Jeff Daugherty Hometown Insurance

04/24/2026

Voted Best Insurance Agency in Suburban Indy! We didn't say it. The voters did 🏆

We’re incredibly grateful—and honestly a little blown away—to share that we’ve been voted #1 Insurance Agency in Suburban Indy!!

Thank you to our amazing community for trusting us, supporting us, and allowing us to protect what matters most every single day. This recognition means everything because it comes from you!

Keep an eye on your mailbox—today’s edition of is hitting homes, and we’re honored to be featured.

We don’t take this lightly. We’ll keep showing up, working hard, and taking care of our clients like neighbors—because that’s exactly what you are.

Thank you again for being part of our story.

03/11/2026

This five star review said it best.
Real service. Real help. Real results.

If you want an insurance team that takes care of you, give us a call today. Let’s see if we can earn your five-star review next.

03/08/2024

Just a little PSA. You might not know that if you have roadside through your insurance and you use that service for a tow, flat tire, etc. That will go down on your record as a claim. I just quoted someone and they used that service 5 times and they had 5 claims that they were unaware of. I highly suggest getting a AAA membership so if you need roadside it won't raise your rates. If your interested give me a call 317-689-6869. Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk.

11/09/2022

Ladies and gentlemen I would like to introduce the official mascot of the agency. Can you tell he absolutely hates it when I work from home😂.