Lancaster Insurance LLC

Lancaster Insurance LLC Family owned and serving the community for over 80 years Lancaster Insurance Agency is honored to have been serving the tri-state area for more than 70 years.

We possess the experience and know how to give you the best insurance products to meet your needs in personal or business ventures. Molly O’Daniel is a 4th Generation insurance management service provider. Our mission is to be your support system and to arm you with accurate information to help you make the right insurance coverage decisions. Whether you are insuring your home, vehicle or business

, we’re here to help protect your future with the expertise our clients have come to expect. As an independent agency, we have the ability to quote each customer with multiple insurance companies that we have relationships with to find our customers the best fit for their needs. What a nice, secure feeling it is to know that you’re fully covered with services from Lancaster Insurance Agency.

Your home is your largest asset, so it's time to treat it like one! Most homeowners spend more time researching their TV...
06/24/2026

Your home is your largest asset, so it's time to treat it like one! Most homeowners spend more time researching their TV purchase than reviewing their homeowner's policy. The TV costs a few hundred dollars. The home costs several hundred thousand. It's time to give the same attention to your home insurance! Learn more on our website, https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/, or call us for assistance: (812) 477-8883!

What is one thing your father taught you that has stayed with you? Share it in the comments, we would love to hear from ...
06/21/2026

What is one thing your father taught you that has stayed with you? Share it in the comments, we would love to hear from our community today. Happy Father's Day to every dad, grandfather and father figure out there.

What is your business worth if you had to rebuild it tomorrow? Not the building. Not the equipment, but the business its...
06/19/2026

What is your business worth if you had to rebuild it tomorrow? Not the building. Not the equipment, but the business itself; the client relationships, the processes, the reputation and the revenue. Business interruption coverage addresses what happens to your income when a covered loss forces your doors closed. Learn more about this coverage on our website, https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/, or call us for more information: (812) 477-8883!

Summer brings significantly more vulnerable road users into the mix, motorcyclists, cyclists, joggers and pedestrians wh...
06/17/2026

Summer brings significantly more vulnerable road users into the mix, motorcyclists, cyclists, joggers and pedestrians who were largely absent during the colder months. Sharing the road safely matters more than ever this time of year, and making sure your liability coverage reflects the increased risk of the summer driving environment is a conversation worth having. Call us to discuss: (812) 477-8883!

A life insurance policy is not for the person who buys it. They will never collect the benefit. But, they buy it knowing...
06/15/2026

A life insurance policy is not for the person who buys it. They will never collect the benefit. But, they buy it knowing that they will never see the return on investment. They buy it to care for their loved ones after they are gone. There are very few financial decisions that mean more than that. Learn more on our website, https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/, or call our team to discuss your options: (812) 477-8883.

Flag Day is not one of the loudest holidays on the calendar, and maybe that is what makes it worth pausing for. It is a ...
06/14/2026

Flag Day is not one of the loudest holidays on the calendar, and maybe that is what makes it worth pausing for. It is a quiet reminder of what this country stands for, what it has been through and the extraordinary people who carried it forward. Happy Flag Day from our team!

There is a fundamental difference between an agent who works for one insurance company and an independent agent who work...
06/10/2026

There is a fundamental difference between an agent who works for one insurance company and an independent agent who works for you. When you call us, we are not trying to fit your life into the products one carrier happens to offer. We are shopping the market on your behalf, asking the right questions, and building a coverage picture that reflects your actual situation. That distinction matters more than most people realize until they need it to. Visit our website to learn more: https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/, or give us a call: (812) 477-8883!

06/09/2026

Good morning! Our phones are working today and we're ready to help you with your insurance needs.

At Lancaster we're not satisfied until you are with your insurance. We have options for home 🏡 auto 🚗 business 🏢 farm 🚜 life and group health plans 📝.

📍Our office is right across from Barnes and Nobles on South Green River Road. Give us a call at 812-477-8883 📞 and see how we've helped hundreds save thousands of dollars on their insurance!

06/08/2026

Hello!
Our phone lines are currently down but we are working on getting that resolved ASAP. We're sorry for the inconvenience and will update you once that is fixed. In the meantime please feel free to email us at [email protected] or stop by our office on South Green River Rd.

The Lancaster Team

The freedom to work, build and look out for one another in this community did not come without cost. Generations of Amer...
06/06/2026

The freedom to work, build and look out for one another in this community did not come without cost. Generations of Americans made sure of that. On this D-Day anniversary, we honor every one of them.

Address

658 S. Green River Road
Evansville, IN
47715

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lancaster Insurance LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category