The Motter Agency

The Motter Agency Established in 1936, The Motter Agency has continued to provide quality insurance to businesses and individuals in Central Pennsylvania for over 70 years.

The Motter Agency provides solutions tailored to the commercial and personal insurance needs of clients in Lycoming, Clinton, Union, Northumberland, Montour, Columbia, Sullivan, Bradford, and Tioga Counties. Gearhart Herr bought the agency in 1976 and today we have six employees in the Jersey Shore office. The Motter Agency is affiliated with the West Branch Susquehanna Builders Association, the A

ssociated Builders and Contractors, the Lycoming County Chamber of Commerce and the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers Association. The Motter Agency is a proud founding member of the Insurance Alliance of Central Pennsylvania. At the Motter Agency, our long-term vision and daily focus on client needs combine to provide a premier level of service to Central Pennsylvania. Our reputation is built on a long history assembling, implementing and maintaining creative solutions for the business and personal insurance needs for companies, individuals and families.

06/01/2026

Bundle vs. package — what’s the difference? If you’re combining your home and auto insurance, this quick guide can help you see how each option works.

For a deeper look, check out the blog: https://wf.insure/48TuEVe

05/01/2026

It was a pleasure hosting the leaders of Gearhart Herr and Company, Inc. as we celebrate a remarkable milestone: 50 years of partnership with Penn National Insurance.

Half a century of shared values, trust, and commitment to serving our community and making life better. Here’s to many more years of success together!

04/15/2026

Producer of the Month/Producer of the Year Congratulations to James Pryde of Doty Hench for being the March winner! Second place goes to Drew Patterson, a Next Generation producer from Christian-Baker Co., and third place goes to Jason Abair of Harding-Yost. 

03/09/2026

👩‍🌾 95 % of U.S. farms are family-owned and operated, and they steward 84 % of farm land across the country.
Behind every field and pasture is a family committed to feeding us at our tables — thank a farmer today! 💚

02/19/2026

Not all homeowners coverage is one-size-fits-all.

This week, is spotlighting homeowners endorsements—the add-ons that can help fill coverage gaps and strengthen your policy where it matters most.

Stick with us for more coverage insights coming soon!

01/26/2026

For the safety of our staff, we will be operating remotely today. You may reach us by our phone for any servicing. Thank you and stay safe today.

01/25/2026

Frozen pipes aren’t just an inconvenience — they can cause real damage to your home or business. ❄️ With extreme cold temperatures approaching, here are five tips to help prevent your pipes from freezing.

Check out our blog to learn more: https://wf.insure/4pLk485

01/13/2026

Car insurance coverage helps protect you from the unexpected. Learn about your coverage options and state requirements. ✓ Get a quote from The Hartford today.

01/07/2026

Stay cozy and safe this winter! ❄️🔥 Before turning up the heat, follow these simple space heater safety tips to keep your home warm and worry-free.

12/30/2025

Have a safe and Happy New Year! We will be closed from 12/31/25 - 1/02/26. We will be back operating at normal business hours Monday 1/05/26.

Address

262 Allegheny Street
Jersey Shore, PA
17740

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 5pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 5pm
Thursday 8:30am - 5pm
Friday 8:30am - 5pm

Telephone

+15703981411

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Motter Agency posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Motter Agency:

Shortcuts

Share

Category