PEI Mutual Insurance Company

PEI Mutual Insurance Company Protecting Each Other Since 1885

We aim to be the insurer of choice on Prince Edward Island through local, personalized service.

We strive to be the best place to work, and to give back to and support our Island communities. PEI Mutual Insurance Company is part of our Island community. Our head office with over 40 employees is located in Summerside, our 17 agents live throughout the Island and make house calls to explain our policies. Our Board of Directors is elected from 9 zones across PEI and is responsible for corporate

policy. We also have our in-house safety advisor who makes house calls to ensure the safety of your homes and businesses! Our locally produced policies (residential, farm, fishing boats, commercial) are competitively priced and policyholders enjoy mutual rebates whenever profits warrant. Our claims are all processed locally as we are the only island-owned insurance company in PEI. We support many local charities, including our local hospitals, Special Olympics PEI, Festival of Small Halls, Sport PEI, PEISAA, United Way of PEI, Provincial Games and many more local impactful organizations. Through our PEI Mutual Educational Trust we provide twenty $1,000 scholarships annually to Island students. Craig Noonan, our CEO, & Rudy Smith, our CFO, make up the executive team and guide the organization towards its objectives. Our Vision:
To be the insurer of choice on PEI

Our Mission:
To provide our members with quality insurance products, at competitive prices, through local, personalized and professional service. Our Core Values:
We listen and respond to our members’ needs;
We behave with integrity;
We treat each other with dignity and respect;
We support, motivate and engage our talent;
We continuously improve and innovate;
We give back to the local communities we serve;
We are accountable collectively and individually. Our Culture:
We strive to be the best place to work in PEI, offering competitive wages and benefits, a leading defined contribution RRSP plan, numerous employee-focused initiatives, and a positive working environment!

Time to turn the page on your PEI Mutual calendar!This month's photo is by Wanda Bailey, taken in beautiful Souris, PEI ...
09/01/2026

Time to turn the page on your PEI Mutual calendar!

This month's photo is by Wanda Bailey, taken in beautiful Souris, PEI 🐦

Today is the last day to enter our Hurricane Preparedness CONTEST!You have a chance to win a Generac Generator, $1,000 c...
08/31/2026

Today is the last day to enter our Hurricane Preparedness CONTEST!

You have a chance to win a Generac Generator, $1,000 credit to any tree trimming business in PEI, a $250 gift card to Canadian Tire, or a $250 gift card to Irving Gas Stations 🎉

More info:

Join our contest for your chance to win a prize! Show us how you are preparing for Hurricane Season by uploading a photo!

Are you passionate about solving technical problems and providing exceptional support? Do you have the skills to trouble...
08/27/2026

Are you passionate about solving technical problems and providing exceptional support?

Do you have the skills to troubleshoot, assist, and ensure seamless IT operations?

If so, we would love to hear from you!

Learn more: https://peimutual.com/Careers/it-support-technician-2

Thank YOU to the team at Big Brothers & Sisters for their work on the Big Give Back initiative 👏🏻
08/25/2026

Thank YOU to the team at Big Brothers & Sisters for their work on the Big Give Back initiative 👏🏻

💙 A HUGE Thank You to PEI Mutual Insurance Company!

We are incredibly grateful to PEI Mutual Insurance Company for their very generous donation of 50 backpacks, 50 lunch bags, more than 90 water bottles and enough school supplies to fill an SUV, in support of our Big Give Back initiative!

This amazing donation will make a huge difference for families in Western PEI as they prepare for a new school year. By helping to provide some of those important back-to-school essentials, PEI Mutual Insurance is helping children head into September feeling prepared, confident, and ready to learn.

Thank you for helping us make sure that more children have what they need to start the school year strong. Your generosity truly makes an impact in our communities!

Thank you, PEI Mutual Insurance Company, for helping us give back in such a BIG way!

Last call! 🚨Applications for our Chief Operating Officer role close this Friday.If you’ve been thinking about it, now’s ...
08/24/2026

Last call! 🚨

Applications for our Chief Operating Officer role close this Friday.

If you’ve been thinking about it, now’s the time. And if someone great comes to mind when you see this, send it their way!

Applications close Friday, August 28th: https://peimutual.com/careers

Congratulations to Stephanie Munn, the winner of our Old Home Week contest!We hope she enjoys her prize:•a one-night sta...
08/24/2026

Congratulations to Stephanie Munn, the winner of our Old Home Week contest!

We hope she enjoys her prize:
•a one-night stay at the Holman Grand Hotel
•$150 Canada’s Food Island gift card
•$50 gas card

Make sure to keep an eye out for more contests coming up!

We're closing this contest on Monday, August 24th - you still have time to enter!What's YOUR favourite part of Old Home ...
08/20/2026

We're closing this contest on Monday, August 24th - you still have time to enter!

What's YOUR favourite part of Old Home Week?

Can you spot the typo in our calendar this month 👀

That’s right, Gold Cup Parade Day is actually August 21st!

To make it up to you, we’re going to give away:
•one-night stay at the Holman Grand Hotel
•$150 Canada’s Food Island gift card
•$50 gas card

All you have to do for your chance to win is tag a friend and tell us your favourite part of Old Home Week in the comments!

(Please be cautious when it comes to potential scam accounts - we will DM the winner directly from this account and we will post the winner here on our page as well!)

08/18/2026

Top-notch customer service is very important to us here at PEI Mutual, that’s why you’ll always get a human voice every time you call.

Let’s have a round of applause for the amazing Reception & Front Office team who make this possible 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Their expertise, friendliness, and dedication to help each member get the answers they need easily and efficiently is a huge part of our success!

Can you spot the typo in our calendar this month 👀That’s right, Gold Cup Parade Day is actually August 21st!To make it u...
08/17/2026

Can you spot the typo in our calendar this month 👀

That’s right, Gold Cup Parade Day is actually August 21st!

To make it up to you, we’re going to give away:
•one-night stay at the Holman Grand Hotel
•$150 Canada’s Food Island gift card
•$50 gas card

All you have to do for your chance to win is tag a friend and tell us your favourite part of Old Home Week in the comments!

(Please be cautious when it comes to potential scam accounts - we will DM the winner directly from this account and we will post the winner here on our page as well!)

We might be a little biased, but this is a pretty great opportunity!We’re hiring a COO...someone who wants to work with ...
08/17/2026

We might be a little biased, but this is a pretty great opportunity!

We’re hiring a COO...someone who wants to work with great people, help turn big ideas into action, and play a meaningful role in what comes next at PEI Mutual.

Know someone who might be a great fit? Give them a nudge!

Applications close August 28th.

More info: https://peimutual.com/careers

Address

116 Walker Avenue
Summerside, PE
C1N6V9

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when PEI Mutual Insurance Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to PEI Mutual Insurance Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category