12/06/2021
How to Position your Portfolio for Tougher Markets in 2022 and Beyond
Higher taxes, more regulation and Fed tapering pose challenges in 2022. Betting against the stock market has mostly been a one-way ticket to the poorhouse over the past 100 years. Over time, stocks always rise. Bear markets, wars, crises, pandemics (see S&P 500 Index chart below). The market survives, and eventually, thrives. Warren Buffett, CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, and arguably the world’s most successful investor since the Rothschild’s dynasty, declares ‘betting against America is a bad idea.’
Equities represent a piece of prosperity; when you own stock, you are wagering that strong management, corporate earnings and cash-flow will drive share prices higher over the long-term. In the United States, the S&P 500 Index is the highest quality index in the world, unmatched by the most profitable multinationals – unrivaled in several industries. Except for the 1930s period, investors have not suffered a losing decade in American stocks until the 2000s. The best-performing decades for the broader market have been the 1990s and the last ten years from 2011 to 2021. The last decade or since the financial crisis lows of March 2009, have been especially remarkable. The United States has enjoyed unprecedented dominance measured against most international bourses; this long period of outperformance has also been coupled by the biggest U.S. dollar bull market since President Nixon took the dollar off the gold standard in August 1971.
Very few markets come close to matching the S&P 500 Index in dollar terms over thew past decade. The S&P 500 Index has gained 16.2% per annum since 2011 – a tremendous run driven mainly by the incredible gains derived from fast-growing technology companies that dominate the benchmark. Information technology represents a whopping 28% of the broader market with trillion-dollar behemoths in the Top Five, including Microsoft Corp., Apple, Inc., Alphabet-Google, Amazon.com and Tesla Inc.; these Top Five alone represent 23% of the S&P 500 Index.
Non-U.S. markets, however, tell a different story over the past ten years. The MSCI EAFE Index (Europe, Australia, and the Far East), which dominated global performance from the 1970s until the 2000s, has gained a paltry 4.7% per annum since 2011. That is a huge 71% performance differential compared to the S&P 500 Index. Worse, the once fast-growing emerging markets led by stalwarts like China, India and Brazil have grown only 2.5% per year since 2011 based on the MSCI Emerging Markets Index; that uninspiring return is a massive 85% performance differential compared to the United States. Basically, global diversification has not paid-off for investors since the 2008 financial crisis. In fact, moving funds overseas has penalized dollar-based portfolios when also including the soaring dollar vis-à-vis foreign currencies.
That is a brief performance history of the United States compared to the world. The bad news is that investors have come to expect big stock market gains in most years because we all tend to invest using a rear-view mirror. The past is not always a guarantee for future returns.
Combined with the seemingly endless liquidity supplied by the Federal Reserve (Fed), record corporate stock buybacks, competitive tax rates and record stock market inflows through ETFs and mutual funds this year, the market has been a bastion of wealth creation for the last decade, and beyond. And rightly so. But the big question to ask is what comes next? Consider the following facts and how they might impact your future returns. Indeed, even the most ardent bull would have to concede that speculative activity is at the point of irrational exuberance:
• Shiller CAPE P/E Ratio: Second most expensive on record at 38.4x for S&P 500 Index
• Fiscal and Monetary Policy Tightening: Best of ‘easy money’ now behind us
• Margin debt: All-time highs at record $936 billion as of October 2021
• Inflows into stocks in 2021 exceed combined inflows over past 19 years (see chart next page)
• ‘Bubbles’ in crypto, meme stocks, NFTs, fine art, residential real estate
• Credit spreads at all-time lows: Junk bonds, leveraged loans, CLOs all trade at highs
• Inflation at 30-year highs at 6.2% year-over-year
• Insider selling at all-time highs as corporate executives sell $69 billion of stock in November
• Stock buybacks at record highs
• Private equity deal-making at all-time highs
• Despite record growth across all segments of capital markets and a strong GDP recovery since Covid-19 lows, ten-year U.S. Treasury rates stuck around 1.5% and well below 2%
Build a Ballast in Your Portfolio
In November, global equity markets tumbled on news of the Omicron Covid variant. Initial data suggests it is highly transmissible and potentially vaccine resistant, which has already led to many countries imposing travel restrictions. Meanwhile, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has hinted at an accelerated tapering as inflation is rising rapidly. The double whammy has sent the VIX soaring. As we shortly approach the of the year, it is time to prepare your portfolio for harder times. The good news is many of these liquid alternatives to hedge your stock market risk remain cheap.
Before recommending hedges to help cushion your stocks from losses, let’s review portfolio construction. The first task is to reduce portfolio volatility. Below is a roadmap for you to get started. Review your stock holdings and classify each position under a risk category: Growth stocks include technology companies like Apple, Inc. and Microsoft, and others like Tesla, Nvidia, Home Depot, Visa, and PayPal Holdings, for example. Value equities include companies like JP Morgan Chase, Citigroup, Berkshire Hathaway, Pfizer, United Health, and Comcast, for example. On the far right of our spectrum are Defensive companies like Procter & Gamble Corp., Johnson & Johnson, Nestlé, Verizon Communications, Coca-Cola Co., and McDonald’s.
Growth Value Defensive
|_________________________________________________|______________________________________________________________|
A diversified portfolio should therefore have a balance between these three investment categories. It is called building a ‘ballast’ or achieving an equilibrium while attempting to dilute volatility. This way, you will maximize market cycles across major styles and take advantage of prevailing trends. For example, growth stocks have blasted ahead of value equities since 2009 and now fetch the highest premium versus the latter since 2016 (see chart, top next page). Value equities, I believe, should eventually outpace growth stocks in the next market cycle or economic slowdown. This is what occurred in the 2000 to 2002 bear market. Value stocks heavily trailed growth companies for almost a decade until the bull market peak of March 2000. Now is a good time to build fresh positions in value-based securities after years of poor relative returns compared to expensive growth stocks.
International equities, trailing Wall Street since 2009, also deserve a place in a diversified portfolio of growth, value, and defensive equities. The chart below depicts the extreme premium commanded by U.S. equities over international stocks since 1950; if the periods including the Nifty Fifty (late 1960s to early 1970s) and the Internet ‘bubble’ (late 1990s) are coined extreme, today’s premium is extraordinary! U.S. stocks have never recorded such a huge performance premium over international stocks since World War II. I suspect this massive performance gap will narrow at some point, probably in conjunction with a U.S. dollar bear market.
How Hedging Helps
As global financial markets crashed in March 2020, triggered by the first pandemic in 100 years, the median ENR Global Contrarian Portfolio – our flagship investment strategy -- declined about 3% compared to a 13.5% plunge for the MSCI World Index, a 12.5% loss for the S&P 500 Index and a bruising loss of 17% for the MSCI World Value Index. We still lost money in March 2020, but much less compared to benchmarks. Hedging, or applying portfolio insurance across several securities providing a negative correlation to stocks, proved invaluable, cutting our losses, and dramatically reducing volatility. The median portfolio declined approximately 78% less than the MSCI World Index and 83% less than the MSCI World Value Index in March of last year.
Buy Tail Risk Protection Now
Instead of dumping your stocks in a brutal bear market, and triggering expensive realized capital gains, what about reducing your portfolio risk now and avoiding an emotional outcome that usually triggers investment mistakes (not to mention a tax bill). What’s more, you should buy several securities that will help to hedge or cushion your stock market losses. Over the last 30 years, I have witnessed real carnage amid bear markets. I am amazed how most investment advisors (IAs) do not try to protect client assets ahead of a big market plunge. For most IAs, losing 20% in a calendar year when the broader market is down 25%, is a favorable outcome. Wrong! That is the wrong way to manage risk, protect your client assets, and build long-term relationships. Yet, the industry is not sufficiently educated around portfolio protection or how to stem portfolio losses. It is all about buy, buy and buy!
In February 2020 – a few weeks ahead of the Covid-19 March stock market crash – I started purchasing tail risk for my clients. The ETF we purchased is the Cambria Tail Risk ETF (see chart below). Tail risk protection means buying ‘downside’ stock market insurance ahead of a crash or dislocation. I trade these instruments regularly, and as market risk increases, I build new positions to shield my clients’ stock holdings. These products include tail risk ETFs like Cambria Tail Risk, long-term Treasury bonds, foreign ‘safe-haven’ currencies, gold, and other securities with a negative correlation to the S&P 500 Index. I believe an investor today should hold several tail risk securities to help protect them from a bad market outcome amid the most speculative and most expensive market since the late 1990s. I will not drive a car without insurance. Will not own a home without coverage. And will not travel without health insurance. I feel the same way about portfolio insurance. It is not cheap to buy insurance, but it brings ‘peace of mind’ to a portfolio of stocks, especially when a bull market advance has resulted in sizeable unrealized capital gains for clients.
The Cambria Tail Risk ETF (AMEX-TAIL) is a relatively new product that provides stock market investors with potential downside protection. TAIL, managing $338 million in assets, is an actively managed fund that attempts to earn money when U.S. equities fall. From its low in the first quarter just before the Covid-19 crash, TAIL rallied 30% before peaking. This is an ETF that does what it is supposed to do in a market crash – rise in value. Ideally, we want to buy TAIL now when sentiment is too bullish, and markets are extremely frothy. Alternately, we want to sell at the point of ‘maximum pessimism’ or when markets get ‘bombed out.’ The hardest part of this trade is when to sell. We are looking to exit this position when stocks get hammered day after day, and sentiment turns bearish. That is when to sell most of your portfolio protection.
How it works: TAIL invests in a combination of U.S. Treasuries and in put options on U.S. indices. The options are out-of-the-money put options with strike prices between 0%-30% below the current price but usually falling in the 5%-15% range. The expiration of these options is between 1 and 16 months. The puts, however, are not held to expiration in order to avoid the accelerated time decay that occurs in the last stages of the life of an option.
The fund generally tries to hold about 90% in U.S. Treasuries and 1% in put options, but given that it is actively managed, Cambria Investment Management may consider it opportune to increase or decrease the allocations.