20/01/2023
To everyone who celebrates, happy Chinese New Year!
Once again, it is that joyous time of the year for us to gather with our friends and family.
Yet, this also marks the time for us to think (or fret) about how much Ang Bao we intend to give to our relatives.
According to online guides, one red packet can go up to $888 for each of our parents and up to $288 for each of our siblings, children & grandchildren!
Phew, good thing that I am at an age where I still get to collect Ang Baos.
But…I want you to consider this, imagine if you could be the one receiving an Ang Bao every month for the rest of your life, even when it is not CNY.
Wouldn't that be great?
Imagine how useful that will be when you are no longer working and want to enjoy your retirement without having to worry about whether you will have sufficient money left for the next month.
You may be thinking that this is too good to be true.
Yet, in fact, there is a financial instrument that allows you to receive cash every month, which is none other than an annuity.
(In the previous few posts, we have thoroughly discussed how you can generate a steady stream of income for yourself via CPF Life. So you may want to check those out as well.)
The picture on the 4th image illustrates how an annuity works - you put in a lump sum of money at the start, and in return you will receive regular payments over a period of time.
This is similar to how CPF Life works.
Annuities are especially useful for those of us who want a higher monthly income when we retire.
That is because CPF Life gives a maximum payout of up to $2,370/month under the Enhanced Retirement Sum (ERS). This amount is probably not enough for most of us to sustain the kind of retirement lifestyle we want, especially after taking into account inflation. (and also, that is assuming we hit the ERS in our Retirement Account (RA))
Most of us will probably want to treat ourselves when we retire. Maybe we have plans to go overseas, try out new hobbies and who knows what else may be on our bucket list (literally, as a list of things we want to do before we kick the bucket.)
To gain greater assurance that we will have enough income every month during our retirement, or simply to have a higher quality of life, one can consider topping up their income with an annuity.
In addition, annuities have many more features that are customisable.
1. Payout Start Date
One of the most important features include giving you the option to choose when you want your payouts to start.
Some annuities allow you to start your payouts from as young as 50 years old, or even a few years after you put in the initial sum.
This is especially useful for those looking to retire as soon as possible and rely on a passive income stream that effectively replaces their monthly salary.
In contrast, the earliest one can start their CPF Life payouts is at the age of 65.
2. Option to reinvest payouts instead of withdrawing them
When your annuity starts giving you monthly payouts at your chosen retirement age, you may or may not need the entire sum of the payout.
In that case, for some annuities, you can choose to reinvest the payout with the issuer of the annuity.
This will allow the payout to compound and grow to a greater value which you can then withdraw in the future when the need arises.
In contrast, we cannot reinvest payouts from CPF Life back into our RA.
That means that if we have no use for the payout, we will most likely be leaving the money in a savings account which compounds at a much lower return.
3. Intergenerational Wealth Transfer
Another significant advantage that annuities have over CPF Life is the ability to benefit both your children and grandchildren, while at the same time, supplementing your own retirement income.
On top of our own retirement needs, some of us may also want a peace of mind that our loved ones can continue to lead a financially stable life after we pass on.
If that is one of our concerns, this feature that annuities provide may be especially appealing. And that is the option to transfer the income stream we receive from annuities to our intended beneficiaries after we pass on.
In other words, so long as we are still well and alive, we will be able to continue receiving the monthly payouts. When we pass on, our children, spouse or other relatives (up to your choice) will be the ones receiving this income stream.
And, this transfer of wealth across generations does not end there.
Suppose this income stream has been transferred to your children after you pass on. When your children pass on, there will be a lump sum passed on to your children’s intended beneficiaries (which could be their own children (i.e. your grandchildren), their spouse/siblings, etc.)
Not only does this allow us to pursue our ideal retirement lifestyle, it is also a lasting gift that will enrich the life of up to two generations.
This is especially attractive for those of us who wish to leave behind a legacy for our future generations.
In contrast, under CPF Life, the bequest left behind for beneficiaries will decrease over time.
Most of the time, once you are past 80 years old, there will not be any money left behind for your beneficiaries when you pass on.
4. Liquidity
While not recommended, private annuity plans also allow for policyholders to surrender their policy prematurely.
The ability to withdraw cash from policy whenever needed is especially important in the case of an unexpected emergency or events that may arise.
In contrast, CPF Life is an illiquid instrument as we are unable to withdraw sums that were committed to CPF Life in our RA.
Now that we know the benefits that annuities can give us, we should also be aware of its downsides.
1. Potentially Higher Returns, but Non-Guaranteed
While annuities can give a higher return than the risk-free 4% return that CPF RA gives, the return from annuities is typically a combination of guaranteed and non-guaranteed returns.
Having a non-guaranteed portion means that it can go either way - if the fund does well, annuities can give a higher return than CPF Life and vice versa.
That being said, most annuities invest in low-risk funds that are mostly comprised of bonds.
It will be useful to check the past performance of the funds as a proxy of the competence of the fund managers.
2. Early Liquidation is Disadvantageous
While one of the advantages that annuities offer over CPF Life is its liquidity, surrendering an annuity prematurely comes with certain penalties.
For instance, if you surrender your annuity in the first few years, there is a high chance that the payout (or what is known as surrender value) will be less than your premiums paid.
Therefore, you should set aside about 3 to 6 months of your monthly expenses as an emergency fund before investing in an annuity.
Doing so will reduce the likelihood of having to liquidate our policies in the future.
Therefore, annuities are useful for those who want:
(i) Higher Monthly Income During Retirement
(ii) The option to transfer this income stream to our intended beneficiaries after our death
(iii) To retire early (before 65)
(iv) The potential to earn more than you saved
- The total payouts that you receive may be greater than the initial sum you put in, depending on how long you live
- In addition, leveraged annuities can potentially allow you to receive a much higher monthly payout with the same amount of capital (although this strategy comes with own sets of risks that you should be familiar with)
(v) To stretch their Supplementary Retirement Scheme (SRS) withdrawals beyond 10 years
- The allowable withdrawal period for SRS is only 10 years. That means, at the end of 10 years from our prescribed retirement age, whatever money that we have yet to withdraw will be automatically transferred out of SRS.
- An annuity allows you to stretch your SRS withdrawals over a longer period of time (more than 10 years). Useful since most of us will probably still be alive after 72/73 based on the average life expectancy of Singaporeans (82 for males, 85 for females).
Annuities vs CPF Life - Which is better?
Each plan has its own unique features and benefits, as they cater to different needs.
While CPF Life gives higher monthly payouts for the same amount of capital committed, the sum of money left behind for our beneficiaries will decrease over time.
In contrast, some annuities leave behind a lump sum that increases over time and this lump sum can be greater than the initial capital committed.
In addition, there are many other features that different annuity plans can provide, as we have explored in this post.
Instead of viewing the two as competing products, why not consider how they can complement each other in our retirement plans?
For example, we can use CPF Life as a base and add on a private annuity to supplement this base retirement income, while giving us greater flexibility to start receiving the payouts earlier, or perhaps even giving us the option to leave more behind for our loved ones.
What are your thoughts on annuities? And will you be considering getting one? I will love to hear your thoughts in the comments below!
If you would like to learn more about the different types of annuities available, please feel free to reach out to me.
There are many different annuities, each with its own unique features. Therefore, it is important to find one that is best tailored to your current financial situation and objectives.
If you find such content on retirement planning helpful so far, do follow me on my social media accounts, so you don’t miss out on future posts about retirement planning & more! In the next post, we will be exploring more about annuities.