Erie Mutual Insurance

Erie Mutual Insurance A progressive insurance company delivering the best customer experience for over 155 years. Real people, Real service.

Erie Mutual Insurance is a progressive property and casualty insurance company based in Dunnville, Ontario. Proudly serving drivers, homeowners, business owners, and farmers in Haldimand County, Niagara Region and the Hamilton area for over 150 years, we are dedicated to our core values; always acting respectfully and professionally, and working to exceed your expectations while providing full va

lue for the premiums you pay. Committed to providing you with the most appropriate and affordable coverage that best meets your ever-changing insurance needs. We offer insurance solutions through our vast array of products including farm insurance, home insurance, auto insurance, commercial insurance, and personal liability insurance. Visit us at www.eriemutual.com to request an insurance quote, and discover how Erie Mutual continues to be proactive to the changing insurance and service needs of our clients. When you become an Erie Mutual member, you’ll "Experience the Value".

TUESDAY TESTIMONIAL Looking for an insurance experience that's simple to understand, handled with ease, and is completel...
06/23/2026

TUESDAY TESTIMONIAL

Looking for an insurance experience that's simple to understand, handled with ease, and is completely stress-free?

Of course you are, who isn't?

This customer was very happy to be dealing with Brent!

Happy Retirement Don! Staff and Board members celebrated an early retirement lunch for our CEO, Don McEvoy. Don will be ...
06/17/2026

Happy Retirement Don!

Staff and Board members celebrated an early retirement lunch for our CEO, Don McEvoy.

Don will be retiring at the end of July.
Please join us in wishing Don all the best in his retirement!

Brent & Samarth enjoyed spending their Saturday morning joining others at Breakfast on the Farm, hosted by Roy-A-Lea Far...
06/15/2026

Brent & Samarth enjoyed spending their Saturday morning joining others at Breakfast on the Farm, hosted by Roy-A-Lea Farms Ltd in Binbrook.

Mornings on every farm are always a wonderful experience, and they get even better once all the chores are done :)

ARE YOU A FIRST TIME HOME BUYER?Take advantage of our 25% FTHB discount on your home insurance. OR combine with a $5000 ...
06/09/2026

ARE YOU A FIRST TIME HOME BUYER?

Take advantage of our 25% FTHB discount on your home insurance.

OR combine with a $5000 Deductible and save over 50%

LEARN MORE https://loom.ly/fbCMdCc

COMMUNITY SPONSORErie Mutual is happy to support the arts within our community. Jean Furlong (left), of the Dunnville Co...
06/05/2026

COMMUNITY SPONSOR

Erie Mutual is happy to support the arts within our community.

Jean Furlong (left), of the Dunnville Community Theatre, accepts a sponsorship cheque from Samarth Patel & Lauren Horton

If you have the opportunity to check out a production this month by the Dunnville Community Theatre, please do - "Hilda's Yard" by Norm Foster will be presented on various dates/times in June (dinner & show or show only). Tickets available at Art Service in Dunnville or online at dct73.com

Ever have your Check Engine light result in some serious damage?Your engine light is triggered by the car's computer det...
06/04/2026

Ever have your Check Engine light result in some serious damage?

Your engine light is triggered by the car's computer detecting a fault in the engine or emissions system. It could be caused by anything from a loose gas cap to a failing sensor or a more serious engine misfire.

We recommend you have it checked.

Please welcome Melissa!Melissa joined our staff last week and had a very full week of training with her fellow employees...
06/01/2026

Please welcome Melissa!

Melissa joined our staff last week and had a very full week of training with her fellow employees in the office. She has over 10 years of insurance experience, and we are very happy to have her join Team Erie.

Please say "hi" to our newest hire if you stop by the office.

Haldimand Youth Soccer is kicking off the season! We're happy to support these young athletes and wish them a wonderful ...
05/27/2026

Haldimand Youth Soccer is kicking off the season!

We're happy to support these young athletes and wish them a wonderful season full of fun, laughter, and sportsmanship.

Looking great, Sawyer!

TUESDAY TESTIMONIALPrompt service, with answers to all of your insurance questions ... that's what we're all about! Want...
05/26/2026

TUESDAY TESTIMONIAL

Prompt service, with answers to all of your insurance questions ... that's what we're all about!

Want an easy insurance experience, without the stress and hassle? Give us a call!

Address

711 Main Street East
Dunnville, ON
N1A2W5

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm

Telephone

+18002636484

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Erie Mutual Insurance posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Erie Mutual Insurance:

Share