James Madison Insurance

Directions Website Contact the business

James Madison Insurance We are an independent insurance agency representing many insurance companies. Welcome to our page. We currently have 2 locations to serve you at.

James Madison Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Ohio representing Morrow, and surrounding counties. Our original office is in Mt. Gilead, and our new location is in Sunbury. We write auto, home, business, life, and farm insurance. We strive to provide the best insurance experience possible. We are the "Revolution in Insurance". Please contact us to provide you with a no risk, no obligation quote.

Life insurance doesn't have to be complicated.Whether you're just getting started or it's been years since you've review...
10/16/2026

Life insurance doesn't have to be complicated.
Whether you're just getting started or it's been years since you've reviewed your coverage, a conversation is a great first step.
As your local ERIE agent, I'm here to help you understand your options.
Let's talk. 📱
Erie Family Life Insurance Company (Erie, PA). ERIE® life insurance products are not available in New York. Go to erieinsurance.com for company licensure and product details.

Fall is a great time to hit the road! And an even better time to make sure your auto insurance is ready to come along fo...
10/14/2026

Fall is a great time to hit the road! And an even better time to make sure your auto insurance is ready to come along for the ride. Ask us about ERIE auto insurance before your next adventure.

With online shopping right at your fingertips, don’t forget about your local small business community. Just down Main St...
09/20/2026

With online shopping right at your fingertips, don’t forget about your local small business community. Just down Main Street are a variety of unique finds that bring big benefits to our hometowns. 💙

You probably know how to protect the belongings inside your car from theft, but there are things outside your car that a...
09/18/2026

You probably know how to protect the belongings inside your car from theft, but there are things outside your car that are valuable for thefts, too, like your catalytic converter. Read how you can prevent your vehicle from becoming a target here: https://www.erieinsurance.com/blog/catalytic-converter-theft

Going to the chapel? There are a lot of important "dos". Make sure one of them is having the right coverage to start you...
09/14/2026

Going to the chapel? There are a lot of important "dos". Make sure one of them is having the right coverage to start your new life on the right path.

Just like an umbrella keeps you covered in a downpour, umbrella insurance gives you an extra layer of protection when li...
09/10/2026

Just like an umbrella keeps you covered in a downpour, umbrella insurance gives you an extra layer of protection when life throws more than you expected. 🌂
Simple. Affordable. Smart.
Ask us how an umbrella policy from ERIE could help protect your peace of mind.

09/05/2026

The early morning riders. 🌄
The weekend adventurers. 🛣️
The ones who take the long way home. ⛰️

Summer is one of the best times to enjoy the road, and we’re proud to help support the riders in our community.

📱☎️ If you have questions about motorcycle insurance, we're here to help. Reach out to our team today.

Is your home one of them? Make sure you have the coverage amount you need for your home.
09/01/2026

Is your home one of them? Make sure you have the coverage amount you need for your home.

Address

38 W. Center Street
Mount Gilead, OH
43338

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when James Madison Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to James Madison Insurance:

Shortcuts

Share

Category