Portage Mutual Insurance

09/25/2026

A Message from Our President & CEO – Cara Cameron

I’m incredibly excited to serve as the President & CEO of Portage Mutual Insurance. As I look ahead, what stands out most is the strength of who we are and the opportunity in front of us.

What will continue to differentiate Portage Mutual is our ability to deliver modern mutuality by combining deep local relationships and expertise with national scale. It’s a model built over generations, grounded in being people-first, trusted, and reliable. We are continuing to evolve by thoughtfully strengthening our capabilities to enhance efficiency, responsiveness, and customer service. I’m energized by what’s ahead and proud to lead a company with such a strong foundation as we continue to grow and evolve together.

06/26/2026

Happy Retirement to our President and CEO, Wayne Wyborn after 40 years of service.

Congratulations, Wayne as you embark on this new journey!

Q: Do you have any travel plans?
A: I will be staying close to home this summer, but I am definitely looking forward to going someplace warm early next year, for a break from the winter.

Q: What hobbies are you excited to spend more time on?
A: I am looking forward to doing some metal and woodworking and catching up on my kindle library.

Q: What’s one lesson you will carry into retirement?
A: Never stop learning. The world is a fascinating place, and we all benefit from being open to learning new skills.

Q: What advice would you give someone just starting their insurance career?
A: Embrace continuous learning and be willing to go outside your comfort zone. There are so many opportunities; you just need to be open to them when the opportunity arises.

06/11/2026

Have you experienced damage from a recent storm?

If you have a claim to report you can either report it to your broker or you can report it to us online at:

We offer 24-hour claims support every day of the week to all our policy holders. For many years, our exceptional claims service has stood above the competition’s. We take pride in assisting all our policy holders during their time of loss. We have an expert claims staff that will help you in the s...

06/01/2026

Today’s Broker Relationship Manager Showcase – Cindy Henderson, one of our BRMs for Alberta.

Cindy's hometown is Calgary, Alberta. Cindy prefers tea over coffee (But does like Baileys with coffee). Overall Cindy is a night owl. One word that friends would use to describe Cindy is ‘Adventurous’, but she says she really just likes exploring new things and ideas.

Cindy has been in the Insurance industry for 44 years, finding her way into the industry after pivoting from another path.

Cindy most enjoys meeting new people, appreciating their varied backgrounds and how they themselves came to work in the Insurance industry.

05/08/2026

Today’s Broker Relationship Manager Showcase – Marc Lyle, our BRM for New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Prince Edward Island.

Marc's hometown is Sydney Mines, Nova Scotia. Marc prefers coffee over tea, enjoying the boost of energy in his mornings, especially with him being a Morning Person overall. One word that friends would use to describe Marc is ‘Caring’.

Marc has been in the Insurance industry for 17 years, getting his start with TD Insurance in Halifax before moving back to Cape Breton, where he was a Broker for 13 years prior to coming to Portage Mutual.

Marc most values and enjoys his co-workers, meeting our Broker partners, and the knowledge that every day means another day where he had a hand in being helpful to someone.

05/06/2026

Another year, another successful Annual General Meeting!

We had a great time hosting our directors, broker partners, and staff last week. We very much enjoyed the opportunity to share the company’s successes over the past year, as well as learn more of the exciting new developments in store for the future of Portage Mutual Insurance.

05/04/2026

Today’s Broker Relationship Manager Showcase – Rob Aniballi, one of our BRMs for Ontario.

Rob's hometown is Stoney Creek, Ontario; He prefers coffee over tea. Rob would say he is a Morning Person without a doubt. One word that friends would use to describe Rob is ‘Steady’.

Rob has been in the Insurance industry for 23 years, beginning with an Insurance Program at Mohawk College.

In his work, Rob most enjoys the professional relationships he is able to build and strengthen with his colleagues and our Brokers.

05/01/2026

Today’s Broker Relationship Manager Showcase – Brenda Holmes, one of our BRMs for Manitoba.

Brenda grew up on a grain and cattle farm north of Oakville, Manitoba; She prefers tea over coffee and would describe herself as a Morning Person. One word that Brenda hopes her friends describe her with is 'Helpful'.

Brenda has been in the Insurance industry for 35 years, getting started in Portage Mutual Insurance's Auto Underwriting department for 3 years before working as a Broker for almost 19 years. Afterwards, Brenda would return to PMI as a Broker Relationship Manager, which is the very same position she holds today.

When it comes to her work, Brenda enjoys a lot of things, but most values the people, namely collaborating with her colleagues and building and strengthening the relationships we have with our Brokers.

04/27/2026

Today’s Broker Relationship Manager Showcase – Lori Penner, one of our BRMs for Manitoba.

Lori's hometown is Crystal City, Manitoba; She prefers coffee (with Bailey's) rather than tea. Lori wouldn't describe herself as either a morning person or night owl, feeling she is a bit of both. One word that friends would use to describe Lori is ‘Supportive’.

Lori has been in the Insurance industry for 35 years, getting started at Portage Mutual Insurance in 1991 as a new face to Portage la Prairie.

Lori most enjoys working with her peers and Industry partners. Having her own work vehicle is a nice perk as well, she notes.

04/21/2026

Today's Broker Relationship Manager Showcase - Lisa Todd, our BRM for Saskatchewan.

Lisa's hometown is Saskatoon, Saskatchewan; she prefers coffee over tea. Lisa describes herself as more of a morning person, keeping a reliable schedule to ensure she is well-rested for the day ahead. One word Lisa's friends describe her with is 'Loyal', but she thinks fun and silly are good candidates as well.

Lisa has been in the Industry for 42 years, starting in High School and University working with her mother, who owned the local Insurance Brokerage of her area while Lisa was growing up.

Lisa most enjoys working with her colleagues, our Broker Partners, and other industry partners.