McCarthy Insurance Group

McCarthy Insurance Group Quality Protection and Unparalleled Service McCarthy Insurance Group was founded in 1959. Our location demonstrates our commitment.

While much has changed in the last half century, our mission of providing “Quality Protection and Unparalleled Service” remains the same. We have been located in Mishawaka since the beginning and are committed to the Mishawaka community. We take great pride in having renovated one of Mishawaka 's oldest buildings and making it beautiful and useful again! We will continue to maintain the high principles and model of stability that has enabled us to succeed for over 50 years.

08/11/2026

🌪️ TORNADO WARNING 🚨

Take shelter. Stay safe.

Because you can’t control the weather—but you can make sure you’re protected when it hits.

There are some causes that are especially close to our heart—and Playing For Peyton is one of them. 🧡⚾McCarthy Insurance...
08/04/2026

There are some causes that are especially close to our heart—and Playing For Peyton is one of them. 🧡⚾
McCarthy Insurance was honored to support All Day Baseball in Sturgis by donating all of the snacks and chips for the event and spending the day lending helping hands in the food tent. The Playing for Peyton Foundation was created in honor of a close family friend- being able to support Peyton’s legacy while standing alongside his amazing family means more to us than words can express. Thank you to everyone who volunteered, donated, played, and stopped by to make it such a special day. 🧡⚾️

Sturgis Area Community Foundation

07/04/2026

🇺🇸 Land of the free, because of the brave.

Wishing you a wonderful and safe 4th of July!

Happy Father’s Day to all the amazing dads! 💙Thank you for the love, guidance, and protection you give your families eve...
06/21/2026

Happy Father’s Day to all the amazing dads! 💙

Thank you for the love, guidance, and protection you give your families every day. Today, we celebrate everything you do and the memories you help create.

Wishing you a day filled with love, laughter, and time with the ones who matter most. Happy Father’s Day! 👔

🎣 Happy National Go Fishing Day! 🎣Whether you're spending the day on the lake, at the river, or on your favorite fishing...
06/18/2026

🎣 Happy National Go Fishing Day! 🎣

Whether you're spending the day on the lake, at the river, or on your favorite fishing dock, we hope you reel in a great catch and enjoy some time outdoors!

And while you're making memories on the water, don't forget to make sure your boat, vehicle, and outdoor equipment are properly protected.

Have a great day and tight lines! 🐟☀️

In case you didn’t know! ⬇️I’ll leave this here!!
06/05/2026

In case you didn’t know! ⬇️

I’ll leave this here!!

Ok what do you think about our new friends bike? Be honest we won’t tell him, I promise!!
05/21/2026

Ok what do you think about our new friends bike?

Be honest we won’t tell him, I promise!!

☀️ Lake days are better when everyone stays safe.Before you hit the water, make sure your crew is protected with these ...
05/19/2026

☀️ Lake days are better when everyone stays safe.
Before you hit the water, make sure your crew is protected with these simple boating safety tips 🚤🌊

✔️ Wear life jackets
✔️ Watch the weather
✔️ Know local boating rules
✔️ Don’t overload the boat or tube

A little preparation can prevent a big accident. Stay safe and enjoy the ride this summer 💙



Buying a home can be stressful. 🏠Make sure you are asking these questions before signing on the dotted line.
05/11/2026

Buying a home can be stressful. 🏠

Make sure you are asking these questions before signing on the dotted line.

💐 Happy Mother’s Day 💐Today we celebrate the moms, grandmas, bonus moms, and mother figures who do so much for the peopl...
05/10/2026

💐 Happy Mother’s Day 💐

Today we celebrate the moms, grandmas, bonus moms, and mother figures who do so much for the people they love every single day ❤️

Thank you for the care, strength, sacrifices, and endless support you give your families. You are truly the heart of every home.

From all of us at McCarthy Insurance Group, we wish you a beautiful Mother’s Day filled with love, laughter, and special moments with those who matter most 🌸

Address

802 Lincolnway W
Mishawaka, IN
46544

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when McCarthy Insurance Group posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to McCarthy Insurance Group:

Shortcuts

Share

Category