Lancaster Insurance LLC

Lancaster Insurance LLC Family owned and serving the community for over 80 years Lancaster Insurance Agency is honored to have been serving the tri-state area for more than 70 years.

We possess the experience and know how to give you the best insurance products to meet your needs in personal or business ventures. Molly O’Daniel is a 4th Generation insurance management service provider. Our mission is to be your support system and to arm you with accurate information to help you make the right insurance coverage decisions. Whether you are insuring your home, vehicle or business

, we’re here to help protect your future with the expertise our clients have come to expect. As an independent agency, we have the ability to quote each customer with multiple insurance companies that we have relationships with to find our customers the best fit for their needs. What a nice, secure feeling it is to know that you’re fully covered with services from Lancaster Insurance Agency.

Labor Day weekend travel is quickly approaching! One fender-bender without uninsured motorist coverage can cost you $15,...
09/02/2026

Labor Day weekend travel is quickly approaching! One fender-bender without uninsured motorist coverage can cost you $15,000+ out of pocket. Is your auto policy ready? Call (812) 477-8883 or visit our website: https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/.
Photo by Nabeel Syed () on Unsplash

A life insurance policy purchased before marriage, children, a mortgage and a career trajectory is built around a financ...
08/31/2026

A life insurance policy purchased before marriage, children, a mortgage and a career trajectory is built around a financial picture that no longer exists. The people depending on you today may need significantly more protection than your twenty-something self anticipated. A policy review is not complicated. It is just overdue! We are here to assist, call us today to review: (812) 477-8883.

In honor of National Beach Day, we want to know, what is the beach you keep going back to? The one that feels like yours...
08/30/2026

In honor of National Beach Day, we want to know, what is the beach you keep going back to? The one that feels like yours? Drop it in the comments and tell us what makes it special. We would love to build a list of places worth visiting, courtesy of our community.

Filing a claim with an agency that knows your name, knows your policy and has an existing relationship with your carrier...
08/28/2026

Filing a claim with an agency that knows your name, knows your policy and has an existing relationship with your carrier is a different experience from calling an 800 number and starting from scratch. The relationship your independent agent builds with you before something goes wrong is what makes the process manageable when it does. Get started on our website, https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/, or call us at (812) 477-8883.

Whether your dog is a hundred pound lab who thinks he is a lap dog, a three pound chihuahua with the confidence of somet...
08/26/2026

Whether your dog is a hundred pound lab who thinks he is a lap dog, a three pound chihuahua with the confidence of something much larger, or anything in between, today is their day. From everyone at Lancaster Insurance Agency, happy National Dog Day. Give them something good today. They have earned it.

Wildfire smoke damage has become a relevant coverage question for homeowners well beyond the immediate fire perimeter as...
08/24/2026

Wildfire smoke damage has become a relevant coverage question for homeowners well beyond the immediate fire perimeter as smoke events affect regions hundreds of miles from active fires. Whether smoke infiltration that damages interior air quality, finishes and personal property triggers coverage under a standard homeowner's policy depends on specific policy language and the circumstances of the event. Reach out to review your coverage: (812) 477-8883.

The best commercial insurance program is one you never think about, because it was built correctly, reviewed regularly a...
08/21/2026

The best commercial insurance program is one you never think about, because it was built correctly, reviewed regularly and is sitting exactly where it needs to be when something happens. The goal is not exciting insurance, it's coverage that performs without drama when the moment arrives. We build "boring" insurance programs with great coverage! Let us help you find your policy today: (812) 477-8883 or https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/.

08/20/2026

Our office will be closed today, 8/20. We will open tomorrow, 8/21 at 9:00am.

Full coverage is one of the most commonly used and least defined terms in auto insurance. It generally implies a combina...
08/19/2026

Full coverage is one of the most commonly used and least defined terms in auto insurance. It generally implies a combination of liability, collision and comprehensive coverage, but the specific limits, deductibles and endorsements that make a policy genuinely protective vary enormously. If your policy description is full coverage and you have never examined what that specifically includes, let's review: (812) 477-8883.

Every year of waiting to purchase life insurance costs something. Whether it be a higher premium for the same coverage, ...
08/17/2026

Every year of waiting to purchase life insurance costs something. Whether it be a higher premium for the same coverage, a health development that changes eligibility or the simple risk of the unexpected. There is no better time than right now to find life coverage that fits your needs, and we are here to help you find the right choice. Call us today at (812) 477-8883, or visit our website: https://www.lancasterinsuranceevansville.com/.

Address

658 S. Green River Road
Evansville, IN
47715

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lancaster Insurance LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category