18/02/2012
Important:
Where assessee-company was assessed under section 143(3), section 147 (first proviso) cannot be invoked merely by reason of a retrospective amendment to section 115JB
• Where assessee-company had disclosed fact of debit to P&L account towards provision for diminution in value of unquoted investments by an entry on expenditure side 'diminution in value of investments Rs. 15,33,22,500/-' and also by way of a Note appended to balance sheet which clearly explained said entry made in P&L account (and thus it was not a case where entry was imbedded in account books and required some more diligence than a cursory look at accounts to find it out) and Assessing Officer examined and enquired into said diminution in value in original assessment proceedings, it could not be said that assessee had failed to disclose fully and truly all material facts and first proviso to section 147 could not be invoked by reason of a retrospective amendment to section 115JB
• Where, however, return was not 'assessed' but only 'processed' under section 143(1)(a), the first proviso to section 147 is not applicable and assessment can be reopened after expiry of 4 years from the end of relevant assessment year if AO has 'reason to believe' that a particular item which had to be added to 'book profit' under section 115JB by virtue of a retrospective amendment but had not been so added and income has escaped assessment