Gentner Insurance Agency, Inc.

Gentner Insurance Agency, Inc. The Gentner Insurance Agency has been serving the educational community since 1980! Welcome to the Gentner Insurance Agency!

Charlie Gentner started Gentner Insurance in 1980 in the basement of his home. In 2002, the agency expanded and built a new office which we currently occupy on M-24 about three miles north of Mayville. After earning his Bachelor’s Degree from Ferris State University and a Master of Arts Degree from Central Michigan University, Charlie began his career in the educational community as a teacher and

coach at Bad Axe schools. He would later go on to teach at Caro schools before finally finding his home at the Tuscola Technology Center as an administrator, computerized accounting teacher and placement coordinator. Dan Gentner took over the agency after Charlie's passing in 2018. Dan grew up helping his father in the office and has worked full time in the agency since 2013. Dan and his wife Raeann, a school social worker at Kingston Elementary, live in Mayville where they enjoy spending time outdoors with their young children Hudson & Grayce. Our great staff includes our office manager Susan Atkerson, a licensed property, casualty and life insurance agent, our Customer Service Representative Courtney Craig, a licensed property and casualty agent, and Ian Pifer, a licensed sales agent. We pride ourselves on our quality, prompt and friendly service. People don’t care how much we know until they know how much WE CARE! Our agency offers insurance through MEEMIC, Progressive, Hagerty, Foremost, AAA, and American Modern as well as numerous life insurance companies including AAA, Prudential, John Hancock, Lincoln, Banner and Protective Life. Please call us at 989-843-5544 for help with your Auto, Home, Boat, ATV, Motorcycle, Flood, Life, and RV insurance.

“I am a Meemic agent but my posts are my own and are not statements by or on my behalf of Meemic.”

09/02/2026

It appears that our email issue is finally resolved! If you have sent an e-mail in the last couple days that you haven't received an answer - please reach out again!

We appear to be having email problems at this time - please call or text the office at 989-843-5544 in the meantime.
08/31/2026

We appear to be having email problems at this time - please call or text the office at 989-843-5544 in the meantime.

Educators, are you paying too much for car insurance?You may qualify for multiple discounts through Meemic Insurance, in...
08/24/2026

Educators, are you paying too much for car insurance?

You may qualify for multiple discounts through Meemic Insurance, including:

✅ Vehicle safety feature discounts
✅ Anti-theft device discounts
✅ Good student discounts
✅ Paperless & pay-in-full discounts
✅ AAA membership discounts
✅ Multi-product/bundle discounts
✅ Advance purchase discounts
…and many more!

Let us help you customize an auto insurance package that fits your lifestyle.

📞 Call today for a FREE quote!
989-843-5544

🌐 Meemic.com/GentnerInsurance

Discounts and savings opportunities are subject to eligibility requirements. Coverage is subject to policy terms, conditions, exclusions, and limitations.

Wishing you a safe, fun, and memorable Independence Day filled with family, friends, and celebration.Have a wonderful ho...
07/04/2026

Wishing you a safe, fun, and memorable Independence Day filled with family, friends, and celebration.

Have a wonderful holiday weekend! ❤️🤍💙

Reminder: Our office will be closed tomorrow, July 3, in observance of the 4th of July holiday. We will resume normal bu...
07/02/2026

Reminder: Our office will be closed tomorrow, July 3, in observance of the 4th of July holiday. We will resume normal business hours Monday, July 6.

Wishing everyone a Safe and Happy 4th of July!

Reminder: Our office will be closed Monday in observance of Memorial Day. 🇺🇸Wishing everyone a safe and happy Memorial D...
05/22/2026

Reminder: Our office will be closed Monday in observance of Memorial Day. 🇺🇸

Wishing everyone a safe and happy Memorial Day weekend! Please travel safely and enjoy the holiday!

Good Grades = Great Savings!Did you know students with good grades may qualify for a Good Student Discount on their auto...
05/13/2026

Good Grades = Great Savings!

Did you know students with good grades may qualify for a Good Student Discount on their auto insurance? If your teen maintains a strong GPA, you could save on your premium while rewarding their hard work in school!

Meemic grant benefits Marlette SchoolsLuke Reynolds, principal at Marlette Elementary School, received a Speed Stacks Co...
05/07/2026

Meemic grant benefits Marlette Schools

Luke Reynolds, principal at Marlette Elementary School, received a Speed Stacks Competition Bundle for winning the February 2026 PopIn2Win grant round from the Meemic Foundation!

The bundle consists of 12 competition cups, timer, mat and a gear bag.

Congratulations Luke and Marlette Schools!

Meemic grant benefits North Branch SchoolsDane Terauds, principal at North Branch's Ruth Fox Middle School, received $50...
05/06/2026

Meemic grant benefits North Branch Schools

Dane Terauds, principal at North Branch's Ruth Fox Middle School, received $500 to spend on Staff Appreciation Week for winning the 2026 1st Quarter Tools4Schools grant round from the Meemic Foundation!

Dane was nominated to win this award by teacher Bill Barkowska.

Congratulations Dane, Bill, and North Branch Schools!

In addition to teachers, it's important that we celebrate ALL school staff! From paraprofessionals and bus drivers to cu...
05/06/2026

In addition to teachers, it's important that we celebrate ALL school staff!

From paraprofessionals and bus drivers to custodians, cafeteria staff, office teams, and administrators, every role makes a difference in the lives of students each day. Your hard work often happens behind the scenes, but your impact is felt everywhere.

You create safe spaces, keep things moving, offer support, and help students feel seen, cared for, and ready to learn.

Thank you to ALL school staff for your dedication, compassion, and commitment to our communities!

Address

5390 Mertz Road
Mayville, MI
48744

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 5pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 5pm
Thursday 8:30am - 5pm
Friday 8:30am - 5pm

Telephone

+19898435544

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Gentner Insurance Agency, Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Gentner Insurance Agency, Inc.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category