09/10/2026
After more than 30 years in the insurance business, I have seen the homeowners insurance market go through many cycles. Right now, homeowners throughout New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and our surrounding region are dealing with a market that requires more attention than it did just a few years ago.
The good news is that there are still quality insurance companies interested in writing homeowners coverage, and homeowners who maintain their properties, address recommendations, and have favorable loss histories can often find competitive options. Working with an independent insurance agency can also provide access to multiple carriers rather than relying on just one company.
The challenge is that underwriting has become much more detailed. Insurance companies are paying closer attention to the age and condition of roofs, electrical systems, plumbing, heating systems, trees and property maintenance, prior claims, replacement costs, and other characteristics of the home. Premiums have also been under pressure because of higher construction and repair costs, weather-related losses, and the increasing cost of claims.
We are also seeing situations where a company may change its underwriting requirements, increase deductibles, request repairs following an inspection, or decide not to renew a particular risk. New Jersey regulations require insurers to provide advance notice when policies are being renewed on altered terms or non-renewed, making it especially important for homeowners to review renewal documents when they arrive.
The Pros
There are still competitive markets available for well-maintained homes, and homeowners may have opportunities to improve their insurance program by reviewing deductibles, available discounts, coverage limits, and packaging their home and automobile insurance.
The Cons
The market has become less forgiving. An older roof, outdated electrical or plumbing, several claims, deferred maintenance, or certain property characteristics can significantly reduce the number of companies willing to offer coverage. Simply renewing the same policy year after year without reviewing it may no longer be the best approach.
How We Can Help
At George Gravenstine Agency, LLC, our job is not simply to provide an insurance quote.
We review your current policy, evaluate your dwelling replacement cost, look for coverage gaps, discuss deductibles and endorsements, and determine which of our available insurance markets is the best fit for your property.
With more than 30 years of insurance experience, I believe one of the most important things an independent broker can provide is options and advice. The cheapest policy is not always the best policy, and finding out that an important coverage was missing after a loss is far too late.
If your homeowners premium has increased substantially, you have received an inspection recommendation or non-renewal notice, or you simply haven't reviewed your coverage recently, give us a call.
George Gravenstine Agency, LLC
Experience. Options. Personal Service.
We would be happy to review your homeowners insurance program and see if there is a better solution available.