What are the opening hours?

Monday 8am - 4:30pm Tuesday 8am - 4:30pm Wednesday 8am - 4:30pm Thursday 8am - 4:30pm Friday 8am - 4:30pm

Tingley Insurance Agency, Inc.

Home
United States
Effingham, IL
Tingley Insurance Agency, Inc.

Whether you need coverage for your new motorcycle or you’re looking for comprehensive health insurance plan, we can assist you with all your insurance needs.

Your protection is our policy! Tingley Insurance Agency Inc is your full service insurance agency. Our experienced and knowledgeable agents will investigate many companies in order to find you the best plan with the greatest value! With over 20 years of experience, our locally owned and operated agency is sure to provide you and your family or business with personalized, dependable service you can

trust. Call 217-342-3637 today for your FREE quote. Get to know Tingley Insurance Agency Inc:

• Personal Auto – Autos, Motorcycles, Trailers, Campers, ATVs , Boats and more
• Homeowners – Houses, Apartments, Mobile homes, & Farms
• Commercial – Commercial Property, Commercial Vehicles, General liability, Workers Comp, Bonds
•Life / Health – Term-life policies, Whole life policies, Group and Individual health policies

Representing a wide range of insurance companies, including: Cincinnati Insurance Companies, Pekin Insurance, Auto-Owners Insurance, Society Insurance Company, Hastings Mutual, Progressive Insurance, Travelers Insurance, BlueCross BlueShield, and PersonalCare. Agent Contact Information:

Christopher Tingley- President
Life, Personal & Business Insurance
[email protected]

Kathy Powell- Life & Health Agent
Individual/Group Health & Medicare supplements
[email protected]

Martha Vogt- Personal Lines CSR
[email protected]

Emily Bohnhoff- Personal Lines CSR
[email protected]

Emily Aden- Commercial Lines CSR
[email protected]

Mackenzie Seip- Commercial Lines CSR
[email protected]

Jody Probst- Administrative Assistant
[email protected]

Brenda Westjohn- Accountant
[email protected]

05/21/2026

Dress for the slide, not for the ride. 🏍️ Safety isn't just about how you ride; it’s about what you wear before you even start the engine.
• Helmet: Full-face offers the most protection.
• Jacket/Pants: Look for CE-rated armor and abrasion-resistant materials.
• Gloves: Protect your hands from debris and impact.
• Boots: Sturdy, over-the-ankle support is a must.

05/18/2026

Adventure is out there but extra protection is right here. Come by our office to see how we can protect your boat, motorcycle, RV, and other outdoor products.

05/13/2026

Congratulations to all area graduates this week!

We extend special recognition to Camilo Aden (son of Emily & Josh) and Wyatt Probst (son of Jody & Craig) on their high school graduations!

We also send our best wishes to Luke and Meg Roewe (son and daughter of Jen & Kevin) during promotion week as they move on to high school!

Everyone at at Tingley Insurance Agency is proud of each of your accomplishments!

05/10/2026

This Mother’s Day, we celebrate the women who do it all—protectors, planners, problem-solvers, and the heart of every home. 💐

At our agency, we know that being a mom means always thinking ahead and making sure your loved ones are safe and secure. That’s why we’re here—to help you protect what matters most, today and for the future.

To all the moms, grandmothers, and mother figures in our community: thank you for everything you do. You are truly the ultimate life planners. ❤️

Happy Mother’s Day from all of us at Tingley Insurance Agency!

05/07/2026

Even seasoned riders can make mistakes that endanger their lives! Follow these tips ANYTIME you take your bike for a ride ↓

05/04/2026

Spring is in the air—and it’s the perfect time for a fresh start 🌷☀️

As you tackle your spring cleaning checklist, don’t forget about your insurance coverage. Life changes fast—new home projects, travel plans, or even updating your valuables can all impact your protection.

Now’s a great time to review your policies and make sure everything is up to date. We’re here to help you stay covered with confidence all season long.

🌼 Need a quick policy checkup? Reach out today—we’ve got you covered!

04/30/2026

HELLO!!! We are officially BACK from our long, unscreened vacation🤣!!

We've got plenty of exciting updates coming your way --- and this time, we will keep you in the loop! Stay tuned!!

07/03/2024

Tingley Insurance will be closing at 3:30 today to kickoff the Independence Day Holiday.
We will reopen Monday, July 8th with normal 8-4:30 business hours.

We hope everyone has a safe & enjoyable Holiday Weekend. 🇺🇸

01/22/2024

Our lobby will be closing today at 12pm due to the weather & road conditions.

You can still reach us by phone this afternoon at 217-342-3637, until end of normal business day at 4:30pm.

Please stay home & stay safe!

‼️ WE ARE HIRING ‼️Please email bwestjohn@tingleyinsurance.com a copy of your resume.We look forward to having you join ...

03/28/2023

‼️ WE ARE HIRING ‼️

Please email [email protected] a copy of your resume.

We look forward to having you join our team!

11/23/2022

Tingley Insurance will be closed Thursday, November 24th & Friday, November 25th. We will reopen with normal business hours on Monday, November 28th.

Happy Thanksgiving to all!

Address

217 W Jefferson Avenue
Effingham, IL
62401

Opening Hours

Monday	8am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	8am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	8am - 4:30pm
Thursday	8am - 4:30pm
Friday	8am - 4:30pm

Telephone

+12173423637

Website

http://tingleyinsurance.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Tingley Insurance Agency, Inc. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Tingley Insurance Agency, Inc.:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Finance Company in Effingham?