10/02/2026
A $139 credit card can give you less back than a free card.
Here's the calculation.
$1,000/month in groceries
→ $12,000/year
$360 cashback
− $139 annual fee
= $221 net
$221 ÷ $12,000
= 1.84% effective return
A free 2% card on the same spending would return $240.
Nothing went wrong.
The advertised 5% rate is real.
The calculation just doesn't end there.
The advertised rate isn't the return.
The full breakdown covers five cards, their published terms, the thresholds and the crossover points.
What would you look at first the rate or the annual fee?