What are the opening hours?

Monday 9am - 5pm Tuesday 9am - 5pm Wednesday 9am - 5pm Thursday 9am - 5pm Friday 9am - 5pm

Rumsey Sustar Insurance

Home
United States
Aurora, OH
Rumsey Sustar Insurance

Providing our clients the freedom to choose. We work to find you the best fit for your insurance needs.

08/31/2026

🚐 Your RV is made for adventure. Your insurance should be ready for the unexpected.

Whether you’re heading out for a weekend getaway, taking a cross-country road trip, or enjoying the freedom of the open road, your RV is more than just a vehicle—it’s a home away from home.

RV insurance can help protect your investment from accidents, theft, weather damage, and more. Because the last thing you want on your next adventure is an insurance surprise.

Before you hit the road, make sure your coverage is along for the ride. 🛣️

📲 Contact Rumsey Sustar Insurance to review your RV coverage and make sure you’re properly protected. 330-708-2800

08/24/2026

🚗 Getting a New Car? Your Insurance Update Can Be Simple!

The excitement of driving home in a new car shouldn’t be overshadowed by paperwork. When you’re buying a new vehicle, give Rumsey Sustar Insurance a call. We’ll help make sure your coverage is updated and your new ride is properly protected.

One simple call can help keep you covered from driveway to destination. 🛡️

New car. New adventure. Same great insurance team.

08/17/2026

A fender bender is stressful enough without having to figure out how you’re going to get around while your vehicle is being repaired.

One simple way to prepare? Make sure your auto insurance policy includes rental car coverage. That way, if an accident leaves your vehicle in the shop, you have transportation without having to rely on Uber, Lyft—or constantly ask friends and family for rides. 😉

Not sure if you have rental car coverage? Give Rumsey Sustar Insurance a call and let’s review your policy before you need it!

📞 Be prepared today. Your future self will thank you!

08/10/2026

⛈️ Mother Nature made quite an entrance this morning!

Those thunderstorms brought plenty of rain, wind, and a reminder that severe weather can happen in an instant.

After a storm, take a few minutes to check your property for damage—especially your roof, siding, gutters, windows, and any areas where water may have gotten in. 📸 Document what you find, and if you’re unsure whether the damage is covered by your policy, give your insurance agent a call.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we’re here to help you understand your coverage before you need it—and help you navigate what comes next when unexpected weather strikes.

Stay safe, stay dry, and let’s hope the rest of the day is a little quieter! 🌧️

08/03/2026

Life insurance isn’t just about planning for the unexpected—it’s about protecting the people and plans that matter most. ❤️

Whether you’re starting a family, buying a home, building a business, or simply want to make sure your loved ones are financially protected, life insurance can play an important role in your overall financial plan.

The right coverage can help provide peace of mind today and financial security for tomorrow.

Have questions about your life insurance options? The team at Rumsey Sustar Insurance is here to help you understand your choices and find coverage that fits your needs.

📞 Let’s talk about protecting what matters most. 330-708-2800

07/27/2026

Running your business from home doesn’t mean your business risks stay outside the front door.

Many home-based business owners assume their homeowners insurance will fully protect their business equipment, inventory, or liability claims. Unfortunately, that’s often not the case.

Whether you’re a consultant, online retailer, freelancer, or service provider, the right business insurance can help protect everything you’ve worked so hard to build. From property coverage to liability protection, having the proper policy in place provides peace of mind so you can focus on growing your business.

Don’t let a claim put your business and personal finances at risk. Rumsey Sustar Insurance can help you find coverage designed for the way you work.

🏡 Home office. 💻 Real business. 🛡️ Real protection.

07/20/2026

🏡 Your home is where life happens — make sure your belongings are protected!

Whether you’re renting an apartment, condo, or house, renters insurance can help protect your personal belongings from unexpected events like theft, fire, or certain types of damage.

Plus, renters insurance may provide liability protection if someone is injured while visiting your home.

Don’t wait until something happens to find out you’re not covered. Let Rumsey Sustar Insurance help you find the right protection for your needs.

📲 Contact us today and make sure your home and belongings have the coverage they deserve! 330-708-2800

07/13/2026

🐶🐱 Because your pet’s only job is to be cute… not create a surprise vet bill! 😂

Our furry family members bring us endless tail wags, purrs, snuggles, and a little bit of chaos. 🐾 But when the unexpected happens, pet insurance can help take some of the stress (and cost) out of those “uh-oh” moments.

From puppy zoomie injuries to curious kitty adventures, having coverage means you can focus on the important stuff — belly rubs, treats, and getting your best friend back to feeling their best. ❤️

Give your four-legged family member the protection they deserve. Talk to Rumsey Sustar Insurance about pet insurance options today!

🐾 Because every good dog deserves a happy ending… and every cat deserves to keep ruling the house. 👑🐈

07/07/2026

🎓 College move-in season is almost here!

As you're checking off the packing list—bedding, books, and snacks—don't forget one important item: renters insurance.

Whether your student is living in a dorm or off-campus apartment, renters insurance can help protect their personal belongings from theft, fire, water damage, and other unexpected events. It may also provide liability coverage if someone is injured in their living space.

Not sure if your homeowner's policy already provides coverage or if it's time for a separate renters policy? We're happy to help you understand your options and make sure your college student is protected before move-in day.

📞 Reach out to the team at Rumsey Sustar Insurance today and head into the school year with confidence! 330-708-2800

07/04/2026

🇺🇸 Happy 4th of July from Rumsey Sustar Insurance 🇺🇸

As we gather with family, friends, and neighbors to celebrate our nation’s independence, we want to take a moment to wish everyone a safe and joyful 4th of July!

From backyard barbecues to fireworks lighting up the night sky, may your day be filled with laughter, gratitude, and pride in the freedoms we share.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we’re proud to serve our community and grateful for the trust you place in us year-round. We wish you a holiday full of celebration—and safety in every moment.

🎆 Happy Independence Day! 🇺🇸

Address

199 S Chillicothe Road
Aurora, OH
44202

Opening Hours

Monday	9am - 5pm
Tuesday	9am - 5pm
Wednesday	9am - 5pm
Thursday	9am - 5pm
Friday	9am - 5pm

Telephone

+13307082800

Website

http://www.rsiagents.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rumsey Sustar Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Rumsey Sustar Insurance:

Want your business to be the top-listed Finance Company in Aurora?