07/24/2025
With so many tools and options available today, one question keeps coming up:
“Should I invest using ETFs or mutual funds?”
So I ran a quick case study with another advisor to compare both approaches using a $100,000 portfolio with a standard 70/30 mix (70% equities / 30% fixed income). We tested three versions:
An ETF portfolio
A DIY-style ETF portfolio
A Mutual fund portfolio
Here’s what stood out — no charts needed:
---
💡 Key Takeaways:
🔹 Mutual Fund Outperformed
Despite having the highest fees, the mutual fund portfolio came out ahead in long-term returns and growth. Cost matters, but value matters more. *This is not always the case and will vary, but just worked out in this situation.*
🔹 ETFs Can Be Cost-Effective
The DIY ETF portfolio had the lowest fees, but not the strongest returns. It's efficient — but performance depends on what’s inside the portfolio, not just the fee.
🔹 It's Not Just About Cost
People often focus only on fees — but performance, tax strategy, and portfolio design matter just as much (if not more).
---
✅ Final Thought:
Whether you use ETFs or mutual funds, what really matters is the plan behind the portfolio. It's about building a strategy that fits your goals, not just chasing the cheapest option.
Want to see how your portfolio stacks up?
Send it over — I’ll happily plug it into the same comparison.