Underhill Agency - Farmers Insurance

Underhill Agency - Farmers Insurance Full-service insurance agent in Marshall, MI and the surrounding areas. 🚗 🏡 🚤 🏢👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Stop by in person, reach out online or call to get a free quote today.
(1)

Whether you're looking for homeowners insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, or another kind, I'm here to help you understand the insurance coverage you may want. Serving the Marshall, MI area since 2022, I can help you understand your coverage options so you can protect what matters most to you.

It’s official. Our Core Values are now hanging in BOTH Underhill Insurance Agency locations! 🎉These aren’t just words on...
05/29/2026

It’s official. Our Core Values are now hanging in BOTH Underhill Insurance Agency locations! 🎉

These aren’t just words on a wall. They are the lifeblood of everything we do here. How we treat our clients, how we support each other, and what drives us to grow every single day.
From putting people first to getting 1% better daily, these 7 values are what separate a good agency from a GREAT one. We are incredibly proud of the team we’ve built and the culture we live out every day.

If you’re ever curious what it looks like to work with an agency that truly puts YOU first, give us a call. We’d love to show you.

📍 Underhill Insurance Agency, Marshall, MI
☎️ 269-727-0660

Exciting update for our Grand Rapids location! 🎉The signage is officially up at 6151 Kalamazoo Ave SE, and it’s starting...
05/27/2026

Exciting update for our Grand Rapids location! 🎉

The signage is officially up at 6151 Kalamazoo Ave SE, and it’s starting to feel even more like home. Huge shoutout to Bre and Tyler for helping to put it up!

We’re proud to continue growing the Underhill Agency and expanding our ability to serve more families and businesses across West Michigan.

Marshall will always be our main office, but we’re excited for what this Grand Rapids location means for our team, our customers, and the future of the agency.

Stop by and see us!

Farmers Insurance – Underhill Agency
📍 6151 Kalamazoo Ave SE, Grand Rapids, MI

Today we pause to honor and remember the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom.From all of...
05/25/2026

Today we pause to honor and remember the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom.

From all of us at Underhill Insurance Agency, we hope everyone has a safe and meaningful Memorial Day. 🇺🇸

Grateful to attend the S.A.F.E. Place Restoring Hope Gala tonight! Congratulations to all of the award recipients, espec...
05/16/2026

Grateful to attend the S.A.F.E. Place Restoring Hope Gala tonight!

Congratulations to all of the award recipients, especially Officer Erin Hug from the City of Marshall Police Department.

Great night supporting an organization that does so much for families in our community!

Happy Mother’s Day to all of the amazing moms out there today!A special thank you to my mom for everything she’s done fo...
05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day to all of the amazing moms out there today!

A special thank you to my mom for everything she’s done for me, my wife for the love and care she gives our family every day, and the incredible moms on our team who balance so much while still showing up with positivity and dedication each day.

We appreciate everything you do, today and every day. 💐

Huge shoutout to the Marshall Redhawks Softball teams for hosting the Youth Night! Such a fun night! 🥎
05/05/2026

Huge shoutout to the Marshall Redhawks Softball teams for hosting the Youth Night!

Such a fun night! 🥎

We stayed warm today at the Marshall United Way Golf Outing! Our team won with a score of -13! (Thank goodness for my wi...
05/02/2026

We stayed warm today at the Marshall United Way Golf Outing!

Our team won with a score of -13! (Thank goodness for my wife 😂❤️)

Monday we got to celebrate some wins with a goal lunch at Schuler's Restaurant here in town 🍽️Gavin, Tyler, and Andrew w...
05/01/2026

Monday we got to celebrate some wins with a goal lunch at Schuler's Restaurant here in town 🍽️

Gavin, Tyler, and Andrew were able to make it out and enjoy it together. Always good to step away for a bit and recognize the work being put in.

Shoutout as well to Axel and Brandy who also hit their goals this month 👏

We’re looking forward to carrying this momentum into the new month and hopefully getting some of our service team members at the table next time too. Let’s keep it rolling 💪

Big news! We’re opening a second location!🎉Starting May 1, you’ll be able to find us in Grand Rapids at 6151 Kalamazoo A...
04/23/2026

Big news! We’re opening a second location!🎉

Starting May 1, you’ll be able to find us in Grand Rapids at 6151 Kalamazoo Ave SE right across from East Kentwood High School-KPS and Heinz Orthodontics! This is something we’ve been working toward for a while, and it feels good to finally share it!

Breanne and Tyler came up with me today to check out the new space, and that’s when it really hit. We’re excited for this next step and everything that comes with it.

Marshall isn’t going anywhere. That’s home, and it will always be our main location. Same team, same service, same focus on taking care of our clients. This just gives us the chance to reach more people.

We’re also bringing on David Howard from the agency we’re purchasing, where he has been since 2024. He’ll be a familiar face for the clients coming over and will help keep things running smoothly in Grand Rapids.

We appreciate everyone who’s supported us along the way. Looking forward to what’s next. Let’s go! 🚀

🚨 $100K+ MONTH — LET’S TALK ABOUT WHAT THIS REALLY MEANS 🚨Huge shoutout to Axel Vazquez Laboy for writing $102,489 in pr...
04/20/2026

🚨 $100K+ MONTH — LET’S TALK ABOUT WHAT THIS REALLY MEANS 🚨

Huge shoutout to Axel Vazquez Laboy for writing $102,489 in premium this month 👏

On paper, that’s an incredible number.
But in this business… it’s elite!

To put it in perspective — this isn’t just a big month in our office, or even in Michigan…
this is top-tier production nationwide.

This doesn’t happen by accident.

🔹 86 households quoted
🔹 39 households written
🔹 78 total policies
🔹 3 life policies + 1 commercial

But the real story is how it happened.

Axel made a decision to level up his process:
✔️ Having deeper conversations and bringing up all lines of business
✔️ Following up more times than most people are willing to
✔️ Doing exactly what he says he’s going to do, every time
✔️ Asking for the business with confidence

Two months ago, he was at 1.42 policies per household
Now he’s running 2.0+ back-to-back months

That’s not luck — that’s growth, discipline, and ex*****on.

This is what it looks like when someone commits to getting better and actually does the work.

Proud of you, Axel. This is just the beginning.

If you’re in sales (or honestly any business), there’s a lot to learn from this 👇
👉 Consistency beats talent
👉 Follow-up wins deals
👉 Process creates results

Drop a 👏 in the comments for Axel — he earned it.

Address

816 Industrial Road
Marshall, MI
49068

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 5pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 5pm
Thursday 8:30am - 5pm
Friday 8:30am - 5pm

Telephone

+12697270660

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Underhill Agency - Farmers Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category