10/16/2026
When a Kind Gift Becomes a Heavy Burden: What Every Church Should Know Before Accepting a Donated Vehicle
A church passed along a donated car without transferring the title, and a fatal accident led to a multi-year lawsuit. Here is a simple checklist to protect your ministry.
Churches are full of generous people. Someone upgrades their car, remembers the single mom in the congregation who has been catching rides to work, and calls the church office: "Could you use this?" It feels like an answered prayer for everyone involved.
Most of the time, it is. But I want to share a story that has stayed with me, because it shows how quickly a kind act can turn into one of the hardest seasons a ministry ever walks through.
What happened:
A church we worked with accepted a donated vehicle and passed it along to someone who needed a car. Everyone's heart was in the right place. But the title was never transferred into the new driver's name through the DMV. The vehicle was never registered in their name, and they never put their own insurance on it.
Not long after, that driver was in a serious accident. One person died, and another was seriously injured.
Because the paperwork had never been finished, the church found itself pulled into the aftermath. After the wreck, the title was moved from the donor to the church. What followed was a claim and a lawsuit that stretched over several years. It was painful for the families who were hurt, painful for the driver, and painful for a congregation that had only wanted to help.
No one in that church set out to take on that kind of risk. They simply did not realize that until the transfer was complete, the risk had never really left their hands.
The lesson:
Finish the transfer, or say no thank you
When a vehicle changes hands, the question of who is responsible for it follows the paperwork. If the title, registration and insurance are not in the new owner's name, someone else may still be connected to that car, and a church that served as the middleman can end up in the middle of something far bigger than it ever imagined.
So here is the lesson I would offer any pastor, administrator or church board:
Before you hand over the keys to any donated vehicle, the title must be fully transferred into the new owner's name, and you should have proof of their registration and proof of their own insurance.
If your ministry does not have the time or the process to do that every single time, it is perfectly fine to decline vehicle donations. That is not a lack of generosity. It is good stewardship. Your calling is to preach, teach, care and serve. You do not have to become a used-car lot to love your neighbor well. Stay in your ministry lane.
A practical checklist for church leaders:
If your church does decide to accept donated vehicles, here is a simple checklist to walk through every time:
1. Decide your policy before the next offer comes in. Talk it through with your leadership and put it in writing: either "we do not accept vehicle donations" or "we accept them only when every step below is completed."
2. Call your insurance agent before you say yes. Ask how your current policy would respond if a donated vehicle passed through the church's hands, even briefly.
3. Do not hand over the keys until the title is transferred. The title should be fully moved into the new owner's name through the DMV or your county tag office. Not "in process," not "we'll get to it." Done.
4. Get proof of registration in the new owner's name. Keep a copy for your records.
5. Get proof of the new owner's own insurance. Their coverage should be in place before they drive away.
6. Avoid leaving the vehicle in limbo. A car sitting in the church parking lot with an open title, or one that someone is "borrowing until the paperwork is done," is exactly where problems begin.
7. Keep a file. Store copies of the signed title, registration and proof of insurance with your church records.
8. Consider a different way to help. Sometimes the kindest answer is to thank the donor and suggest they sell the vehicle themselves, or give it directly to the person in need, so the church never stands in the middle.
9. Train whoever answers the phone. The staff member or volunteer who takes the call should know your policy, so a well-meaning "Sure, bring it by!" does not commit the church before leadership has a chance to weigh in.
Generosity and wisdom belong together
Scripture calls us to be generous, and it also calls us to be wise. Those two things are not in tension. Taking the time to do things right, or having the courage to say "not this way," protects the people you serve, the people on the road, and the ministry God has entrusted to you.
If you are not sure how your church would be affected if a donated vehicle went wrong, or you would like help putting a simple donation policy in place, we would be glad to talk it through with you. At MinistrySure, helping churches think through situations like this before they happen is what we love to do. Give us a call at (770) 716-0180 or visit us a www.ministrysure.com
No pressure, just a conversation.
Georgia churches, Christian schools, and ministries are all we insure — 700+ of them, since 1989. Request a free coverage review before your renewal.
