PEI Mutual Insurance Company

PEI Mutual Insurance Company Protecting Each Other Since 1885

We aim to be the insurer of choice on Prince Edward Island through local, personalized service.

We strive to be the best place to work, and to give back to and support our Island communities. PEI Mutual Insurance Company is part of our Island community. Our head office with over 40 employees is located in Summerside, our 17 agents live throughout the Island and make house calls to explain our policies. Our Board of Directors is elected from 9 zones across PEI and is responsible for corporate

policy. We also have our in-house safety advisor who makes house calls to ensure the safety of your homes and businesses! Our locally produced policies (residential, farm, fishing boats, commercial) are competitively priced and policyholders enjoy mutual rebates whenever profits warrant. Our claims are all processed locally as we are the only island-owned insurance company in PEI. We support many local charities, including our local hospitals, Special Olympics PEI, Festival of Small Halls, Sport PEI, PEISAA, United Way of PEI, Provincial Games and many more local impactful organizations. Through our PEI Mutual Educational Trust we provide twenty $1,000 scholarships annually to Island students. Craig Noonan, our CEO, & Rudy Smith, our CFO, make up the executive team and guide the organization towards its objectives. Our Vision:
To be the insurer of choice on PEI

Our Mission:
To provide our members with quality insurance products, at competitive prices, through local, personalized and professional service. Our Core Values:
We listen and respond to our members’ needs;
We behave with integrity;
We treat each other with dignity and respect;
We support, motivate and engage our talent;
We continuously improve and innovate;
We give back to the local communities we serve;
We are accountable collectively and individually. Our Culture:
We strive to be the best place to work in PEI, offering competitive wages and benefits, a leading defined contribution RRSP plan, numerous employee-focused initiatives, and a positive working environment!

06/18/2026

Thank You, PEI Mutual

Hospice PEI is grateful to PEI Mutual Insurance Company for once again supporting our annual Hike & Bike for Hospice event.

The support of local sponsors is essential to the success of this fundraiser and helps us raise critical funds for the programs and services that support individuals and families across our communities.

As one of our three major annual fundraising events, Hike & Bike for Hospice relies on the generosity of community partners who help us move closer to our goal each year.

Thank you, PEI Mutual Insurance Company for your continued support of Hospice PEI and the compassionate care we provide in our community.

We donated 100 trees to the City of Charlottetown, PE’s Business Tree Planting Initiative and our summer student Gracie ...
06/18/2026

We donated 100 trees to the City of Charlottetown, PE’s Business Tree Planting Initiative and our summer student Gracie helped plant them!

What a perfect way to celebrate summer, take care of the environment and give back to our communities 👏🏻

PEI Mutual is proud to support the Western Hospital Foundation with a newly established annual contribution of $8,000. T...
06/17/2026

PEI Mutual is proud to support the Western Hospital Foundation with a newly established annual contribution of $8,000.

This funding supports their golf tournament and gala, and a direct contribution to enhance healthcare in West Prince.

Pictured from left are Lee Gallant, Manager of Marketing & Communications at PEI Mutual, and Dave Pizio, Chairman of the Western Hospital Foundation.

Carbon monoxide can be a silent and deadly risk, that's why it's so important to install carbon monoxide detectors in yo...
06/16/2026

Carbon monoxide can be a silent and deadly risk, that's why it's so important to install carbon monoxide detectors in your home and regularly check that they're working properly.

This is your reminder to go check your Carbon Monoxide Detector right now!

The PEI Mutual Festival of Small Halls has contributed to our vibrant arts scene, rural PEI communities, and shoulder-se...
06/15/2026

The PEI Mutual Festival of Small Halls has contributed to our vibrant arts scene, rural PEI communities, and shoulder-season tourism since 2008, and we are proud to play a role in ensuring it remains an enduring part of our Island’s cultural landscape.

It’s also a beautiful reminder that the simple pleasures of life - good music, good company, and a sense of community - are also the greatest pleasures.

If you are a policyholder with PEI Mutual, we hope you also take pride in supporting the festival through your choice to insure with us. As a mutual company, we will always be community-focused and we couldn’t do it without the support of our members!

Check out this year's schedule & get your tickets: https://smallhalls.com

Our contest closes tonight at 11:59pm - don’t forget to send in your photos today!
06/15/2026

Our contest closes tonight at 11:59pm - don’t forget to send in your photos today!

Haven't sent in your photos yet for our Calendar Photo Contest? You still have time!

We'll be accepting submissions until Monday, June 15th at 11:59PM (AST).

•Photos must be digital files
•Landscape format only
•File types: .jpeg, .png or .tiff
Submit electronically: https://peimutual.com/calendar

We ♥️ supporting the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Foundation! We were happy to be along for the ride as the cart sponsor at ...
06/12/2026

We ♥️ supporting the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Foundation! We were happy to be along for the ride as the cart sponsor at this year's tournament ⛳️

We're looking forward to being part of such a great event!
06/10/2026

We're looking forward to being part of such a great event!

🏆 HOCKEYFEST CORPORATE DIVISION 🏆

The Noah Dobson's HockeyFest Corporate Division presented by Curran & Briggs is back! Joining Curran & Briggs in this year's Corporate Division competition are:

🏒 BGC Prince County - Summerside Club
🏒 High Button Sports (who will also be on-site shooting on Friday!)
🏒 Holland College
🏒 PEI Mutual Insurance Company
🏒 Summerside Integrative Care Clinic

We're grateful for the support, and we're looking forward to seeing all your game faces NEXT FRIDAY when the 4th Annual Noah Dobson's HockeyFest begins!

| | Explore Summerside | Community Connections Inc.- Summerside | Prince Edward Island Tourism | The City of Summerside | HockeyFest - Game On | Summerside Toyota

06/09/2026

A photo of yours might be everyone’s favourite next year!

You have until June 15th to submit your photos to our Calendar Photo Contest.

•Photos must be digital files
•Landscape format only
•There are prizes for Gold, Silver, Bronze and Best Winter Photo!

You can find more info on our website ☺️

Have you decided to rent out your property? Make sure to let your Agent know!We may be able to offer some types of renta...
06/08/2026

Have you decided to rent out your property? Make sure to let your Agent know!

We may be able to offer some types of rental insurance under your Homeowners Policy, but it's not typically suited for rentals. A Residential or Commercial Policy might be a better fit!

Let us know if there are any changes in the occupancy of your property, as this may void your policy.

Address

116 Walker Avenue
Summerside, PE
C1N6V9

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when PEI Mutual Insurance Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to PEI Mutual Insurance Company:

Share