24/07/2022
Commodity Future Trade Ban: Curse or Boon on Agrarian Society
It is now more than seven months that NCDEX Futures trade in 7 commodities is serving
ban after market regulator SEBI on 20th December 2021 denied Future Trade in below
mentioned commodities and subsequently NCDEX in it’s circular vide dated 20th
December 2021 acted in compliance:
S. No. Commodity Name Symbol
01 Wheat WHEATFAQ
02 Chana* CHANA
03 Rapeseed – Mustard Seed* RMSEED
04 Soybean SYBEANIDR
05 Refined Soy Oil SYOREF
06 Hipro Soybean Meal SBMEALIDR
07 Crude Palm Oil CPO
08 Moong MOONG
09 NCDEX Soydex SOYDEX
*These actions have already been implemented in the said commodities vide Exchange
circulars no. NCDEX/SURVEILLANCE & INVESTIGATION-049/2021 dated August 16, 2021,
and NCDEX/SURVEILLANCE & INVESTIGATION- 082/2021 dated October 08, 2021
The market sentiments were jolted by decision and many small agri traders, farmers and
other participants lost the opportunity to hedge against the price risk which is inherit in
commodities due to multiple factors like supply chain, seasonality, demand & supply,
production, international trade, geo-political conditions etc.
Though regulator didn’t mention any reason for ban, but it was considered that obvious
reason to ban the Future Trade was to curb food inflation in the country which was at
5.2% as measured by Consumer Price Index-Combined (CPI-C) in 2021-22 (April-December),
says the Economic Survey 2021-22. However, it was observed that prices of some
perishable commodities like onion and tomato were skyrocketed in FY 2019-20 and
consumers burnt holes in their pockets to afford consumption of this essential
commodities in kitchen.
The bigger question which remained unanswered, is ban on Futures Tarde in above
mentioned commodities have showered boon in agrarian community or society at large
because if price hike in agri commodities is due to Futures Trade then as per Nomura
report published recently stated the food inflation will average over 8 per cent year-on-
year in 2022 from 3.7% in 2021.
Thus, it can be inferred that ban in trade on Exchange haven’t provided any soothing pill
to the economy in restricting food inflation and rather it was witnessed that market
fundamentals played the vital role in making the commodities costlier to common man.
The export ban in wheat commodity by GOI on 13th May 2022 was classic case where
Future Trade didn’t contribute to price rise in wheat which made GOI to ban export on
wheat to manage the overall food security of the country and to support other
vulnerable countries amid Ukraine & Russia War.
Future Trade in India which is still considered at nascent stage and participation of agri
value chain participants is still not in encouraging numbers, ban on commodities and that
too in large number for such long period may hurt the sentiments of agrarian society and
rather there can be other check and balances which can be bring in force by regulator
like increasing margin, restriction on open interest for commodity derivatives, easing
import regulations, stock limit to increase supply in open market to keep check on
inflation.
The detrimental effect of ban in above commodities is now showing sign of concern in
the market where farmers, FPO and other participants are left with no option to hedge
the commodities on exchange which effect fair trade and participants are left at the
mercy of physical trade where chances of delivery default is always a risk.
Further, physical delivery of exchange traded commodities provide comfort to trade
participants for fair and time bound delivery of commodities as per exchange defined
specifications which act as assurance for market to take business decision in trade either
for export, domestic consumption, food processing etc.
It may also be noticed that, in absence of futures trade many companies engaged in
dealing of commodities resort to international exchanges to hedge their trade in Indian
market which takes away huge volume from Indian Exchanges with a point of no return
which hinder fair price discovery in Indian Market that aid in outlook on commodities.
Frequent bans on commodity derivatives contracts also hinder effort by exchanges to
develop the market ecosystem i.e., spot and futures trade prices dissemination to market
participants, development of storage capacities and assessment tools for fair assaying of
commodities and development of negotiable warehouse receipts as opportunity for
farmers and other participants to avoid distress sale.
It is now imperative that regulator revoke ban as soon as possible for market trade in agri
commodities to prosper and compete with international exchanges. Further delay will
only dent the confidence of agri community and will showcase negative narrative in
market and long journey of exchange in educating and training agrarian society to
participate in Future Trade may turn sour and dream of increasing the income of farmers,
FPO and other small market participants may be further stretched for long period.
Note: Views in above post are personal.