Gardner & Strayer Insurance Group

Gardner & Strayer Insurance Group Offering the best auto insurance, life insurance, homeowners insurance and business insurance in Sanduskey and Bellevue Ohio.

Our agency has grown to become one of the leading independent agencies in North Central Ohio by associating with many of the nation’s top insurers which has made us capable of insuring some of Ohio’s largest companies. Our agency has been an innovator in developing specialty programs tailored to only the best businesses in their industry. These exclusive programs have allowed our agency to bring o

ur customers a unique product that helps them in their quest to stand taller than their competition. Our specialty programs can provide protection in any state, and can include risk management services, consulting services, employee benefits, bonding, and insurance products. Gardner & Strayer Insurance Group provides all customers with the highest quality of service. We strive to ensure that we fulfill all the needs of each one of our customers. With 2 locations, Bellevue and Sandusky, we are able to respond to any situation that might arise. We are committed to providing each customer with the information you need to make the right decision when it comes to protecting your family, home, autos, property, and businesses. Regardless of your specific insurance needs, we will take the time to help your maximize your insurance program with available cost saving features and discounts. Our agency is comprised of one of the most knowledgeable and skilled team of insurance and customer service experts. Our focus is making a difference, one customer at a time. Call today to arrange an appointment with one of our team members. If you can't make it to our office, we will come to you!

🏈 BIG GAME. BIG SAVINGS. BIG PROTECTION. 🏈While you're cheering on your team, make sure your home, auto, and business ar...
02/03/2026

🏈 BIG GAME. BIG SAVINGS. BIG PROTECTION. 🏈

While you're cheering on your team, make sure your home, auto, and business are protected with the right coverage!

At Gardner & Strayer Insurance, we shop multiple carriers to find the best protection for what matters most to you — without the stress.

✅ Better rates
✅ Local, personal service
✅ Coverage that actually fits your life

Don’t wait for a fumble to realize you’re underinsured.
📞 Call us today at 419-483-6620 for a free coverage review!

🎄✨ Holiday Hours Announcement ✨🎄Gardner & Strayer would like to wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a Happy N...
12/23/2025

🎄✨ Holiday Hours Announcement ✨🎄

Gardner & Strayer would like to wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

Please take note of our holiday office hours:

🎅 Christmas Hours
• Wednesday, December 24 – Closing at 1:00 PM
• Thursday, December 25 – Closed
• Friday, December 26 – Closed

🎆 New Year’s Hours
• Wednesday, December 31 – Closing at 3:00 PM
• Thursday, January 1 – Closed
• Friday, January 2 – Closed

Thank you for trusting Gardner & Strayer this year. We wish you a joyful, safe, and peaceful holiday season! 💫

Behind every policy is a team that truly cares. Meet the faces at Gardner & Strayer who are dedicated to protecting what...
09/11/2025

Behind every policy is a team that truly cares. Meet the faces at Gardner & Strayer who are dedicated to protecting what matters most to you. 💼✨

We Remember. We Honor. We Never Forget. 🇺🇸Today, on the anniversary of September 11, 2001, we pause to honor the lives l...
09/11/2025

We Remember. We Honor. We Never Forget. 🇺🇸

Today, on the anniversary of September 11, 2001, we pause to honor the lives lost, the heroes who ran toward danger, and the families forever changed.

At Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency, we are grateful for the resilience of our nation and the strength of our community. May we continue to stand united, remembering the importance of compassion, courage, and care for one another.

08/12/2025

At Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency in Bellevue, we believe insurance is about more than numbers and paperwork — it’s about people. It’s about protecting your family, your business, your home, and your future.

Whether you’re just starting out, growing your business, or planning for the years ahead, we’re here to make sure you have the coverage you need before you need it.

🛡 Personal Insurance
From your car and home to your valuables and recreational vehicles, we’ll help you find the right protection to fit your lifestyle.

🏢 Commercial Insurance
Your business is your livelihood, and we take that seriously. We offer tailored coverage for small businesses, contractors, retail shops, farms, and more — so you can focus on running your business, not worrying about risk.

Why choose Gardner & Strayer?
✅ Local, friendly agents who know our community
✅ A variety of trusted insurance carriers to give you options
✅ Personalized service you won’t find with 1-800 numbers or chatbots
✅ Peace of mind knowing we’re here to advocate for YOU when you need us most

Life changes — and your insurance should change with it. From the everyday moments to life’s biggest milestones, Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency is here to protect what matters most to you.

📍 Stop by our Bellevue office or give us a call today. Let’s review your coverage and make sure you’re prepared for whatever comes next.

📞 Phone: (419) 483-6620
🏢 Address: 114 E Main Street, Bellevue, OH 44811

Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency – Your Protection. Our Promise.

🎆 The 4th of July is almost here — is your holiday plan protected? 🎇At Gardner and Strayer Insurance Agency, we’re here ...
06/30/2025

🎆 The 4th of July is almost here — is your holiday plan protected? 🎇

At Gardner and Strayer Insurance Agency, we’re here to help you prepare so you can focus on celebrating with peace of mind. Whether you’re hosting a backyard barbecue, traveling for the long weekend, or enjoying fireworks with family — we’re just a call away to review your coverage and answer your questions.

✨ Before the celebrations begin, remember:
✅ Check that your home and auto policies are up to date
✅ Practice firework and grill safety
✅ Make a plan for safe travel

Let’s make this Independence Day safe and memorable together!
📞 Call us at (419) 483-6620 to review your coverage before the holiday.

06/26/2025

🔈🔊🔈🔊🔈🔊
Big and exciting news ❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️

Gardner & Lindsey Insurance Agency, Inc. partners with Nationwide to protect farms in Northern Ohio.
Anthony Gardner, an independent Insurance agent based in Willard, is proud to announce a new partnership with Nationwide as an appointed provider of farm insurance at Gardner and Lindsey Insurance. This collaboration brings local farmers in Northern Ohio access to comprehensive coverage customized to the unique needs of their operations.
"By partnering with Nationwide, I'm excited to offer tailored coverage options that meet the unique needs of farmers," said Anthony. "Nationwide commitment to protection aligns perfectly with my goal of helping you secure the future of your farm."
-Nationwide, one of the leading farm insurance providers in the country, offers a wide range of benefits to policyholders, including:
-Comprehensive coverage designed to meet the needs of changing farm operations.
-Complimentary risk management services to help you identify and reduce hazards.
-Dedicated claims professionals committed to getting you back to business.
-Commitment to community with programs and partnerships to support the safety and future of the industry.

Farmers interested in learning more or scheduling a personalized consultation can contact Anthony at 419-933-2051 or [email protected]. Together, we'll work to build a more secure future for your farm.

At Gardner & Lindsey Insurance Agency, Inc., we are committed to insuring you, your farms, and your loved ones with the proper coverage. Our dedication is to your satisfaction.

🌪️ After the Storm, We're Here for You 💙To our friends in Bellevue and surrounding communities— we hope you and your lov...
06/19/2025

🌪️ After the Storm, We're Here for You 💙
To our friends in Bellevue and surrounding communities— we hope you and your loved ones are safe. Last night’s storms caused significant damage across the area. We know how unsettling it can be to wake up to storm damage. Whether it’s a leaky roof, downed trees, or power loss, you don’t have to face it alone.

At Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency, we’re here for you.
We’re ready to help you assess the damage, file your claim, and get on the path to recovery—quickly and with confidence.

📋 What to Do Now:
✅ Take photos of any storm-related damage
✅ Make temporary repairs if needed to prevent further loss
✅ Keep all receipts for emergency work or materials
✅ Contact us to begin your claim

📞 Call Us: 419-483-6620
🕘 Office Hours: 9 AM to 5 PM
📍 Local, trusted, and here when you need us most

💙 Gardner & Strayer Insurance Agency – We’re here for you. Always.

06/11/2025

💡 Think renter’s insurance is optional? Think again.

Your stuff is worth more than you think. Whether it's theft, fire, or a burst pipe, renter’s insurance helps cover the cost of what you love. Starting at less than a coffee a week, it's peace of mind you can afford.
Don’t wait for “what if?” to become “what now?”

✅ Covers:

Personal belongings

Liability protection

Temporary housing

📦 Simple. Affordable. Essential.

👉 Get a quote today!

🌧️ It's raining now... but what about when life pours? ☔Just like an umbrella keeps you dry in a storm, umbrella insuran...
06/09/2025

🌧️ It's raining now... but what about when life pours? ☔
Just like an umbrella keeps you dry in a storm, umbrella insurance protects you when the unexpected strikes — beyond your auto or home coverage.
💼 Extra liability protection
🚗 Covers major accidents
🏠 Helps when legal bills stack up
Stay safe, stay dry — and stay covered.
Ask us about umbrella insurance today! 🌂

🛑 What Would You Do Without Insurance? 🛠️🚗🏡Life is unpredictable. One minute everything’s fine—the next, you're dealing ...
05/30/2025

🛑 What Would You Do Without Insurance? 🛠️🚗🏡

Life is unpredictable. One minute everything’s fine—the next, you're dealing with a fender bender, storm damage, or worse. That’s why having the right home and auto insurance isn’t just smart—it’s essential.

🔹 Auto Insurance: Covers accidents, theft, weather damage, and liability.
🔹 Home Insurance: Protects your home and belongings from fire, storms, theft, and more.

✅ Peace of mind
✅Financial protection
✅ Help when you need it most
✅ Quick recovery when the unexpected hits

Don’t wait until it’s too late. Make sure you're covered!

📞 Call us today 419-483-6620 for a free quote or policy review. We’ll help you find affordable coverage that fits your life.

Let us quote your Home & Auto Insurance today! 🏡🚗We know insurance shopping can be ruff… but it doesn’t have to be!Wheth...
05/29/2025

Let us quote your Home & Auto Insurance today! 🏡🚗

We know insurance shopping can be ruff… but it doesn’t have to be!
Whether you're looking to bundle and save or just want better coverage for peace of mind, we're here to help — no growling involved. 😄

📞Call us today 419-483-6620 or click the link below to get a fast, friendly quote.
Because your home and car deserve the best protection (and so do you)!

📍 To get a quote for your auto click here: 🚘🚖🚙
https://app.usecanopy.com/c/auto-info-gathering

📍 To get a quote for your home click here: 🏠🏡🏘
https://app.usecanopy.com/c/homeowners-info-gathering

Address

114 E Main Street
Bellevue, OH
44811

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+14194836620

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Gardner & Strayer Insurance Group posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Gardner & Strayer Insurance Group:

Shortcuts

Share

Category