Rumsey Sustar Insurance

Rumsey Sustar Insurance Providing our clients the freedom to choose. We work to find you the best fit for your insurance needs.

Life is full of milestones, surprises, and changes. Having the right life insurance coverage can help provide financial ...
06/01/2026

Life is full of milestones, surprises, and changes. Having the right life insurance coverage can help provide financial security for the people who matter most to you.

Whether you're starting a family, buying a home, planning for the future, or simply reviewing your current coverage, life insurance is an important part of a well-rounded financial plan.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we're here to help you explore your options and find coverage that fits your needs and goals.

📞 Contact our team today to learn more about protecting your loved ones with life insurance. 330-708-2800

Today we honor and remember the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom. Their courage and s...
05/25/2026

Today we honor and remember the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom. Their courage and service will never be forgotten. Wishing everyone a safe and meaningful Memorial Day as we reflect with gratitude. 🇺🇸

Nothing says holiday weekend like sun, open water, and a boat cutting through the waves.Whether you’re heading out on La...
05/18/2026

Nothing says holiday weekend like sun, open water, and a boat cutting through the waves.

Whether you’re heading out on Lake Erie or cruising your favorite local spot, it’s the perfect time to slow down, soak it in, and make some memories on the water. Just don’t forget the essentials—life jackets, safe boating practices, and making sure your coverage is ready before you untie from the dock.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we help boaters feel confident that if the unexpected happens, they’re not left drifting. From liability to physical damage coverage, we’ve got the details covered so you can focus on the fun part.

Here’s to smooth seas, safe rides, and a great holiday weekend out on the water. 🚤☀️

🏡 When was the last time you reviewed your homeowners insurance policy?Life changes — and your coverage should keep up. ...
05/11/2026

🏡 When was the last time you reviewed your homeowners insurance policy?

Life changes — and your coverage should keep up. Whether you’ve renovated your home, purchased valuable items, welcomed a new family member, or simply haven’t reviewed your policy in a while, now is a great time to make sure you’re properly protected.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we’re here to help you understand your coverage and identify any gaps before the unexpected happens.

A quick policy review today can help provide peace of mind tomorrow. Contact us to schedule your homeowners insurance review! 🏠🔍

Your pet is family—so why not protect them like it? 🐾Unexpected vet bills can add up quickly, but pet insurance helps yo...
05/04/2026

Your pet is family—so why not protect them like it? 🐾
Unexpected vet bills can add up quickly, but pet insurance helps you stay focused on what matters most: your furry friend’s health and happiness. From routine care to emergencies, having coverage in place can bring peace of mind when you need it most.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we’re here to help you explore options that fit your pet’s needs and your budget. Because they’re more than pets—they’re part of the family. ❤️

📞 Let’s talk about coverage that keeps tails wagging! 330-708-2800

☀️ Lake days are better on a Jet Ski! Before you hit the water this summer, make sure your fun is protected with the rig...
04/27/2026

☀️ Lake days are better on a Jet Ski! Before you hit the water this summer, make sure your fun is protected with the right insurance coverage. From accidents and damage to liability protection, having the right policy can help keep your summer stress-free. 🌊

Rumsey Sustar Insurance can help you find coverage so you can ride with confidence all season long.

Ready to make waves? Contact us today! 🚤

Revved up and ready for adventure? Dirt bikes bring excitement, freedom, and fun—but they also come with risks. Whether ...
04/20/2026

Revved up and ready for adventure? Dirt bikes bring excitement, freedom, and fun—but they also come with risks. Whether you're hitting the trails or riding on private property, make sure you're protected before you twist the throttle.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we can help you explore coverage options for your dirt bike, gear, and liability needs so you can ride with confidence.

Adventure is better when you're covered. Contact us today to learn more! 330-708-2800

Ready for riding season? 🌲🏍️Before you take your four wheeler out on the trails, make sure you’re properly protected. Ac...
04/13/2026

Ready for riding season? 🌲🏍️

Before you take your four wheeler out on the trails, make sure you’re properly protected. Accidents can happen in an instant—and having the right ATV coverage can help protect you, your ride, and your peace of mind.

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we can help you find coverage options tailored for your four wheeler so you can ride with confidence all season long.

Let’s make sure you’re covered before you hit the trails—because the only thing you should be focused on is the adventure ahead.

🌷🐣 Happy Easter from all of us at Rumsey Sustar Insurance! 🐰🌼Wishing you a day filled with joy, renewal, and time spent ...
04/05/2026

🌷🐣 Happy Easter from all of us at Rumsey Sustar Insurance! 🐰🌼

Wishing you a day filled with joy, renewal, and time spent with the people who matter most. May this season of new beginnings bring you happiness, peace, and a little extra sunshine.

We’re grateful for the opportunity to serve and protect what matters most to you—today and every day.

Have a safe and wonderful Easter! 💛

Boating season is right around the corner—and there’s nothing better than getting back out on the water! 🚤☀️Before you s...
03/30/2026

Boating season is right around the corner—and there’s nothing better than getting back out on the water! 🚤☀️

Before you set sail, it’s the perfect time to take a closer look at your boat insurance policy. Are you fully covered? Could you be saving money?

At Rumsey Sustar Insurance, we’re here to help you review your coverage, identify any gaps, and make sure you’re getting the best value for your protection.

Let’s make sure smooth sailing starts before you even leave the dock. 🌊

📞 Reach out today for a quick policy review! 330-708-2800

Address

199 S Chillicothe Road
Aurora, OH
44202

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+13307082800

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rumsey Sustar Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Rumsey Sustar Insurance:

Shortcuts

Share

Category