What are the opening hours?

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm

Erie Mutual Insurance

Home
Canada
Dunnville, ON
Erie Mutual Insurance

A progressive insurance company delivering the best customer experience for over 150 years. Real people, Real service.

Erie Mutual Insurance is a progressive property and casualty insurance company based in Dunnville, Ontario. Proudly serving drivers, homeowners, business owners, and farmers in Haldimand County, Niagara Region and the Hamilton area for over 150 years, we are dedicated to our core values; always acting respectfully and professionally, and working to exceed your expectations while providing full va

lue for the premiums you pay. Committed to providing you with the most appropriate and affordable coverage that best meets your ever-changing insurance needs. We offer insurance solutions through our vast array of products including farm insurance, home insurance, auto insurance, commercial insurance, and personal liability insurance. Visit us at www.eriemutual.com to request an insurance quote, and discover how Erie Mutual continues to be proactive to the changing insurance and service needs of our clients. When you become an Erie Mutual member, you’ll "Experience the Value".

09/01/2026

TUESDAY TESTIMONIAL

Having an insurance agent you can trust to take care of your needs is crucial.

Denise is knowledgeable, personable, and one step ahead of what you need next. That's what provides you comfort and peace of mind when it comes to protecting your home, farm, and business.

08/31/2026

COMMUNITY SPONSOR

Erie Mutual Insurance is always happy to support our community. A sponsorship cheque was recently provided to members of the Haldimand River Kings U13B Hockey Team.

Support from local businesses helps to offset team expenses and allows a valuable opportunity for player development, team activities, tournaments, and season events throughout the year.

We wish the River Kings team all the best!

08/27/2026

ANOTHER CONTEST ALERT!

WIN AN ALL-ACCESS FAMILY PASS TO THE WAINFLEET FAIR

LIKE or COMMENT on this post to be entered.

Contest runs from today until 11:59 pm on Thursday, September 3rd only. The winner will be randomly drawn on Friday, September 4th, and must be able to claim/pick up the prize at our office in Dunnville during office hours; no cash substitutions. The winner will be contacted via FB or IG Message by an Erie Mutual staff member.

The winning package includes a Family Pass, which you can redeem at the fair for 3-day wristbands for 2 Adults and up to 3 children, and provides All Access to the Arena & Fairgrounds, ATV Expo, ATV Mud Bog, Demolition Derby, and Trucks & Tractor Pulls. The winning package is valued at $95.

This promotion/contest is in no way sponsored, endorsed, administered by, or associated with Facebook or Instagram.

BTW, look for our tent at the Wainfleet Fair! Please stop by to say "hi" and enter our FREE CONTEST DRAW during the fair.

08/25/2026

At Erie Mutual, insurance is still personal.

When you call, you'll talk to real people who live and work in the communities we serve.

For more than 150 years, we've been helping families, homeowners, drivers, businesses, and farmers across Niagara and Haldimand protect what matters most.

We're more than insurance. We're part of the community.

08/24/2026

CONTEST ALERT!

WIN A 4-PACK OF PASSES TO WEST NIAGARA FAIR

LIKE or COMMENT on this post to be entered.

Contest runs from today until 11:59 pm on Thursday, Sept 3rd only. The winner will be randomly drawn on Friday, September 4th, and must be able to claim/pick up the prize at our office in Dunnville during office hours, or has the option to have the winning package emailed - no cash substitutions. The winner will be contacted via FB or IG Message by an Erie Mutual staff member.

The winning package consists of 2 Adult General Admission Fair Passes, 2 Child General Admission Fair Passes, and 4 Midway Passes (good for all ages). The winning package is valued at $170.

This promotion/contest is in no way sponsored, endorsed, administered by, or associated with Facebook or Instagram.

BTW, look for us at the West Niagara Fair as a vendor again this year.

We're so happy to be back! Stop by to say "hi" if you're there on Friday/Saturday and enter our FREE CONTEST DRAW being offered during the fair.

08/20/2026

COMMUNITY SPONSOR

Darcy Johnson, Manager of Marketing & Business Development, provides a sponsor cheque to teammates of the Haldimand Rivercats U9B Girls Hockey Team.

Funds help to support operating expenses, including ice rentals, referees, tournaments, and other costs.

We wish the team all the best in their upcoming season!

08/18/2026

WELCOME NICK!

Please join us in welcoming Nicholas Feeney as our new Financial Controller at Erie Mutual Insurance!

Nick has over 25 years of finance and accounting leadership experience and a strategic perspective that will be valuable as we continue to grow and serve our communities.

08/17/2026

15-YEAR MILESTONE

Congratulations, Lauren, on your 15 Year Milestone at Erie Mutual!

Over the years, Lauren has transitioned from Customer Service Rep to Agent to her current role as Manager of Sales. She continues to contribute to our company's success and to mentoring those new to the insurance industry within her department.

08/14/2026

SAVE ON INSURANCE TODAY

First Time Home Buyer?
Need Insurance?
Want an online estimate?

GET A 25% DISCOUNT TODAY!
https://loom.ly/dvMfbhg

08/11/2026

COMMUNITY SPONSOR

Erie Mutual President & CEO, Jennifer Fess (left), presents a sponsorship cheque to Lisa Hostein (Executive Director) of the West Haldimand Hospital Foundation in support of their Annual Charity Golf Tournament.

Funds raised through the Foundation help towards the purchase of vital equipment needed by the hospital.

We wish them a successful tournament!

Address

711 Main Street East
Dunnville, ON
N1A2W5

Opening Hours

Monday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday	8:30am - 4:30pm

Telephone

+18002636484

Website

https://www.eriemutual.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Erie Mutual Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Erie Mutual Insurance:

Want your business to be the top-listed Finance Company in Dunnville?