Mathews Insurance, Inc

Mathews Insurance, Inc Full Service Independent Insurance Agency FRIENDLY, RELIABLE & LOCAL. A friend you can rely on. For your car, home, business, and life Mathews Insurance, Inc.

has it all for you at one of our two locations. From our offices in Athens, Ohio and McConnelsville, Ohio we serve the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Southeastern Ohio. As an independent insurance agency, we represent many top rated insurance companies. We're here for you locally, 24/7 via our website or by calling us at the location nearest you:
Mathews Insurance, Inc

Athens, Ohio (740) 593-5573
James Insurance Agency McConnelsville, Ohio (740) 962-9900
We strive to provide you with the right insurance protection, superior claim service when you need it and the essential convenience of a local office. Mathews Insurance, Inc. is proud to serve you!

September is Life Insurance Awareness Month!Take a few minutes this month to review your coverage and make sure your lov...
09/02/2026

September is Life Insurance Awareness Month!

Take a few minutes this month to review your coverage and make sure your loved ones are properly protected or contact us today for a life insurance quote.

Because protecting your family’s future is one of the most important things you can do for them.

A huge thank you to our amazing client for taking the time to recognize Brenda and Jill! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐As a small, independent ag...
08/31/2026

A huge thank you to our amazing client for taking the time to recognize Brenda and Jill! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

As a small, independent agency, reviews like yours truly help us grow. They not only encourage our team, but they also help others in our community feel confident choosing an agency that puts people first.

If we've helped you with your insurance, we'd love to hear about your experience!
- https://mathewsinsurance.com/contact/review-us/

As an independent insurance agency, we don’t work for just one company. We compare coverage options from multiple insura...
08/28/2026

As an independent insurance agency, we don’t work for just one company.

We compare coverage options from multiple insurance carriers to help find the right protection for your home, auto, business, and more.

Let us shop your insurance and find coverage that fits your needs.

- (740)593-5573
- www.mathewsinsurancee.com

We were so happy to have the opportunity to support the Nelsonville Parade of the Hills Annual Pie Auction!We proudly do...
08/24/2026

We were so happy to have the opportunity to support the Nelsonville Parade of the Hills Annual Pie Auction!

We proudly donated a USA themed cherry pie, beautifully made by the incredibly talented Terri W.

We love supporting our local community and the events that make Southeast Ohio so special. Thank you to everyone who helps make Parade of the Hills such a wonderful tradition!

What a great evening at the Nelsonville Area Chamber of Commerce Nash Bash last night!Agents Chase and Mallory had a won...
08/19/2026

What a great evening at the Nelsonville Area Chamber of Commerce Nash Bash last night!

Agents Chase and Mallory had a wonderful time celebrating local businesses and community members while also kicking off the Nelsonville Parade of the Hills!
A special shoutout to Mallory, who serves as Secretary for the Nelsonville Area Chamber, and to the Chamber for all the work they do to support local businesses and our community.

Our agency also partnered with Black Diamond Brewery & Distillery to provide a donated raffle basket for the evening. Thank you to everyone who helped make the event such a success!

Many homeowners are surprised to learn that flooding caused by rising water is typically not covered by a standard homeo...
08/17/2026

Many homeowners are surprised to learn that flooding caused by rising water is typically not covered by a standard homeowner's policy.

Don’t wait until the water rises to find out you needed coverage.

Contact us today for a Flood Insurance Quote!

Having the right insurance is important, but understanding your coverage is just as important.Let our team help you revi...
08/14/2026

Having the right insurance is important, but understanding your coverage is just as important.

Let our team help you review your policies and make sure you’re protected before the unexpected happens. 🏡🚗🛡️

As an annual Platinum Sponsor of the Athens County Board of Realtors, we’re proud to support an organization that streng...
08/13/2026

As an annual Platinum Sponsor of the Athens County Board of Realtors, we’re proud to support an organization that strengthens our region and helps connect people with the place they call home. ACBOR’s commitment to bringing REALTORS® together with the businesses and professionals who support their clients is something we deeply value.

Today, two of our Mathews Insurance agents are at the ACBOR Expo in Middleport building relationships, supporting local REALTORS®, and celebrating the shared work we all do to serve our community. We’re grateful for this partnership and excited to be part of an event that brings so many dedicated professionals together.

Life changes. Your insurance should too. 🏡🚗Make sure your coverage still fits your needs and protects the things you’ve ...
08/11/2026

Life changes. Your insurance should too. 🏡🚗

Make sure your coverage still fits your needs and protects the things you’ve worked hard for.

Contact us today for a personalized insurance review or quote!

Address

240 Columbus Road
Athens, OH
45701

Opening Hours

Monday 7:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 7:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 7:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 7:30am - 4pm

Telephone

+17405935573

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mathews Insurance, Inc posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category