Andrea Sheren: Allstate Insurance

Directions Website

Andrea Sheren: Allstate Insurance Allstate Agency in Middle Island, NY It’s easy to love what you do when you can help families and individuals who rely on you.

That’s especially true for a lifelong resident of New York who gets to assist customers in and around Middle Island. I grew up on Long Island before graduating from Keene State College with a bachelor’s degree in business administration in 1987. In 2004 I started working in the insurance industry, and I took over this agency in 2014. This experience has allowed me to speak more passionately to others who may not understand the value of insurance in their day-to-day lives.

Finding time to relax outside of the office is also important. I’ve always loved spending summers at the beach and on the water – I particularly love boating and skiing. When I want to enjoy the city, I can often be found in Manhattan shopping, grabbing a bite to eat and enjoying the scenery. I also raised my children on Long Island. Now that they’re grown, my son is active duty in the U.S. Army and my daughter attends college. My husband, John, is also an agency owner.

Our goal is building long-lasting relationships with those in our communities. My staff and I strive to provide excellent customer service. Our agency's mission is assisting those in and around our community so they can feel confident in choosing options they feel fit their needs. We look forward to serving you!

Your ideal retirement might seem out of reach now, but a tailored plan can help you achieve your hopes and dreams. I'd l...
11/03/2026

Your ideal retirement might seem out of reach now, but a tailored plan can help you achieve your hopes and dreams. I'd love to help you get where you want to go.

Securities offered through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, Member FINRA, SIPC.

I call this place home too, and I know what life is like here. Your coverage should look out for your home and everythin...
11/03/2026

I call this place home too, and I know what life is like here. Your coverage should look out for your home and everything you love about it. Give my agency a call today at (631) 736-3100

A big shoutout to everyone celebrating a birthday in November! 🦃🎉 The season of thanks is here! Share something you’re t...
11/02/2026

A big shoutout to everyone celebrating a birthday in November! 🦃🎉 The season of thanks is here! Share something you’re thankful for this season as we celebrate YOU!

Future you will be thankful if you start planning for retirement today. Contact me for help creating a roadmap that lets...
10/28/2026

Future you will be thankful if you start planning for retirement today. Contact me for help creating a roadmap that lets you enjoy today with more confidence about what's next.

Securities offered through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, Member FINRA, SIPC.

Many people forego life insurance because they think it's expensive, but we work with top-rated providers to offer optio...
10/22/2026

Many people forego life insurance because they think it's expensive, but we work with top-rated providers to offer options that meet your needs and budget. Contact me to learn more.

Securities offered through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, Member FINRA, SIPC.

10/22/2026

Water damage shows up when you least expect it, and it rarely leaves your favorite things untouched. 💧 Think your landlord's insurance covers your belongings? It doesn't.

Call (631) 736-3100 today to see how affordable renters insurance can be.

The future doesn't feel so scary when you're prepared for it. Contact me for help developing a retirement plan that can ...
10/20/2026

The future doesn't feel so scary when you're prepared for it. Contact me for help developing a retirement plan that can help you balance your income, today's expenses and what's next.

Securities offered through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, Member FINRA, SIPC.

Customized protection starts with covering what your condo HOA won’t. Call me at (631) 736-3100 today to explore your op...
10/12/2026

Customized protection starts with covering what your condo HOA won’t. Call me at (631) 736-3100 today to explore your options.

Renters insurance covers the things that matter most, whether they're at home, in storage or even in your car. Reach out...
10/02/2026

Renters insurance covers the things that matter most, whether they're at home, in storage or even in your car. Reach out at (631) 736-3100 to learn more.

Happy Birthday to all our October friends! 🎃🎉 While you’re enjoying the season, remember life’s surprises aren’t always ...
10/01/2026

Happy Birthday to all our October friends! 🎃🎉 While you’re enjoying the season, remember life’s surprises aren’t always fun-sized. We’re here to help keep the things you value protected so you can focus on the treats, not the tricks. Call us at (631) 736-3100 for a quick coverage check.

07/27/2026

They doubted the vision. But you know home improvements are expensive.

The upgrades that don’t usually make the feeds are the ones that keep your family safe and comfortable. 🤲

05/27/2026

Not me getting emotional over a home upgrade.

The upgrades that don’t usually make the feeds are the ones that keep your family safe and comfortable. 🤲

05/26/2026

Thermostat set. Vibes set. We’re good over here.

The upgrades that don’t usually make the feeds are the ones that keep your family safe and comfortable. 🤲

05/22/2026

They said magic wasn't real. Then it stopped leaking.

The upgrades that don’t usually make the feeds are the ones that keep your family safe and comfortable. 🤲

05/21/2026

The pricey upgrade spoke and we listened.

The upgrades that don’t usually make the feeds are the ones that keep your family safe and comfortable. 🤲

In an inside sales role, you'll use your expertise to find affordable solutions that help people protect what matters mo...
12/10/2025

In an inside sales role, you'll use your expertise to find affordable solutions that help people protect what matters most in their lives. Sound like something you're interested in?

Take control of your career journey and apply today: http://spr.ly/6008C64f6

12/03/2025

From free therapy sessions to personalized financial services and virtual fitness classes, Allstate takes employee wellbeing seriously. We even have an entire group of Wellbeing Champions committed to growing our culture of wellness by sharing valuable updates, helping employees locate resources and checking in on their fellow Allstaters.

See how Allstate supports you at work and beyond. Check out our wellbeing benefits:
http://spr.ly/600872ZHy

When employees have the resources to challenge themselves, they don't just grow — they drive change and make a differenc...
11/12/2025

When employees have the resources to challenge themselves, they don't just grow — they drive change and make a difference. Our intrapreneurs group is a community of dreamers and doers that spark innovation across the company, and the entire insurance industry, by encouraging their fellow Allstaters to think creatively to solve the real problems facing us and our customers.

Want to drive lasting change at work and in the world? Join a team that's not afraid to think outside the box. http://spr.ly/60027n8Ow

This is what community looks like. We're proud of the Allstaters in Dallas-Fort Worth for showing up in a major way for ...
11/04/2025

This is what community looks like. We're proud of the Allstaters in Dallas-Fort Worth for showing up in a major way for Genesis Women's Shelter & Support. They packed hundreds of toiletry bags and hosted a food drive to help support women in need on their healing journey.

Our employees' passions become ours. This is why each Allstate employee gets PTO to volunteer their time to causes they care about.

Discover how we help our people thrive while making an impact. http://spr.ly/60097KcF7

Address

171 Middle Country Road
Middle Island, NY
11953

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 6pm
Tuesday 9am - 8pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Andrea Sheren: Allstate Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Nearby finance companies