What are the opening hours?

Monday 7:30am - 4:30pm Tuesday 7:30am - 4:30pm Wednesday 7:30am - 4:30pm Thursday 7:30am - 4:30pm Friday 7:30am - 4pm

Mathews Insurance, Inc

Home
United States
Athens, OH
Mathews Insurance, Inc

Call Directions Website

Full Service Independent Insurance Agency FRIENDLY, RELIABLE & LOCAL. A friend you can rely on. For your car, home, business, and life Mathews Insurance, Inc.

has it all for you at one of our two locations. From our offices in Athens, Ohio and McConnelsville, Ohio we serve the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Southeastern Ohio. As an independent insurance agency, we represent many top rated insurance companies. We're here for you locally, 24/7 via our website or by calling us at the location nearest you:
Mathews Insurance, Inc Athens, Ohio (740) 593-5573
James Insurance Agency McConnelsville, Ohio (740) 962-9900
We strive to provide you with the right insurance protection, superior claim service when you need it and the essential convenience of a local office. Mathews Insurance, Inc. is proud to serve you!

10/14/2026

The scariest thing this Halloween isn't a haunted house… it's finding out you don't have the coverage you thought you did! 👻

Let us help you review your coverage before the unexpected comes knocking.
- (740) 593-5573
- www.MathewsInsurance.com

10/11/2026

Happy Birthday, Brooke! 🎂

We hope your day is filled with good food, lots of laughs, and absolutely no work-related stress! We’re so glad to have you on our team and hope you have the best birthday! Cheers to another great year! 🥳

10/08/2026

Today, we’re celebrating an incredible milestone for Karla, as she has spent an amazing 45 years with our agency!

We are so thankful for the years of hard work, dedication, knowledge, and care you have given to our team and our clients. 45 years is an amazing accomplishment, and we’re lucky to have had you as such an important part of our office for so many years.

Thank you for everything you do and for all the memories you’ve helped create along the way. Here’s to 45 years and counting! 🥂🎉

10/07/2026

We’re here to protect your journey, wherever life takes you.

Your life changes, your needs change, and your auto insurance should keep up.

Contact us today for an auto insurance quote!
- (740) 593-5573
- www.mathewsinsurance.com

10/05/2026

Happy Birthday, Sharon! 🎂

We’re so thankful to have you as part of the Mathews Insurance team. We hope your birthday is filled with all the things that make you happiest. You deserve it!

Here’s to another great year ahead! 🎈

10/02/2026

We are so excited to announce that Mallory Swaim is officially our newest Agency Partner! 🥳

Mallory has been a valued part of our team for over 10 years, and throughout that time, she has consistently shown dedication, hard work, and a genuine commitment to our clients and our agency.

This new position is so well deserved, and we couldn’t be prouder to see Mallory take this next step. She has worked incredibly hard to get here, and we are excited to see all that the future holds!

Please join us in congratulating Mallory on becoming an Agency Partner!

09/29/2026

Today, we celebrate someone who has given so much of their time, dedication, and heart to our team. ❤️

After years of hard work and commitment, we are wishing Brenda James a very happy retirement!

Your contributions have made a lasting impact on our agency, our clients, and everyone who has had the pleasure of working alongside you. We are incredibly grateful for all the memories, laughter, hard work, and dedication you have shared with us over the years.

While we will certainly miss having you here, we are so excited for you to begin this new chapter and enjoy all that retirement has to offer!

Congratulations, Brenda! You’ve earned it! 🎉🥂

09/28/2026

On Saturday, Chase had the privilege of attending the Walk to End Alzheimer’s! 💜

We’re so thankful for the opportunity to meet so many wonderful people in our community and hear the stories and reasons that brought everyone together for this special event.

It was truly inspiring to see our community come together to support such an important cause. We can’t wait to see you all again next year!

If you would still like to donate to this important cause, you can do so through the link below! 👇
https://www.alz.org/

09/27/2026

Help us wish one of our amazing team members a very Happy Birthday! 🥳 We’re so thankful to have you as part of our team.

We hope your day is filled with lots of happiness, laughter, and maybe a little cake, too! 🎂🎈

Happy Birthday, Chase!

Address

240 Columbus Road
Athens, OH
45701

Opening Hours

Monday	7:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	7:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	7:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday	7:30am - 4:30pm
Friday	7:30am - 4pm

Telephone

+17405935573

Website

http://www.MathewsInsurance.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mathews Insurance, Inc posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed finance company in Athens?