22/07/2026
Listed is not the same as liquid
Two Malaysian companies are on their way off Bursa.
Both gave the same reason. Nobody could sell the shares.
GuocoLand Malaysia is being taken private at RM1.10 a share through a selective capital reduction. The High Court confirmed it on 13 July. Trading stops on 30 July.
Ajinomoto Malaysia's Japanese parent proposed the same route in June, at RM20 a share, RM603.4 million in total.
The detail worth pausing on is not the price. It is the reason both put in writing.
Ajinomoto's filing noted its shares had traded an average of about 38,715 a day over five years. On that volume, a shareholder with any real position cannot get out at the screen price. They wait, or they push the price down themselves.
GuocoLand said much the same. Low trading liquidity. An opportunity for shareholders to exit.
Read that again. Two listed companies, telling their own shareholders that being listed was not giving them a way out.
Ask a founder what the endgame is and many will say listing.
Underneath that sits an assumption nobody examines. That going public is how you get your money out.
It is not. Listing gives you a venue. It does not give you a buyer.
The numbers agree. Bursa had a record number of IPOs last year. Two out of every three ended the year below their listing price.
You can reach the exit and still not get paid.
Here is the distinction that matters.
An exit event happens to you. Someone decides to buy, at a price you did not set, on a timetable you did not choose.
An exit right is something you negotiated in advance. A trigger, a valuation method, a process that runs whether or not the other side feels like it this year.
The minorities in these two companies had an exit event. They waited years, and it arrived when the controlling shareholder decided it should.
Now think about who else is in that position.
Every family business shareholder who never signed an agreement with a buy-sell mechanism. Every co-founder with no drag-along, no tag-along, no valuation formula. Every second-generation holder of shares in a company they cannot sell.
None of them are listed. All of them have the same problem.
If getting out depends on someone else deciding to buy, you do not have liquidity. You have a hope.
To be fair, listing still works for companies that need capital at scale, acquisition currency, or employee equity that means something. And a premium paid in a take-private tells you the traded price and the transaction price were two different numbers. It does not tell you which one was right. We are not going to pretend to know.
So the question is not public or private.
It is whether you designed how you get out, or assumed it.
Most owners assumed it.
------
Commentary, not investment advice. Figures from company announcements to Bursa Malaysia and published market data as at July 2026.