s another? Knowing you can get superior insu...
08/20/2026

Exploring the great outdoors on an ATV is one of life's best feelings. What’s another? Knowing you can get superior insurance coverage for that ATV at a fantastic price with ERIE. Our ATV policies cover:

✔️ Physical damage to your vehicle, including collision, vandalism and theft.
✔️ Property damage liability (if another person's property is damaged and you're responsible for it.)
✔️ An accident with an uninsured or underinsured motorist.
✔️ We can even factor in seasonal usage.

Give us a call at (419)947-4575 or send us a DM to learn more.

Your auto coverage should feel like it was built just for you 🚗With Erie Insurance, there are more than 30 extra policy ...
08/12/2026

Your auto coverage should feel like it was built just for you 🚗

With Erie Insurance, there are more than 30 extra policy options available so you can add that personal touch based on your life and how you drive.

Because the right coverage isn’t one-size-fits-all.
Want to see what that could look like for you? Let’s chat! 📱☎️

It's National S'More Day! Just like the perfect s'more, our coverage options layer protection where you need it most. Re...
08/10/2026

It's National S'More Day! Just like the perfect s'more, our coverage options layer protection where you need it most. Reach out to us to learn more about your coverage options and enjoy each sweet moment of summer safely.

It's National Pickleball Day! Our insurance coverage plans are tailored to protect you in every game of life. Don’t let ...
08/08/2026

It's National Pickleball Day! Our insurance coverage plans are tailored to protect you in every game of life. Don’t let unexpected mishaps sideline your dreams, give us a call at or send us a message to view all your coverage options.

Address

38 W. Center Street
Mount Gilead, OH
43338

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when James Madison Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to James Madison Insurance:

Shortcuts

Share

Category