PEI Mutual Insurance Company

Directions Website Contact the business

PEI Mutual Insurance Company Protecting Each Other Since 1885

We aim to be the insurer of choice on Prince Edward Island through local, personalized service.

We strive to be the best place to work, and to give back to and support our Island communities. PEI Mutual Insurance Company is part of our Island community. Our head office with over 40 employees is located in Summerside, our 17 agents live throughout the Island and make house calls to explain our policies. Our Board of Directors is elected from 9 zones across PEI and is responsible for corporate policy. We also have our in-house safety advisor who makes house calls to ensure the safety of your homes and businesses! Our locally produced policies (residential, farm, fishing boats, commercial) are competitively priced and policyholders enjoy mutual rebates whenever profits warrant. Our claims are all processed locally as we are the only island-owned insurance company in PEI. We support many local charities, including our local hospitals, Special Olympics PEI, Festival of Small Halls, Sport PEI, PEISAA, United Way of PEI, Provincial Games and many more local impactful organizations. Through our PEI Mutual Educational Trust we provide twenty $1,000 scholarships annually to Island students. Craig Noonan, our CEO, & Rudy Smith, our CFO, make up the executive team and guide the organization towards its objectives. Our Vision:
To be the insurer of choice on PEI

Our Mission:
To provide our members with quality insurance products, at competitive prices, through local, personalized and professional service. Our Core Values:
We listen and respond to our members’ needs;
We behave with integrity;
We treat each other with dignity and respect;
We support, motivate and engage our talent;
We continuously improve and innovate;
We give back to the local communities we serve;
We are accountable collectively and individually. Our Culture:
We strive to be the best place to work in PEI, offering competitive wages and benefits, a leading defined contribution RRSP plan, numerous employee-focused initiatives, and a positive working environment!

Planning on installing a wood-burning appliance? Make sure to let us know!Installing a wood appliance represents a mater...
10/20/2026

Planning on installing a wood-burning appliance? Make sure to let us know!

Installing a wood appliance represents a material change to the policy. Our Agent will visit your home to complete a survey to verify that it is installed according to our standards.

PEI Mutual requires that a wood appliance:
🔥 is certified by CSA, ULC or Warnock-Hersey
🔥 is installed to the manufacturer’s specifications
🔥 is vented to an approved chimney system

This is your reminder to give your oven a good clean!Grease and food splatters can ignite at high temperatures.Keeping y...
10/19/2026

This is your reminder to give your oven a good clean!

Grease and food splatters can ignite at high temperatures.

Keeping your oven clean will help keep you and your home safe 🏡

Why choose PEI Mutual?We understand the needs of Islanders because we are Islanders. Our coverage reflects the Island wa...
10/16/2026

Why choose PEI Mutual?

We understand the needs of Islanders because we are Islanders.

Our coverage reflects the Island way, including home, commercial, farm, and fishing policies. And we pride ourselves in providing local, personal service that highlights the best of Prince Edward Island.

More info: https://peimutual.com

Now hiring!We offer:•37.5-hour work week•a respectful work environment•paid vacation, generous sick and medical leave be...
10/15/2026

Now hiring!

We offer:
•37.5-hour work week
•a respectful work environment
•paid vacation, generous sick and medical leave benefits
•Dental, health, and vision care benefits 100% funded by the company – including access to virtual healthcare 24/7 and Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
•One of PEI’s best defined-contribution retirement savings plans (RRSP) matched by the company
•Various employee well-being initiatives and wellness challenges
•Insurance education, paid study time and other development opportunities
•The opportunity to work with a dynamic and collaborative team of professionals

We can't wait for you to join our Accounting Team!

More info: https://peimutual.com/Careers/accounting-technician

Closing up the cottage isn’t exactly anyone’s idea of fun, but it’s one of those tasks that gives you a deep sense of sa...
10/14/2026

Closing up the cottage isn’t exactly anyone’s idea of fun, but it’s one of those tasks that gives you a deep sense of satisfaction once it’s done.

You can rest easy through the winter knowing your beloved cottage is safely ‘tucked in’ and waiting for your return next spring.

Here's a checklist you can use to make sure your property is safe through the winter: https://peimutual.com/safety_tips/closing-up-your-pei-cottage-for-the-winter

Do you have these essentials ready-to-go?•Stored or bottled water: two litres per person per day for drinking, cooking a...
10/13/2026

Do you have these essentials ready-to-go?

•Stored or bottled water: two litres per person per day for drinking, cooking and hygiene
•Non-perishable food, such as canned food, energy bars and dried foods (replace once a year)
•Manual can opener
•Wind-up or battery-powered flashlight
•Wind-up or battery-powered radio
•Extra batteries and battery packs
•First aid kit including adhesive bandages, tape, gauze, antiseptic wound cleanser, and disposable gloves
•Extra keys for your car and house
•Cash in smaller bills and coins
•Mobile phone charger and power bank
•Tissue paper, toilet paper and paper towels

We hope everyone is having a wonderful Thanksgiving weekend!Our office is closed today, but we'll still be monitoring an...
10/12/2026

We hope everyone is having a wonderful Thanksgiving weekend!

Our office is closed today, but we'll still be monitoring any claims coming in online or by phone.

Give us a call and leave a voicemail: 1-800-565-5441

Report a claim online: https://peimutual.com/report-a-claim

10/09/2026

One of our favourite annual traditions is gifting each one of our team members a box filled with everything they need for their family’s Thanksgiving dinner!

We want to know…what’s YOUR favourite part of Thanksgiving dinner?

Thank you to the Greater Charlottetown Area Chamber of Commerce for having us at their Annual Golf Tournament last week!...
10/07/2026

Thank you to the Greater Charlottetown Area Chamber of Commerce for having us at their Annual Golf Tournament last week!

It's always a great event, and this year was no different. We're proud to support the great work you do every day!

High winds can cause huge damage, but there are steps you can take ahead of time to avoid a future claim!
10/06/2026

High winds can cause huge damage, but there are steps you can take ahead of time to avoid a future claim!

Address

116 Walker Avenue
Summerside, PE
C1N6V9

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when PEI Mutual Insurance Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to PEI Mutual Insurance Company:

Shortcuts

Share