Dufferin Mutual

Dufferin Mutual Property and Casualty Mutual Insurer located in Shelburne, Ontario.

Dufferin Mutual was founded in 1895 as a farm mutual and remains a true 'mutual' today, owned entirely by it's policyholders. We provide:

- Underwriting of policies through our Brokers & Agents
- Claims handling and procedures

Our Hours of Operation:

Monday through Friday 8:30 am to 4:30 pm.

We are very proud to be part of this amazing event!
02/04/2026

We are very proud to be part of this amazing event!

We’re thrilled to recognize Crewson Insurance Brokers and Dufferin Mutual as our returning Presenting Albatross Sponsors for the 2026 Headwaters Golf Classic!

Your incredible support makes this event possible and helps us continue to make a meaningful impact in our community. We couldn’t do it without you!

Here’s to another fantastic year of golf, community, and collaboration - see you on the greens!

Protect your home during this Oh So Cold weather!!
01/22/2026

Protect your home during this Oh So Cold weather!!

: Protecting the pipes in your home is essential during cold snaps to prevent ruptures and flooding. Avoid costly damage by following these simple tips.

With today’s weather forecast, this seems like a good share!!
01/19/2026

With today’s weather forecast, this seems like a good share!!

Canadian winters can be dangerous for drivers if they’re not prepared for rapidly changing road conditions. Take the time to review our Top 10 tips and share with family & friends.

01/16/2026

Who do you face off for?

We are excited to cheer on Shilo Rousseau along side Algoma Mutual   Good luck Shilo!
01/12/2026

We are excited to cheer on Shilo Rousseau along side Algoma Mutual Good luck Shilo!

Help us Face Off for Cancer on January 16th!  All proceeds support cancer care at Headwaters Health Care Foundation!
01/06/2026

Help us Face Off for Cancer on January 16th! All proceeds support cancer care at Headwaters Health Care Foundation!

Hockey + Community = ❤️
Catch the Shelburne Muskies vs. Lucknow Lancers charity game Jan 16 at 8:30 p.m.
All proceeds support cancer care at Headwaters.
Let’s fill the stands!

May your holiday season be merry and bright, filled with joy, love, and laughter. Merry Christmas and happy holidays fro...
12/10/2025

May your holiday season be merry and bright, filled with joy, love, and laughter. Merry Christmas and happy holidays from the Staff and Directors at Dufferin Mutual, a division of Integrated Mutual Insurance Group.

We are very happy to once again sponsor this amazing drive that directly helps those in our community. This year you can...
12/01/2025

We are very happy to once again sponsor this amazing drive that directly helps those in our community. This year you can drop your toys or non perishable items at our office Monday-Friday 8:30am-4:30pm for collection by the fire department. Tis the season to give!

Yes!!!!!! ⚾️
10/25/2025

Yes!!!!!! ⚾️

Our Farm Underwriter spent a wonderful day at the Canada's Outdoor Farm Show with the Ontario Mutuals. Can you spot her?...
09/10/2025

Our Farm Underwriter spent a wonderful day at the Canada's Outdoor Farm Show with the Ontario Mutuals. Can you spot her? 👀

Our office will be closed today at 2pm and remain closed through Monday to observe Labour Day.  Have a safe and happy lo...
08/29/2025

Our office will be closed today at 2pm and remain closed through Monday to observe Labour Day. Have a safe and happy long weekend!

Congratulations to the Shelburne Free Press on 150 years!!
07/21/2025

Congratulations to the Shelburne Free Press on 150 years!!

Address

802 Main Street East Unit #4
Shelburne, ON
L9V2Z5

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Dufferin Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Dufferin Mutual:

Share