Gardner Insurance Agency, Inc.

Gardner Insurance Agency, Inc. As an independent agency, we're able to help you, our clients, find the best possible insurance coverage for the lowest price.
(1)

"Smile-Maker" since 1979

Independent Insurance Agency specializing in Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance serving Madison, IN and the surrounding communities. A Local Family Business

Gardner Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company that specializes in auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance and business insurance. Gardner Insurance was established in Madison, Indian

a in 1979 by Bob Gardner (the "Smile-Maker") and his wife Carolyn. Their eldest daughter , Robin Goodnight, joined them in 1980 and still runs the agency today as the principle agent. Her son, Greg Goodnight, recently started working at Gardner, representing the third generation in the family business. As our clients, friends and family know, Gardner Insurance takes pride in our business. We continue to retain our core values and principles as we move forward in the 21st Century of insurance. We have served the Madison community and surrounding areas since the inception of Gardner Insurance, and we continue to pride ourselves on quality service, client loyalty and helping make the best choices for you, our customers.

The GIA Staff enjoyed a delicious lunch today at Red on Main to celebrate Greg and Robin!Happy Birthday to our August cr...
08/28/2026

The GIA Staff enjoyed a delicious lunch today at Red on Main to celebrate Greg and Robin!

Happy Birthday to our August crew!

We're celebrating two August birthdays today!Our office will be closed from 11:45 - 1:45 for a very special birthday lun...
08/28/2026

We're celebrating two August birthdays today!

Our office will be closed from 11:45 - 1:45 for a very special birthday lunch.

Happy Belated Birthday to Robin and Greg!

Don't forget!Thank you for your patience as we updated our phone system. We want to remind you to check your contacts fo...
07/25/2026

Don't forget!

Thank you for your patience as we updated our phone system.

We want to remind you to check your contacts for Gardner Insurance Agency and be sure you have our phone number programmed, as this is our only phone number in use moving forward - 812 265 6166.

The following numbers are no longer in use. Please remove them from your saved contacts:
812 273 5046
812 273 6145

Thank you for your patience as we updated our phone system. We want to remind you to check your contacts for Gardner Ins...
07/09/2026

Thank you for your patience as we updated our phone system.

We want to remind you to check your contacts for Gardner Insurance Agency and be sure you have our phone number programmed, as this is our only phone number in use moving forward - 812 265 6166.

The following numbers are no longer in use. Please remove them from your saved contacts:
812 273 5046
812 273 6145

07/08/2026

Our phone system update is still in process, but you should be able to reach us by phone at 812 265 6166.

If you call and get our voicemail, please leave a message so we can get back to you as soon as possible.

Thank you for your understanding!

07/06/2026

Monday, July 6, 2026:

Our phones are currently still experiencing issues as we work through a system upgrade.

If you need to contact us, please reach out via email to Catrina Bell at [email protected]

We will share updates here - thank you for your patience and understanding!

Wishing you a happy and safe 4th of July and Regatta weekend from the team at Gardner Insurance Agency!
07/03/2026

Wishing you a happy and safe 4th of July and Regatta weekend from the team at Gardner Insurance Agency!

07/02/2026

We're currently experiencing phone issues in our office.

We apologize for the inconvenience if you have been trying to reach us and are working toward a resolution.

If you need to contact us, please reach out via email to Catrina Bell at [email protected]

We will update this post once our phone system is up and running again - thank you for your understanding!

07/02/2026
Check out some great safety tips from our friends at Hastings Insurance Company!We hope you enjoy the fun and festivitie...
06/29/2026

Check out some great safety tips from our friends at Hastings Insurance Company!

We hope you enjoy the fun and festivities of this holiday and stay safe as you celebrate the 4th of July and the Madison Regatta this weekend!

Fireworks are a beautiful celebration of many different holidays, but, they are also the cause of injuries year in and year out. As you and your friends & family celebrate this year, make sure you read over these tips to keep your holiday safe!

Address

606 E Main Street
Madison, IN
47250

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+18122656166

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Gardner Insurance Agency, Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Gardner Insurance Agency, Inc.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category