02/24/2026
Index products. There is almost always a moving part!
First off, there are some products that actually do guarantee the cap for the entire term of the annuity. This is a great option if you don’t trust the company. But, there is a trade-off in that Rate versus the products that do have moving parts.
Yesterday, we had a conversation with a guy that was talking about a product that he said had “no moving parts“. We had to burst his bubble and explain that although the caps and the participation rates on the product were guaranteed, the underlying index that was used did indeed have a major moving part. It was an excess return index. Nothing wrong with it, but if he truly knew how these things worked, he would not be able to talk about how there are “no moving parts“. An excess return index is basically like a built-in fee that can go up and down with interest rates. Again, I like some of these excess return indexes, but he was misrepresenting it.
In short, don’t be tricked by some of these products because there are two layers in the pricing formula that need to be looked at. The first layer is the product caps, participation rates, etc. The second layer is the underlying index. Carriers have gotten tricky over the years with what is hidden in the underlying index.
I believe that if call option markets are “efficient” over the long run, all of these strategies will perform about the same. My favorite? The plain vanilla S&P 500 strategy. Of course, I analyze the carriers as well. I won’t say who my favorite carriers are here. Message us if you want to have a conversation.
A simple way of looking at how much “juice” is truly applied to the call option budget is to look at what the fixed account rate is on that index product. Of course there are ways to beef up the “juice“ by additional fees, etc..